kane1138

No problem. You can't all be as sharp as me.

I'm guessing if you remove s it will fix the link. Nice to see noobs fit in so well round here.

I have a Justop Media Player plugged into my TV and it normally causes me all kinds of grief with high bitrate MKVs.  But it plays all of Hal's 1080p edits with no problems.

Looking good.

jedimasterobiwan said:

only reason why i asked when next month it was coming out was because it was a long time since i posted on here

 Yeah,  it's been forever. Good to see you back. 

Done!

Not done yet. Hopefully this year.

So, there are some inconsistencies that will never be resolved. That must really mess with your OCD.

Awesome. I so enjoyed his persistent questions on other people's threads. Now he has his own thread......and it is one giant question! 

So, jedimasterobiwan...

Why don't you do your own edit? 

When will it exist?

When will it be released? 

If not, why not?

Ady announced a while ago (on FB?) that he would work on all remaining movies (after ESB) as one large project. 

Hal 9000 said:

kk650 said:

Adywan did a great job with that but I can't use it for my own releases because however good it is, its never been part of the official releases.

Just for the record, Adywan's version of the ESB Emperor scene isn't available on its own somewhere, is it?

No. At least, not outside the highly compressed world of YouTube.

I believe he is working to fix consistency issues, from shot to shot. They used a number of different looking suits/puppets during filming.

Waiting for the inevitable question...

jedimasterobiwan said:

hal 9000 i don't have any peers for your edit can you please help?

 Best question of the year so far.

jedimasterobiwan - have you heard of a little fan edit called The Empire Strikes Back Revisited? You should really check it out. It's great.

jedimasterobiwan will be pleased.

jedimasterobiwan said:

hal9000 when is your the approaching storm v.3 and labyrinth of evil v.3 expected to come out?

jedimasterobiwan said:

so in two weeks approaching storm v.3 should be up?

jedimasterobiwan said:

how far a long is approaching storm v3 coming?

Impatient, aren't ya. It'll be done when it is done. These things take time. Constantly asking for updates isn't going to get it done any quicker. 

I think your voice fits pretty well, HAL.

Welcome to 2015, Marty.

adywan said:

asterisk8 said:

How's this for an idea? I'll donate $100 to adywan if you promise to stop pointing out things that need fixing in TESB. Seriously.

 So, are you going to accept this challenge, Ronster? ;)

 Apparently not.

Chris Bores said:

I always had a feeling, but was reluctant to believe  Lucas was a money grubbing scumbag who cared nothing about Star Wars and only appreciated it for the money it has garnered him, but this is the last nail the coffin.

That's a little harsh.  Don't forget that Lucas is a "money grabbing scumbag" who donates more money to charitable causes than you will probably ever see in your lifetime.

The SE ending of ROTJ provides a massive change.  We see celebrations on various planets; including Coruscant, during which we are led to believe that the Empire has fallen.

In the GOUT, we merely see a small celebration on the moon of Endor.  There is no reason to believe the Empire has been completely overthrown. For all we know, someone could have simply stepped into Palpatine's shoes and taken control of the remaining fleet.

EP VII could very well see a continuation of the Empire (in some form), and therefore be a follow-up to the GOUT, rather than the SE.

rpvee said:

Vader scene (low quality): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0PgF_cfrhM

It's James Earl Jones, but something sounds different...

He just sounds so.....old.

It actually may have been better if they had used a young-JEJ sound-a-like, rather than JEJ himself.  There are some amazing Vader impersonators out there.

It is illogical.

Every publicly released version of every film should be made available.  Simples.