This user has been banned.
Reread my first post. ANH is above ROTS.
ROTS is much more emotionally authentic than TFA.
ROTS earned my feelings, while TFA felt like it was telling me how to feel without really deserving my emotion or having the pathos to back it up.
whoops
- The Empire Strikes Back
- A New Hope
- The Force Awakens
- Return of the Jedi
- Revenge of the Sith
- The Phantom Menace
- Attack of the Clones
1 and 2 don’t need an explanation, it’s pretty much a consensus. I’ve seen TFA twice now and I enjoyed it much more the second time. I rewatched RotJ and while I still love it, I have to admit that I think TFA is a better movie. Despite the similarities to ANH that have been discussed over and over again, I think it breathes new life into the franchise and has been the most engaging movie since Empire*.
All of the prequels are turds, but RotS is the most polished turd.
Deja vu.
Go back to 4chan please.
- The Empire Strikes Back
- A New Hope
- The Force Awakens
- Return of the Jedi
- Revenge of the Sith
- The Phantom Menace
- Attack of the Clones
1 and 2 don’t need an explanation, it’s pretty much a consensus. I’ve seen TFA twice now and I enjoyed it much more the second time. I rewatched RotJ and while I still love it, I have to admit that I think TFA is a better movie. Despite the similarities to ANH that have been discussed over and over again, I think it breathes new life into the franchise and has been the most engaging movie since Empire*.
All of the prequels are turds, but RotS is the most polished turd.
Deja vu.
Go back to 4chan.
flop of the century
Eh, I can’t post images.
I think the forum has a “disallow images posted by anyone rating any prequel movie over any ot movie” filter.
[snarky comment]
Eh, I can’t post images.
How does one post images with this new layout?
- Star Wars
- Revenge of The Sith
- The Empire Strikes Back
- Attack of The Clones/The Phantom Menace/Return of The Jedi(with Victory Celebration)
- Return of The Jedi sans Victory Celebration
- The Special Edition OT
- The Force Awakens
Have you even seen TFA or do you just disregard it because Lucas wasn’t involved?
I just found it to be a completely imagination-free uninspired cash grab.
And ROTS isn’t?
No?
It’s barely a film. It’s a bunch of cutscenes.
An accurate review of tfa
You are so detached from reality I’m honestly having a hard time figuring out if you believe anything you say or if you are trolling. ROTS contains almost no sets, it’s all greenscreen and computer animation. Half the movie is nothing but a video game.
I don’t care how much you hate TFA, it is nothing like ROTS in that regard.
NONE of that is objectively worse than using physical sets and props. I don’t care how much you hate the PT, TFA was a rushed together piece of incoherent nonsense.
I will be… I Will Be.
It’s barely a film. It’s a bunch of cutscenes, underacting and overacting, and lazy connect-the-dots who-could-possibly-care.
But if you really enjoy Yoda professing his love to Chewbacca, well more power to you I guess.
Good relations with George Lucas, I have.
On the contrary, he’d have to be easily pleased to rank ROTS above TESB.
OR I just find it to be the better film.
- Star Wars
- Revenge of The Sith
- The Empire Strikes Back
- Attack of The Clones/The Phantom Menace/Return of The Jedi(with Victory Celebration)
- Return of The Jedi sans Victory Celebration
- The Special Edition OT
- The Force Awakens
Have you even seen TFA or do you just disregard it because Lucas wasn’t involved?
I just found it to be a complety imagination-free unispired cash grab.
Feel free to “objectively” disprove my statement.I can’t disprove how you feel, regardless of how crazy I think your feelings and rankings are.
With that said, ROTS has been scientifically proven to be a terrible film.
I would like to see a peer reviewed study on the subject.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0TGcvtzjUs
and then this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hD7xZFLhTq8
You’re welcome.
CinemaSins?
How embarrassing…
Also, I was engaging in ‘banter’ with Ric, I am aware that there are plenty of critisisms of ROTS online. (Plinkett etc)
No problem. Just Google “ROTS everyone but me.”
I did that. Now what?
originaltrilogy.com/post/id/792288
So did the script suck or were you wrong?
I think you can extrapolate the answer from my opinion of the film.
- Star Wars
- Revenge of The Sith
- The Empire Strikes Back
- Attack of The Clones/The Phantom Menace/Return of The Jedi(with Victory Celebration)
- Return of The Jedi sans Victory Celebration
- The Special Edition OT
- The Force Awakens
Have you even seen TFA or do you just disregard it because Lucas wasn’t involved?
I just found it to be a complety imagination-free unispired cash grab.
Feel free to “objectively” disprove my statement.I can’t disprove how you feel, regardless of how crazy I think your feelings and rankings are.
With that said, ROTS has been scientifically proven to be a terrible film.
I would like to see a peer reviewed study on the subject.
- Star Wars
- Revenge of The Sith
- The Empire Strikes Back
- Attack of The Clones/The Phantom Menace/Return of The Jedi(with Victory Celebration)
- Return of The Jedi sans Victory Celebration
- The Special Edition OT
- The Force Awakens
Have you even seen TFA or do you just disregard it because Lucas wasn’t involved?
I just found it to be a completely imagination-free uninspired cash grab.
Feel free to “objectively” disprove my statement.
whoops
Ranking a PT film over ESB. Ballsy.
ESB is extremely overrated IMO. It’s extremely good mind you, just not as good as Lucas’s masterful opening and closings of his saga.
this will be a day long remembered
Yeah, I was just don’t know if it is in circulation on the internet yet, which is why i asked.
Would anyone be interested in a DVD version of the 24 minute shorter IMAX cut of Apollo 13?
It’s 1 hour and 54 minutes long and is in the 1:66.1 aspect ratio.
I’ll upload it if people want it.
Just wanted to say again that you guys are amazing. I'm more exited for this than for TFA.