fishmanlee

angel that mockup reminds me of super star wars/empire strikes back

GoodMusician said:

So uh...what if I said 

 

"Anyone want Lapti Nek/ Ewok Celebration sung by Joseph Williams in english and huttesse?"

i would say "GIMME GIMME GIMME!!!!"

an idea of mine in 4 words: Dinosaur-like-thingies Ewoks Endor ROTJ 

here is skyjedi2005's OP for refrence sluggo:

Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda said:

You know, there is a very good chance that when the Holiday Special comes out on Blu-Ray, it will be the only Lucas movie ever released in high quality in its original theatrical form.  Wouldn't THAT be ironic.

 Lucas will NOT release that EVER! (waves hand)

why?

im guessing they were edited to flow together unlike on tv? (you know how on tv when you get to a cliffhanger moment and the fade out for commercials?)

i can see john williams/george lucas/jesse harlin: "put some more unreleased music in that game just to drive GoodMusician insane!"

calle it the "compromise" edition

but "The Eagles are Coming" makes sense

they need more men....

Krakatoa said:

I was gonna refuse the 2004 set. But I got it as a gift, so, whaddya gonna do?

 stash it until everyone forgets then throw it out?

TFUII has some new music from the prequels:

"Security Recordings / It Cant Be":  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ancsVsi8UFA

"Be Mindful of Your Thoughts":  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7EBsTFzYe70

these are straight from the game

Mielr said:

fishmanlee said:

the 1997 re-releases werent that bad, it was the 1999+ DVD's and anti-OT Lucas that were

I think the 1997 re-releases were bad. There were parts of them that made my stomach turn.

 but they were the SE's back then, now in the 2004 they are the Original Trilogy.

Bingowings said:

That really does look cool and flows well with the sound (obviously it would need the reinstatement of the black bars during the Tantive explosion to be really effective).

I don't mean to be a git but is anyone actually suggesting doing an edit of SE with Superman music?

I thought the original idea was to have a Superman style opening in a SE?

 

the music was for the viewer to make the connection (in other words it was temporary), obviously to make it work someone would have to have a composer write similarly styled star wars music for the credits

the 1997 re-releases werent that bad, it was the 1999+ DVD's and anti-OT Lucas that were

give it 15 minutes if its not working by then i'll put it up to megaupload


or you can try here: http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRescorer#p/u/0/7AMGoOb5hbQ

third version:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7AMGoOb5hbQ

i took two of these ideas and tried them


Monroville said:

have it appear larger: "STAR WARS" should fill the screen ala BEN HUR title.

Also, you have that spot from 1:06 to 1:12 that has no music; maybe do a test where the high point ends on the blockade runner explosion.

Crygor64 said:

 

fishmanlee said:

heres another point: Adywan uses the "Less is more" approach, George does not

Doesn't matter. Changes are changes.

And Adywan surely does NOT use the less is more approach. Instead his idea of "improvement" is to add more tie-fighters, more AT-ATs, etc.

How does that help the story? How does that "improve" the original trilogy? It doesn't.

As a purist I know the OT is a product of its time. Its perfect in its imperfection. Adding more stuff only hurts these classic films.

 and he also removed several bad cg sequences, took out a certain amount of CG creatures and made han shoot first returned the obi-wan hut scene to its original edit and all of the changes he has made are justifiable, unlike george, why do we need a flying droid behind stormtroopers? why would there need to be those big lizard things? (can't remember its name)

heres another point: Adywan uses the "Less is more" approach, George does not

Monroville said:

Also, you have that spot from 1:06 to 1:12 that has no music; maybe do a test where the high point ends on the blockade runner explosion.

the reason i had a point with no music is because the video was based off of the opening of superman returns:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HyE1V6Ac49Q

changing music in a scene is one thing taking out a sound effect, thats something else

Akwat Kbrana said:

Maybe you should replace the howl with PT music.

 i take it your not a fan of post 1999 Star Wars JW?

i really think there should be NO howl

its better then the 2004 but it sounds too much like alfred molina in the beggining of ROTLA when he sees forristals corpse