Yeah the OT had that old and busted look,
The PT has all the New hotness!
Give me Old and Busted any day of the week - so bob is trying to get the old busted hotness and I think he has more or less got it
You missed out on troops that is an absolute classic and needs to be put into this edit
I still think it should be the SD that is grayed out, have the red stripe coloured a dark blue at least to show that they are changing
Actually I think his idea is sound, not the shopping part obviously but the amount of people down there does look visually interesting and has potential
looks much better... why they originally went with that maroon colored outfit with purplypink skin is quite beyond my capacity.
The Golden Idol said:
I'm skeptical about this idea. I don't think the audience should know that Vader turns good at this point, I feel like switching their sabers would spoil the surprise of his redemption.
Think of it this way, Luke is about to replace his father at the Emperors side so it makes sense that he is to be slain by a sith weapon.
chyron8472 said:
RoccondilRinon said:
I always thought he shouted "NEVER!"
So did I.
ie.:
Vader: Give yourself to the Dark Side. It is the only way you can save your friends. Yes, your thoughts betray you. Your feelings for them are strong. Especially for... sister. So, you have a twin sister. Obi-Wan was wise to hide her from me. Now his failure is complete. If you will not turn to the dark side, then perhaps she will.Luke: NEVER!
I always thought he said Father as in a warning, in that he had no wish to stab his father in the back and give him a fair chance to turn back to the light side of the force.
I think its just the lack of uniformity of the smaller craft that sticks out for me
The lighting around the walkway into the shuttle is the worst part it is completely off compared to the rest of the composition of the shot, the only way I can justify it is if there is a REALLY bright light on the underside of the nose of the tyderium.
I always loved and hated that matte painting, the inconsistancy between the painting and the live action really sticks out and yet I love the painting (although It should have a lot more activity in it ( just think of the hanger bay in TPM with the N1's stacked 1 on top of the other) not to mention how the hell the Tyderium manages to get out of there with out hitting anything is beyond me
I think the rumble would work really well there as it is tapping to luke's emotion!
Don't knock it till someone has tried it guys it could work
I still don't have the balls to watch it once!!!
its bad enough I've seen the PT why put myself through the torture of seeing the HS (now does that stand for holiday special or horse shit???? .....or possibly both!)
How about using the force push noise to show look pushed him to the floor with the force in his anger?
What's wrong with leaving it as is LOL
this is supposed to be from a galaxy far away not from the city 1 state over!!!
Especially if you go with the Hologram idea mentioned earlier
I watched TPM last night all the way through for the first time in years
last time I watched it I just switched my brain off, sat back and enjoyed.
now........
because of you lot..........
I sat there last night cringing constantly, just wanting to rip it to shreads and reform it into something... ANYTHING... that is better than what we got!!!
....
the worst part is I'm watching AotC tonight I may just have to hang myself!!!!! lol
personally I loved the new SW logo I had a bit of a "What the..." moment when I saw it LOL
I like it on the big ship, i'm not sold on the jedi fighters though!
Darth Solo said:
Sorry folks, but can we take the Jedi talk to the wishlist thread so as not to destract from the current edit.
Has been said many times i know
Ditto on the PT talk guys!!!
bobgarcia74 said:
Throw in the "I Hate You" line as Obi wan is about to walk away there is a reaction form Obi that I think might fit in nicely
lets face it it R2 is turned into a slapstick character with his "little action scene" at the beginning of the movie & I don't think there is a fan editor out there that has kept it in their edit, Zod knows It would be the first thing to go if I had the talent to do one of my own
http://www.youtube.com/user/BobGarcia1974#p/u/10/gQQ1OdSEhrE
;-)
RoccondilRinon said:
I was under the impression he'd already heard of it.
He probably does but he doesn't talk about it because he wants you to buy the original so he gets royalties from it, he has nothing to gain from promoting a fan edit
Rogue Leader did a pretty sweet mock up on facebook
