haraldo23

Ok, if we are letting it all out then -

In ANH C3PO is kind of an asshole. He clearly did not give a fudge about R2 when Luke was taking him home together with that other droid. After all they've been through he just looked back at R2 and didn't say ANYTHING, he just looked away. Like, "Sucks to be you, bro! I guess I'm lucky!".

You can say, "But, hey, when that red droid broke down C3PO recommended to take R2 instead!", but that's bullcrap! He should have said "I ain't going anywhere with my techno-friend!" as soon as Uncle Owen decided to take him.

But instead - he had a chance to flee from Jawas and he took it and left his best friend behind - alone in a desert, kidnapped by a bunch of weird little Sidiouses.

What a douche!

But then later he tries to give an impression that he's friends with R2 - he tells Luke how they both survived Clone Wars and then he's worried about R2 not coming back from the space fight over Yavin... It doesn't make any sense!

It's not exactly a big deal and I could come up with my own explanation why C3PO didn't act when he had to, but it's just something to consider.

Radi0n said:

haraldo23 said:

How The Empire Strikes Back Should Have Ended

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6L8b1zPE0-Y

This would make a great ESB:R special feature, if the guys at HISHE would approve :)

Those guys are down for anything. One guy asked them if he could use their Spider-Man 3 HISHE for another video and they let him. So, it wouldn't hurt to ask them.

And besides - if they are Star Wars fans and if they are aware of ANH:R - it shouldn't be a problem. Everyone I know (from those who have seen ANH:R) has an enormous respect for Adywan and his Revisited series.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6L8b1zPE0-Y

vaderios said:

So if the consistency was to make all the saga with pointy edges you would be happy? No?

Ok i guess consistency with the OT.... right?

 

-Angel

For me, it doesn't matter really. I'd just like to see consistency. For example, if Adywan made rounded tips for sabers in ANH then I would like to see them stay that way throughout the Revisited series.

And if Bob decides to keep pointy tips in this edit, then it would be great to have pointy tips in all of his Star Wars edits.

That is the way I see it.

But don't get me wrong, I understand it's not easy to do that. So it's not a big deal if they keep changing.

Yeah, man, it's just you.

I took a look at it again and it looks sweet. Much better than the original.

mrbenja0618 said:

Lucas just needed to pick a flavor and stick with it.... I'm honestly fine with pointy or not... BUT PICK ONE AND STAY CONSISTENT!

Agreed. That would be very nice.

Another thing in ANH (and OT in general) is - you can hear that stormtroopers' armor is made out of plastic. Every time they move or run - you can hear plastic sounds. And it sounds kind of fake. Maybe it's possible to remove those sounds or change them somehow.

Jaitea said:

I was mucking about with the Death Star's lift door shot...but I diverted to when the gang arrive in the detention block...and added some blood spatters....like suggested a while ago....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-iSlkEXna2U

...also I dont know if it has been mentioned before but is the 'Where are you taking that thing?' guy the same actor when he gets shot?

J

Loving the blood!

Come on, man. XD I'm just messing around.

Nah, it's cool, I'm just gonna print them out at my place... Everyone is invited! XD

vaderios said:

 

-Angel

Dude! I love these! Seriously! Fudging awesome! I could literally have sex with these images. It's just mind blowing to even imagine how something like this would look in motion. Great work, man! Inspiring stuff...

Yeah, I noticed that too! Especially in the scene where Palpatine reveals his true identity to Anakin. When Anakin ignites his saber there's a close-up of Palpatine with a saber in his face and you can clearly see it has a pointy tip.

You could just start the movie off with that space battle perhaps. Make it seem like it's going on throughout the movie.... I don't know. Haven't seen TPM for about 2 years.

They look very crisp is what I wanted to say. Maybe too crisp.

Anyway, I just wanted to say that it would be very cool if the color wouldn't change throughout the series. :)

So I was watching ROTS again and I noticed how the blue lightsabers look very dark, not like in TPM, AOTC or even in the OT.

Maybe it's because those digital sets were pretty dark, but if you look at the promotional pictures you can see that they are very different than they were in the movie -

And this is a shot form the movie -

It's not a big issue for me, except that in ROTS they look a bit cartoon'ish. It would be cool to have a constant color throughout the series.

But what do you guys think? And, most importantly, what are Bob's thoughts about this?

TV's Frink said:

Of course, there are plenty of people who didn't notice the 2004 screwed up colors, the lightsaber problems, the sound issues, and on and on...

Exactly! There are plenty of people who didn't... buy/watch the 2004 special edition.

If you look at OT - all of the scenes usually center around the main characters. So making an additional scene with Boba would look... well, not very OT.

bobgarcia74 said:

Just a quick pic of what I was mentioning in the last post. Still more work to do tho. But that Sheild just sells the whole scene IMHO.

Dude!!! Awesome!!! XD

I say we go Rambo on ROTJ and put some serious carnage in there. XD

I like the idea of removing Boba Fett from ROTJ COMPLETELY.

Everybody knows him  as a character from ESB anyway... plus, he seriously went out like a punk.

Bingowings said:

... the films should look like they are taking place in the same universe but in a different time period.

Agreed.

Harmy said:

 

I love how angry he looks! XD Reminds me of Honey Badger -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c81bcjyfn6U

Just re-watched ROTJ and I have to say that there are bunch stuff that I don't really like. I know we have discussed this before, but - Ewoks vs. Empire need some blood. Those little creatures are pwning StormTroopers left and right and it's just way too friendly.

(Just a mock-up. It doesn't need to be this over-the-top XD)

Also, the whole space action scene at the end -  I enjoyed it, but I don't get it. If The Empire is raping the whole damn GALAXY, then how come there's only dozens of rebellion fighters?

You would think that there would be hundreds of volunteers, throughout the galaxy, excited to kick some Empire ass, don't you think?

It needs to be more crowded. Maybe not like ROTS, but it would be great to have at least couple of more ships.

Oh and it's kind of funny how C3PO in ANH says he's not much a story teller, but in this movie... well,  it looks like ewoks are having an awesome time listening to him...

It's kind of weird to see a scene from the prequels and think about the original trilogy... 

Great job!