fishmanlee

General Greivous should be edited to sound like "Henry": Enri (General Greivous)

Obi-wan should call everyone "Pathetic Lifeform"

So, there is a lot of unused music in these films, thought I would make videos with the score restored to the picture:

All of these videos are in this Google Drive folder:

https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0BxQSwI5aPja9MmZjVHJFSDNQeU0&usp=sharing

This should be in the Fan Edits section, because sometimes the music was for a completely different cut.

Ryan McAvoy said:

To me, hearing/seeing the Dreamworks logo says...

"Congratulations you've just paid to see a movie that you were hoping would be really good but which will only mildly disappoint you"

;-)

Where as the Fox Fanfare always comes with the feint suggestion that you may (Despite your brain telling you that it won't) be about to watch a movie with Lightsabers and Pulse Rifles in it ;-)

Funnily enough, John Williams also wrote this theme.

Howabout cliegg riding mauls speeder?

Also this has some potentially funny lines from Mcdiarmid (it could be useful in Ridicuoulous Hope. too)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=098eEvhiZDA

Could Ani Yell out "Mommy!" as he is cut by Obi-Wan on Mustafar?

I don't think Ungoliant was mentioned in the Appendices...?

doubleofive said:

 

fishmanlee said:

The reason the EE is so short, is because the Theatrical is so long.

And because the book is so short. Did we really think he could pump 3 3.5 hour movies out of The Hobbit?

 

And the Appendices, and Unfinished Tales, The History of Middle-Earth series..

Mithrandir said:

or richer than Moria...mithril!

Erebor in glory vs. Moria in Decline....

The reason the EE is so short, is because the Theatrical is so long.

Barry was too repetitive for me, one cue is just 30 seconds of the same thing looped for 2:00 minutes.

So?

Alot of Goldsmith scores sound the same, almost every composer has this "issue"

Ryan McAvoy said:

As a writer of film scores Williams is overrated IMO. Brilliant, but overated. Ennio Morricone and Bernard Hermann are the greatest ever composers of film scores. Every score they did featured a whole new soundscape of different instruments and emotional depths.

The linking scores in Williams work are usually a rehash of everything he's done before. Star Wars, Harry Potter, Indiana Jones, Jurassic Park are so similar.

None of his scores are truly the same though.

Jurassic Park uses much more synth than Star Wars.

Harry Potter uses much more Celeste than Indiana Jones (except KOTCS)

With each Indy score, the style difference is huge, Raiders is mostly minor keyed, Temple is frenetic, Crusade is laid back, humorous, and emotional, KOTCS has more Sci-fi.

Star Wars is more Romantic than the others.

and plenty of Williams scores had "new" soundscapes

Eh, Superman is closer to Star Wars than Raiders is, for example "Chasing Crooks" the strings sound alot like the writing in "Tie Fighter Attack"/"The Battle of Yavin".

"The End of Ridiculousness!?"

'The Ridiculous Sequel Trilogy: Now There Are Two of Them!"

True, but for people expecting to hear exactly what they heard in 1977, from John Williams in 1999-2005 for vastly inferior films...

Plus Williams scored the films in certain ways:

TPM was mostly Pastorale (Anakin is Free, and Arrival at Coruscant), with energetic action music (Take To Your Ships)

AOTC was more rythmic, with all the percussion (Chase thorugh Courscant, The Conveyor Belt, Dooku Vs. Obi-wan)

three quarters of ROTS was scored more like a political thriller, a la Nixon, with brooding low key music, the rest was references to the OT (A home for the Twins, Plans for the Twins).

Wexter said:

Why on EARTH didn't they used that?

Techinically they did, they repurposed that design for the Orc Azog kills on weathertop (his servant, that leads the Warg chase near the beginning of the film

.Mac. said:

These arachnids appear a bit large (twice the height of yoda?) and menacing though, so inserting them somewhere without disrupting the focus on the character(s)/scene is greatly limited. I'm interested in seeing these arachnids, but I feel it'd only work at the long-shot of the X-Wing crash and/or maybe while R2 is out in the rain.

"In addition to the very large ones, there were also some smaller, knee-height ones; Luke Skywalker ended up facing a number of these in his training.["

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Knobby_white_spider#cite_note-RS_III-0

those spiders are in Rouge Squadron III right?

Ronster said:

I Really did not like the CGI for Azog

They had to, Azog's design was a last minute addition, he originally looked like this:

http://images.wikia.com/lotr/images/9/94/Picture3.png

http://images.wikia.com/lotr/images/b/b0/Imageffffff.jpg

Perhaps the stormtroopers could march to the Winkies theme from Wizard of Oz?

Some ideas:

Darth Vader should be dubbed like Mr. T, or with a light chipmunk voice.

Sith should be called Sith-Sith.

"Once more the Sith-Sith will rule the galaxy, and we will have...Pizza..."

Order 66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666................

http://www.denofgeek.com/movies/star-wars/26133/richard-marquand-interview-return-of-the-jedi-star-wars

Vader kind of looks like he is trick or treating in that hologram shot ;)