logo Sign In

fishmanlee

User Group
Members
Join date
20-May-2009
Last activity
30-May-2025
Posts
1,765

Post History

Post
#377063
Topic
Info & Ideas: ESB and ROTJ Wishlist
Time
rcb said:
fishmanlee said:

well the everybody in star wars isnt very smart if they cant figure out anakin and padme are married....

 

 obi-wan did, n i think yoda had a hunch.

 

 i mean like alot of the senate people or something

i mean there sleeping in the same room/bed! "oh senatoor i gotta protect youu!"

and its not like there isnt paparazzi in a galaxy far far away..

Post
#377043
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time
Bingowings said:
SomethingStarWarsRelated said:
Bingowings said:

I like the general idea SSWR but I still think it's too much information.

We know from Leia in ROTJ she dies when she is very young, my earliest memories are from when I was about two but they are very vague so shifting it up to about three years later sort of makes sense.

If this was done as a time shifting montage her niece could be Leia (though we don't know that at the time) if she doesn't turn up in a reworked Episode II.

The explanation that Leia gives could act as a explanation of the scene we see in a reworked ROTS.

Thanks for the feedback, Bingo. Are you saying one of Padme's nieces (from AOTC deleted scene or ROTS funeral scene) could possibly be mis-interpreted (to our advantage) as Liea in the OT? So once ROTJ rolls around we finally find out about the Luke/Liea relationship? Hmmm...this is not something I've ever heard before.

I personally don't like the time shifting montage idea...not very Star Wars-y...plus (and I think we feel the same way on this) we don't won't to give away too much information...we don't want to spell everything out.

Did you really feel the dialouge I came up with spelled everything out too much? I figured we have to kill off Padme somehow...or make it obvious she's not gonna make it much longer. She's an important character after all...

...but then again the same could be said for Yoda...and I am definantly against having it spelled out to us that Yoda stays on Dagobah until ESB. My 2 cents.  :P

It wasn't very Star Wars to leap around time and space at the end of a film until 1997, the SE celebration scenes are exactly that only over a shorter time span.

 

i guess the probe droid scene in ESB wasnt very Star Wars...

 

Post
#375414
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time
Bingowings said:

I'm surprised that nobody has brought this up yet (maybe someone has but this is post 2565) but as far as I can make out (other than battledroids which don't count) TPM is the only Star Wars film where no named character loses a hand.

This clearly needs to be sorted out.

So who in Episode One should get the hand chop (please not Ric Olié he'd never shut up about it)?

 

 i dont remember anyone losing a hand in ANH