Ffs, why does everything in this trilogy have to tie back to the Originals? Anyway, leaving the thread. Enjoy your spoilers, everyone!
Upon seeing those pictures, I remembered that this is a spoiler thread. I like small teaser like this, but I don’t want to have anything major spoiled, like a surprise appearance of an old character, or just the general plot. I take my best option is to leave this thread?
Star Wars has a pretty nice logo when stacked. The thing is, it’s got a hexagonal shape, so when you unstack it, it just looks like two awkward trapezoids. Anybody got some idea how to fix this?
It doesn’t really matter if the story needs to be told so long as the end result is entertaining (that is, unless it’s one of the cases where knowing more takes too much mystery away, but this isn’t one of them). TPM may not be as relevant to the story as AotC, but it sure as hell is more entertaining.
Why complain about the flawless CG Leia rather than the admirable, but could use improvement CG Tarkin?
Leia showing up at all was pure fan service, and really makes no sense if you think about it. What was a senator doing at the Attack in Scariff? Strategically speaking all she was was a liability. If she was captured, Alderaan would be proven guilty of rebellion. She wasn’t fighting nor did she have any expertise, and the plan was to escape via the big ship (as per Raddus’s orders) not the freighter. Why is she there?
Or, you know, they put her there for continuity?
Either it hasn’t been revealed because they’re gonna move it to earlier in the timeline, or this show is gonna run alongside Episodes VII and VIII in the chronology.
You people make me sick.
I guess that makes sense.
How you feel about RotS probably depends a lot on how much you care about story versus execution. RotS because I’m just glad to see the story unfold, even if it’s not perfect. Some people find it’s poor execution more offensive because it’s a more important episode, but I just like because it’s important.
What if the shapeshifter in Attack of the Clones, y’know… shapeshifted?
How did Anakin know that was her? And I wonder if that’d be confusing if you didn’t know about it going in.
“Master, the batteries in your Wii remote are low.”
Guys, can we get the conversation back on track please? Just agree to disagree.
Looks like an average animated TV show for 5 year olds. I’ll pass.
Oh, come on. It’s at least for 7 year olds.
I am getting major Titan A.E. vibes, which isn’t good or bad.
I certainly don’t get that vibe, which is a shame 'cause I really like that movie. Speaking of which…
Oh, I agree! That looks pretty good! I found it ironic that Titan A.E. caught some flak for doing the same when anime has been blending the two since Lensman in 1984.
The CGI was not made to blend in. It was not cel-shaded or anything. It was like Time Jam’s CGI.
Thank god he has a personality!!! After Rebels, I had pretty low expectations. This show looks less bland.
Also, Filoni won’t be showrunner for this show, as he’s busy with TCW. He’ll be giving advice, though.
Be my guest. I dare you to restore the Luke and Biggs scene. That’s the one distorted scene I really want restored.
D’Qar should have dragon blood trees like in the concept art to make it more unique.
You know how Hayden Christensen looks nothing like Jake Lloyd? Well you know does (aside from Leo DiCaprio, who turned down the part)? John Simm. I wonder if he can do an american accent.
It’s at least interesting. Granted I’d seen blue Maul before on the cover for TPM OST.
Well done.
Ironically, this is a rather cringey title.
Is there a way to make it seem like Anakin and Padme have secretly been smashing for a while before AotC?
Gross!! They’re barely 14 before AOTC!
Anakin, the youngest of the two, is 20 in AOTC. If you remove the “no contact in 10 years” bit, they could have been fucking for as many as four years without it being “gross” or damaging
Actually, he’s 19, the same age Luke and Rey were when they started their journeys.
Outbound Flight has the right idea.
Great! I’ll get right to updating my more complex SW animation spreadsheet, which has a section for the Smudger films based directly on yours.
I’ve had one for my colleagues for the last few years, I’ve refined it now with as much info as I can glean about the current plan for the movies, from all of Smudger’s previous comments on Fanedit forums and here. It aims to give as much info as possible - original order, chronological, arcs, quality, inclusion in Smudger’s movies and proposed movies, and a hybrid ordering for if you want to watch the movies alongside the episodes not included.
Image defaulting to hybrid order (what you were asking for above) here: https://imgur.com/a/kKpdar1
Or you can play around with the list via filters here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wUlU_myy1Jgn2S59_fvuddCGpjQw3KTmav79lr0KeyI/edit?usp=sharing
Edit: Smudger, I’d welcome your input if any of that’s inaccurate!
Please update for V, now that it’s out. Also, you should change the period in the title to a question mark.
Marketing red herring without a doubt.