haraldo23

Good news!

It's on the 1st page -

Dagobah:

   1. Fixing bad colouring job on R2's panels in space.
   2. Stabilizing the readout on the R2 translation screen.
   3. Adding visible atmosphere as the X-Wing gets close to Dagobah.
   4. Restoring "You're lucky you don't taste very good" line. ...

BTW, will you leave the scene where Anakin kills those kids?

I know you said you

-Removed the younglings dialogue.

But how about that whole scene?

Then again - don't get me wrong - it's ok if it stays, I'm just asking. :)

nline4 said:

Midichlorians are not important because they are not important to the OT story

Exactly!

I love everything Bob has done so far, so it's cool.

DuTwan said:

Nooooo lightsaber colours must remain blue, green and red. Bob has only just fixed Mace's. If he included orange etc then changin mace's was pointless since its the rainbow of colours again.

Agreed. However, if we had to vote I would go for blue and red only (in PT), so that later the green one in ROTJ has some meaning to it. 

bobgarcia74 said:

Taking rotten old lemons, and making sweet a$$ lemon-aid.

Much better now.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqhjKJXhVfk

 

Watching this I got the exact same feeling that I had back in 2004 when I 1st saw the trailer for "Revenge of the Sith" and got all excited and couldn't stop smiling like some kind of imbecile. XD

Would you consider using only blue lightsabers for your edit, Bob?

And another question - would you consider removing those guys in the background as shown in these mock-ups (right click->view image).

They get killed in, like, 2 seconds, so they're pretty useless and it would make Mace seem more confident, like he's pretty sure he can take on Palpatine on his own.

And I believe Vaderous is the author of these mock-ups.

Happy Birthday, Adywan!

ThrowgnCpr said:

In the end though, its Bob's edit, and whatever he wants he should go with... I've been thoroughly impressed with the things he has done so far.

Agreed!

vaderios said:

What exactly was good on him? what was his purpose? Or maybe it had in his face a big word "COOL FACTOR"

-Angel

Yes, I admit - he looks great and that's the reason I like him.

Nothing in TPM looked as cool as Darth Maul,  so I think he should stay the way he looks right now.

Darth Maul was the only good thing about TPM. The way he looks should not be changed IMHO.

Nice! He looks more menacing.

No no no no. You guys misunderstood me. What I meant to say with that whole "Anakin-to-Vader transformation" was - 

that scene where those robots transform Anakin into Darth Vader, not the whole emotional converting process through the trilogy (that pretty much sucked).

I was just talking about that one scene at the end of ROTS. It's a cool scene which I was really looking forward to see 5 years ago and I'm still very excited about it when I see it.  And I think  that it should stay and should not be removed.

The whole Anakin-to-Vader transformation was one of the coolest things about PT. If you remove that then there's not much to anticipate. It's a different trilogy and I think it needs it's own ending.

This whole lightsaber thing you guys just brought up is way too much.

It's an interesting idea, but if it's not done correctly then this edit could fail and I don't want that to happen because I'm really looking forward to this one.

bobgarcia74 said:

ok then its vote time

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZHXwPWBirw
red
vs
white
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GYxhmVgJKQA

Yeah, I'm leaning toward white now.

White looks better, I think. But maybe you should put a little bit of yellow in there, so that it looks more like electricity or something like that.

It feels a bit unfinished when it's only white.

Either way - I choose white.

bobgarcia74 said:

An update. Last one for awhile. Gonna be buckling down and getting as much of this done as possible. Took a few days break and ready to get back too it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZHXwPWBirw

Wow! That is truly remarkable!

You're doing an amazing job.

This guy is really annoying...

Dude I can't get a grin of my face!

You fudging rock! This is beautiful!

vaderios said:

-Angel

DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUDE! AWESOME!

|m||>.<|m|

Bingowings said:

... but we are still left with a Fett who needn't have been there (a bounty hunter hiring a bounty hunter seems a bit daft).

Maybe he wanted to keep a low profile but still earn some money, so he hired someone else to do his job. It would seem logical for him not doing the dirty work.

SomethingStarWarsRelated said:

Here's my attempt at the speeder chase from AOTC:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvBR0tcqBOI

Sorry, Bingowings, I tried making it Anakin that jumps out the window instead...but I just couln't do enough with the footage to make it work...maybe some day Adywan can pull it off... ;)

WOW! That's awesome!

Actually, this might sound kind of weird (and my spelling isn't that great, so it's hard for me to explain), but Adywan has put that little Star Wars Kid back into me again. I used to be a pretty big fan of Star Wars, but then that whole  "Star Wars feeling" faded away. You know that feeling when you want to be a part of that universe and you just can't get enough of it, and everything about it seems great and unique? I don't really know why, but I lost it. And it wasn't because of the Prequels or Special Editions, or stuff like that.

But now, after I saw ANH:R, that feeling is back! I want to be a part of that universe again and I can't wait to see TESB:R (when it's finished of course). It's like watching those movies for the first time AGAIN. 

It's fantastic!

I have a question -

Would you consider doing something like this for your edit -

http://fc07.deviantart.net/fs49/f/2009/174/d/d/SW3___ROTS_Recolor_01_by_SWRemixed.jpg

?