logo Sign In

fmalover

User Group
Members
Join date
21-Mar-2013
Last activity
15-Apr-2024
Posts
940

Post History

Post
#1494241
Topic
Great movies you hate.
Time

I don’t hate this movie at all, just don’t care about it, Alfonso Cuarón’s Children of Men.

Seriously, everywhere I look the movie has been praised to the heavens as a watershed in movie history and how prescient it turned out to be and all the subtle visual cues, and at first I wondered if I was watching it wrong, and have rewatched it quite a few times but it still doesn’t do anything for me. I sincerely don’t care about the plot, the characters, the cinematography or anything, it’s just a flat affect for me. I still don’t get what’s so great about this movie, and I’ve actually enjoyed Cuarón’s other movies.

Then again, a guy I know who is a huge fan of CoM once told that if I don’t like the movie for any reason then that’s cool.

Post
#1491906
Topic
If you need to B*tch about something... this is the place
Time

The way I see it, all countries are shady.

I live in Venezuela, a country that has ‘freed’ itself from the American Empire, and frankly the state-run socialist government I’ve experienced for the past 23 years is just as bad as the rampant capitalism of the US, maybe even worse.

Remember that scene in The Mandalorian where Werner Herzog’s character questions whether the Rebellion’s toppling of the Empire has actually accomplished anything? That’s pretty much how I feel right now, as this government has trampled on my every dream and aspiration. I sincerely hope sooner rather than later I can finally leave this country and never return nor hear about it ever again.

You can say I have grown past the common trope in works of fiction about the ‘Evil Empire’ that must be taken down, as my life experiences have taught me that the reality is a lot more complicated.

Post
#1491455
Topic
Unpopular Opinion Thread
Time

What I miss the most about the old EU is that the writers had genuine freedom to let their imagination run wild, and even wrote stories that were completely disconnected from the movies despite taking place during the same time period. I remember one story about a Rebel unit having a skirmish with Imperial forces far away from the Battle of Endor, and the characters had never had any interaction with the main characters. There’s also the character of Darca Nyl, a human with no Force sensitivity who nevertheless learned to wield a lightsaber so he could properly duel the Dark Jedi who murdered his family.

Under Disney all the stories seem obsessed with linking everything with the main saga, and even when they are unrelated to the main saga, sooner or later they start shoehorning the main saga into the plot (The Mandalorian, anyone?).

Post
#1488787
Topic
Unpopular Opinion Thread
Time

Superweapon VII said:

If Anakin and Padme had been close in age, I could buy their romance as authentic (well, more authentic, anyway). As-is, it feels like Anakin, suffering separation anxiety from his mother, latched onto the closest friendly female to ease the pain of his loss. That, combined with his unhealthy fixation on Padme in the years between TPM & AOTC — a girl he’d only known briefly — leave me with the impression that he wasn’t truly in love with her; he was only obsessed with this surrogate maternal figure.

You just reminded me of that scene in the movie Analyze This in which Dr. Sobel explains the Oedipus complex, to which Paul Vitti reacts by asking “Are you saying I wanted to fuck my mom?”

Post
#1488633
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

Superweapon VII said:

fmalover said:

Superweapon VII said:

Villeneuve’s Dune is not an improvement on Lynch’s version. For everything it does better, there’s a roughly equal amount it does worse. Quality-wise, the two pretty much balance out. Though I’ll always revisit Lynch’s film; I doubt I’ll watch Villeneuve’s again, even after Part Two comes out.

What bothers me the most is how many people are hailing it as the definitive Dune adaptation.

I’m sorry, but if there’s one thing the 1984 has over Villeneuve’s is that it fully embraced the book’s inherent weirdness, whereas Villeneuve seems ashamed of it and we’re left with a very bland movie.

I present the Jamis fight as Exhibit A for why the movie fell flat for me. In the source material, Paul sheds tears after killing Jamis. In this movie, he hardly seems phased by it at all.

I’d seen three of Villeneuve’s films beforehand — Maelstrom, Arrival, and Blade Runner 2049 — and all three are emotionally and visually gloomy. That style may suit the world of Blade Runner, but I always envisioned the Dune universe as a more vibrant, resonant setting.

Villeneuve’s customary choice of a desaturated colour palette only adds to the lifeless look of the movie.

Post
#1488513
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

Superweapon VII said:

Villeneuve’s Dune is not an improvement on Lynch’s version. For everything it does better, there’s a roughly equal amount it does worse. Quality-wise, the two pretty much balance out. Though I’ll always revisit Lynch’s film; I doubt I’ll watch Villeneuve’s again, even after Part Two comes out.

What bothers me the most is how many people are hailing it as the definitive Dune adaptation.

I’m sorry, but if there’s one thing the 1984 has over Villeneuve’s is that it fully embraced the book’s inherent weirdness, whereas Villeneuve seems ashamed of it and we’re left with a very bland movie.

Post
#1484108
Topic
Dune - Denis Villeneuve
Time

jedi_bendu said:

fmalover said:

In the book the Emperor is described as being in his early seventies yet looks no older than 35.

Yeah, I genuinely think this is just an unreasonable casting expectation. Personally I’m glad Denis/the casting director is ignoring this and just focusing on who is the best actor to bring the right qualities to the role.

Why is it unreasonable?

We’ve had plenty of actors in their mid twenties playing beings who are centuries or millennia old (vampires, LOTR elves, etc), so this wouldn’t be much of a stretch.

I will never watch the Dune adaptation I want, that is a fact.

Post
#1484097
Topic
Dune - Denis Villeneuve
Time

In the book the Emperor is described as being in his early seventies yet looks no older than 35.

I hoped Villeneuve would finally cast an actor in his late thirties to early forties or least one who looks deceptively young (Jared Leto comes to mind, as he’s 50 years old but can easily pass for a much younger man) so we could have a book-accurate Emperor Shaddam IV. Alas, Villeneuve has chosen to continue the tradition of casting much older actors in the role.

IMO Walken would’ve been much better suited to play Count Fenring.