fishmanlee

isnt that an image only post?

and still... i dont see how this ruins the "reveal" in official ROTS

how would that change his reaction in ROTS?

all it would be here is a vision

i just wish George Lucas had left the original score for the final battle of TPM intact...

anyways i would like it if it were just choir-less, its much better that way IMHO

......not really........ Jaws is mainly low lying "horror" and the music doesnt really "come up out of the water", where the star wars scores are more sparse but have more action and a fantasy-ish, superman is the closest to ESB but it has alot more "romantic" and beautiful (like with the fortress of solitude stuff) and Raiders is alot more rough and tumble action music, TOD is more energetic i believe doug adams the author of the "Music of the Lord of the Rings Films" book called it "Indiana Jones The Musical" or something like that...

more like the recording technology changed, there really isnt much difference between the PT style and the OT style

thats ben burtt talking!

fishmanlee said:

in the scene when leia kisses luke in ESB you could dub her with the lines of Lorraine in BTTF one commenting on how it seems like she is kissing her brother LOL

i cant believe no-one took notice of this comic gold

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WO1NY-yGjR8

Yoda Vs. Sidious with new score/music by Isaac Vail.

This is not the final version, the final version will have choir

whats so nice about it is that its original

EDIT: he probably wont be doing that for a while, because right now he is working on a prequel rescore for me right now, but its about 95% percent done right now so..

muddyknees2000 said:

Captain Antilles said:

Ghostbusters said:

I know you said you are not accepting any suggestions for the revamp edit, but I want to know your guy's opinions of these 3 ANH duel re-edits.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNCLEJhZhow&playnext_from=TL&videos=60fvniuCew0

This one I like the best. I like how it mixes the "Battle of Heros" at the beginning with the classic ANH theme at the end, this one feels the most fitting in ANH IMO.

I really like this one. I feel like the music fits it very well, which actually surprises me because I was always one of those people who thought that this particular scene sounded best left alone. Whoever cut this together did a nice job.

 Meh, sans music is still the way I likes it......

i prefer this music:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2m8NgBx1TGk&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL ;)

daneditor said:

Okay, cool. Had you thought the other transition was poor I'd have been worried.

the transition between the OT music and the TFU(II?) music is pretty "odd"

I always assumed it was sort of like a riding lawnmower,

perhaps the Lightsaber has a hand/heat sensor?

if it occurs in one cue/track, it does not qualify as a leitmotif I believe

Mace Windu joins the soundboards: http://starwars.com/games/playnow/soundboards/#/?theme=59

Avoidz, i think they already fixed the missing rotoscope

go get the torches!!

^Me too!

I loved the first edition, i would love to see what tricks ABC pulled out of his sleeve this time

It didnt do that to me either, i was referring to other people, not me.

mrbenja0618 said:

fishmanlee said:

Well, flapjacks are better than Han Solo, and bacon will DESTROY the OT! Mark my words!

This made more sense than anything else you've said thus far.

well GL IS getting pretty fat....

mrbenja0618 said:

fishmanlee said:

mrbenja0618 said:

That doesn't make sense..... That's like saying, well, we had Jedi in one of the movies, they shouldn't be in another.... That's the same stupid mentality that got us Ewoks instead of wookies in ROTJ.

And haven't you heard the saying that a girl will marry a man like her father... Lots of truth in that... So think about it..... Maybe that's secretly why she was attracted to Han, because he seemed similar to the man who helped shape who she is.

And its a mentality similar to yours that got us the Jedi order as we know it in the prequels, a bunch of superhero types

I'm curious how that works. Now, if I said every character in the prequels should be just like Han Solo, then your comment would be valid. I didn't say that.

Now, I will agree with you to an extent that there were an over abundance of Jedi in one action sequence in the prequels, but to say that they should have been few and far between goes against what was implied in OT. "They were the guardians of peace and justice..." That to me says there were many. Jedi are glorified cops, and you'll need plenty to provide justice across the entire galaxy. Not just 6. How would that work in my town if there were only 6 Jedi? 

Now if you're just simply saying that my mentality is the same that made Jedi superhero types.... Um.... Isn't that what they were supposed to be??? Why have powers if they aren't going to be viewed in that light?

Anyway, please read my posts before you misrepresent me. Thanks.

well from what I've read, Jar-Jar, Bail, Anakin, Hayden and I think Owen have been considered as Rogue types- and those are just the ones i can remember, if all these were added together into one edit, it would lessen Han Solo's significance, but you guy's were not saying that, you were just going to pick one and thats that.

however, I stand corrected in the area that that would totally ruin Han's character.

and i see all you guy's points (er however you word that)

brash_stryker said:

Again Fish, you miss the point. Jar Jar and and PT Anakin ruined the films they were IN. And that's because they sucked.

Whereas you said that improving a character that is currently as dull as they get, would somehow ruin the OT - a series of films made decades before.

PT Anakin was in ROTJSE, but other than that, I stand corrected

Bingowings said:

A posh, moneyed aristocratic rough and tumbler would be a very different character from a pirate captain living on his wits rough and tumbler.

Han Solo isn't diminished by Lando or Boba Fett, both of which share traits with him.

The film where all three are in is largely believed to the best representation of all three characters.

ROTJ?

TML said:

fishmanlee said:

brash_stryker said:

Off camera, she has given the baby girl to Bail Organa (who also needs to be a more rough and tumble Han Solo type rather than the dull Senator he's written as in the prequels)

 

no, he should not be like han solo at all, that would ruin the OT

I love how some people believe that one little character could possibly "ruin a whole film series". Are these films really that fragile?

Apparently Jar-Jar and PT-Anakin did, with a little help from Lucas that is

mrbenja0618 said:

That doesn't make sense..... That's like saying, well, we had Jedi in one of the movies, they shouldn't be in another.... That's the same stupid mentality that got us Ewoks instead of wookies in ROTJ.

And haven't you heard the saying that a girl will marry a man like her father... Lots of truth in that... So think about it..... Maybe that's secretly why she was attracted to Han, because he seemed similar to the man who helped shape who she is.

And its a mentality similar to yours that got us the Jedi order as we know it in the prequels, a bunch of superhero types IMO

brash_stryker said:

No...Han Solo isn't "like a Jedi". He's the ANTI Jedi! Jedi are disciplined, diplomatic, peacekeeping knights. Han Solo is a badass rogue who doesn't do things by the book. He shoots first and asks questions later (until the SE).

I think you've missed the whole point of Han's character. "Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid"

thats not what i meant by "He's like a Jedi"

let me rephrase it: He's like a Green Lightsaber [Should be]: Rare

Well, IMHO Han Solo is like a Jedi, he should be a rare occurrence, having a bunch of rough and tumble types just cheapens HS's character....


seriously though, what I meant is that (I think) it would make no sense for Leia to be initially turned off to Solo's "Rough and Tumbleness" when her father is/was the same way


and i didnt mean that Bail couldnt be changed or altered, just that i dont think making him like Han Solo is the right change to make IMO.

yeah its like saying "I watched the 1st and 6th Star Wars movie and that turned me off to the whole series!"