The infamous Luke building his lightsaber scene: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uf5LKSudNug&feature=channel_video_title
AuggieBenDoggie said:
They way I see it, I already have enough of starwars on video to qualify me to have a copy of Adys edit. I have the unaltered original trilogy on VHS and Laser Disc. I have the Special Editions on VHS and Laser Disc. I have the 2004 dvd's and the prequel dvds. I also have The Phantom Menace VHS. Buying the Blu-rays does nothing for me.
except for whatever deleted scenes Ady decides to use in his edits (if he so chooses)
Tobar said:
fishmanlee said:
http://www.youtube.com/user/BetterThanHollywood9#p/a/u/0/ryqbQE2JF8I
Luke training with a lightsaber, no sound though ;(
I have a hunch that part of "Training of a Jedi Knight" would have scored some of that as some sort of montage or something...
http://www.youtube.com/user/BetterThanHollywood9#p/a/u/0/ryqbQE2JF8I
Luke training with a lightsaber, no sound though ;(
ben_danger said:
i'm not an expert, but someone (ady or angel) did a fair job cleaning up the previous release of the biggs scene. surely they could do a pretty awesome job with this release?
It was Angel.
Really, all these "Lucasfixes"* are getting old and annoying.
*I now hereby patent/coin the word/phrase Lucasfixes/Lucasfix
Sorry, I am really tired, I meant to post this (the post below) in the Random Star Wars Thoughts thread:
Really, all these "Lucasfixes"* are getting old and annoying.
*I now hereby patent/coin the word/phrase Lucasfixes/Lucasfix
I would love these to be re-sent since I have lost the links..
http://starwars.com/news/saga_bluray_restoration/index.html
notice something?
"The Phantom Menace REVISITED"
Maybe you could mingle them together?
msycamore said:
The two musical transitions to the Imperial fleet in The Empire Strikes Back as John Williams intended was nice to hear restored.
Do not forget the music when Boba fett takes off.
OzoneSherrif said:
There was no reason why Anakin had to have been born there anyway, aside from Lucas wanting the movies to rhyme... like poetry...
Except that Uncle Owen lived on Tattooine.
and He doesnt seem like the kind of guy to travel.
But then of course on the other hand Anakin could.
Like I said, I thikn The Death of Johnathan kent would have been a better inspiration track.
however I also think that its a bit too long the way you are utilizing it, I think if you cut a few of the notes and replaced them, it would work better
and it would make it seem more 70's/80's williams I think, if you used this technique somewhere: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qECa54fWt9E
I think the version in Johnathan's Death would have been the better model.
and the heroes intro part, I think the theme/motif is too long for that sort of fanfare thing you are going for.
The Cutter said:
fishmanlee said:
(And I always thought the friendship motif would be more, comical in a way in certain scenes (not too comical of course) like the scherzo from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_2LeU8Wz2Iit would have been a great thing if Obi-wan and Anakin's relationship had been close in some way to the Jones relationship...I love that movie, I love the humor...I love the way the relationship is done : humor + deep feeling. It has nothing to do with the PT stupid jokes...
But for that you need great actors, great script and great dialogues....
I used that track for the Elevator scene* (I know you cut it out, and I understand why) and I thought it would have fit well if the dialogue had been good and necessary.
(*I used 0:12 onward of Alarm when Greivous enters the room if you want to know)
The Cutter said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0bcRCCg01I&t=1m20s
" Hey John !!, you are not serious !! you will not put Holts music in star wars, it's too obvious !!"
^_^
He pretty much ditched that in ESB though.
(And I always thought the friendship motif would be more, comical in a way in certain scenes (not too comical of course) like the scherzo from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_2LeU8Wz2I
The Cutter said:
you will hear it three/four times in the movie.
Late game item much?
Mithrandir said:
timdiggerm said:
Small note: I was thinking about the DS explosions, and about how most of us want to see the shockwave gone from ANH.
I'm actually not sure I feel the same way about ROTJ. The collapse of the reactor makes the shockwave make more sense in ROTJ, it looks pretty cool the Falcon at the end, and it makes a nice visual distinction between the DS and DSII explosions.
(in Hoth, when the ion cannon fires, the star destroyer kinda sinks in space).
that doesnt count as an explosion, thats only all of the systems shutting down.
Which style of williams are we talking about anyway?
60's comedy williams?
70's disaster and adventure film williams?
80's Action and Adventure Williams?
90's Creature and Political Figure biography films williams?
or 2000's Drama williams?
and about your mention of ET, most of the score is "Ambient background music" like you said, with only "Escape - Chase - Goodbye" (and the end credits) being the only real memorable music.
Those two are no comparison.
that is too "inappropriate and cloying to be used as some kind of Anakin & Obi Wan friendship theme" you might as well use this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MK6TXMsvgQg
that piece I posted above could prove malleable enough to be a motif for A&O.
and JW has still got it, The Jungle Chase, and the War Horse trailer proves it.
There is a motif, you could integrate into something with Anakin and Obi-wan, its from the track "Goodbye old friend": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIHI5aouffE&feature=related
its from 0:00 to about 0:40
Angel said:
You cant listen the score of PT (apart TMP maybe but is not the same) as a stand alone piece. I still have ANH and ESB scores as the best so far because they hardly repeat them selfs in the contex.
In PT the orchestration changes the style changes the melody is nowhere etc etc...
Now im not saying/thought that the PT score if it was orchestrated with the 70s way might sound better or worse but in my experience the scores are pretty much dead with the way they use to be. TheKcutter knows that better from us.
Thats because the best parts were not used/are unreleased!
like the Emporer Motif in I Am The Senate, and Across the Stars right after the death of Mace.Sorry i cant see them as good music.
Its other making music for a shot/film and other for filling the gaps with an ambient background music.
-Angel
The Prequel scores are Cut and Paste jobs anyways, half of the music in AOTC and ROTS is from TPM.
and not even the best tracks from TPM: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WyVs_L8z8E
but it does not matter, its Cutter's edit, not mine.
Angel said:
I find the PT score very bland and ambient.
-Angel
Thats because the best parts were not used/are unreleased!
like the Emporer Motif in I Am The Senate, and Across the Stars right after the death of Mace.
Thats easy to explain, the green heat of the lightsaber was getting close to the gun and made the sparks.
Angel said:
fishmanlee said:
" BTW, you think you could come up with a good/better Droid/Villian theme?
I think something similar (not exactly the same notes, but the same mood) to this would be interesting: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58wJRrvVgZI
or: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fCQKLKElPBY
But its still up to you.
maybe this will be some inspiration: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bvu3hCmHRf4 "
X3Lol you said that once!
Your point? (seriously though, I didnt think he saw it so I reposted it, call me stupid or whatever)
I love the theme TheKcutter I cant wait to listen the heroic version of it :)
-Angel
Yeah I like this version of it also (at 1:30): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXYj8nChItw
I don't think so.
and I meant this post:
" BTW, you think you could come up with a good/better Droid/Villian theme?
I think something similar (not exactly the same notes, but the same mood) to this would be interesting: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58wJRrvVgZI
or: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fCQKLKElPBY
But its still up to you.
maybe this will be some inspiration: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bvu3hCmHRf4 "