darklordoftech

Juno Eclipse said:

Did George plan on brining Palpatine back in any of his many Sequel Trilogy ideas?

No

I knew what Yoda looks like from pop culture, so when Yoda claimed not to be Yoda himself but rather someone who knows Yoda, I was surprised and thought, “Is this Yoda’s brother?”

“There’s multiple original versions”/“it’s debatable which versions are actually the originals”.

Aside fron sound mix variations and the addition of “Episode IV: A New Hope”, I’m not aware of any pre-1997 variations.

Hadrian sunrider said:

Lucas: We also wanted to have a scene where Vader goes and bows before the Force and the Force picks him up and tells him that he better go out and get that crystal… But it’s not the Force personified; it’s on the verge of personification. Maybe it’s a shadow or something.

Alan Dean Foster: The ultimate…

Lucas: It’s the ultimate evil. It’s the devil.

Is it possible that Pomojema, the Cthullu-looking being who we see a statue of in Splinter of the Mind’s Eye, was intended to be this being?

Omni said:

I despise them.

Why?

Another problem with the Plinkett reviews is that they made people forget about the suppression of the original versions and think that the prequels were fans’ only grevience with Lucas, so Disney felt a lot of pressure to make sequels that didn’t resemble the prequels and no pressure to release the original versions of the movies. I wish Plinkett reviwed the Special Editions in additon to the prequels.

If the prequels are the Soviet Union, the Plinkett reviews are Joe McCarthy. The Plinkett reviews are so nitpicky and make such stupid complaints about the prequels that they make constructive criticism of the prequels harder.

Kane Skywalker if the rough draft script of what would be become Star Wars (ANH) is anything to go by.

I wish they made a comic adaptation of this draft like they did of the rough draft of ANH (“The Star Wars”).

Mara Jade sneaking into Jabba’s Palace to assassinate Luke. The Emperor wanted to turn Luke to the dark side (which would require Luke to be alive) and there’s no way he would allow anyone besides himself and Vader to get involved in his plans for Luke.

Superweapon VII said:

darklordoftech said:

Superweapon VII said:

Spartacus01 said:

I hate the post-1999 EU Jedi with every all of myself.

Agree. I can tolerate the prequel-era Jedi to an extent, but it really got my goat when their characteristics were applied to Jedi outside that era.

I also hated this with the Sith. Things like the “Darth” title and red lightsabers kept getting pushed further and further back in the timeline.

I know, right?

I enjoyed the KOTOR comic well enough, but it irked me when one of Exar Kun’s followers turned up with a red lightsaber or when Haazen commented on choosing “Darth Hayze” as his Sith name.

I think that as far as the Legends timeline goes, the “Darth” title and red lightsabers should begin no earlier than 2000 BBY (when the TPM novelization says the Sith were founded) and end with Empire’s End.

https://boards.theforce.net/threads/rewriting-the-ot-to-suit-the-prequels-humor.50039598/

Superweapon VII said:

Spartacus01 said:

I hate the post-1999 EU Jedi with every all of myself.

Agree. I can tolerate the prequel-era Jedi to an extent, but it really got my goat when their characteristics were applied to Jedi outside that era.

I also hated this with the Sith. Things like the “Darth” title and red lightsabers kept getting pushed further and further back in the timeline.

Spartacus01 said:

Anakin Starkiller said:

Man, you guys don’t like Legacy?

I just hate the fact that they used the Sith as the bad guys again. I mean, yeah, I’m the first who doesn’t always agree with George Lucas, but in this case I prefer to stay on his side and to say that there are no more Sith after Return of the Jedi.
We can think everything we want about the Prequels, but they exist, so why can’t we just try being consistent with them? The Prequels say that Anakin would have destroyed the Sith, and he did destroy the Sith when he killed Palpatine and Vader in Return of the Jedi. So, there should be no more Sith after that.

Also, the Sith in Legacy are all called “Darth”, have red lightsabers, and have Maul-like tattoos. If they hated the prequels, they could have made the villains not so prequel-like.

I wonder how fans would have reacted if Ki-Adi Mundi (the conehead Jedi) said, “The Sith have been extinct for 1000 generations” instead “the Sith have been extinct for a millenium.” It would be consistent with ANH, but it would contradict the dates of the Sith Wars in the Tales of the Jedi comics.

When the Special Editions of the Original Trilogy were released, complete (aside from Lapti Nek and Yub Nub) soundtracks were also released. Furthermore, an “Ultimate Eidtion” soundtrack was released for TPM. However, complete soundtracks were never released for AOTC or ROTS.

Disney has released complete soundtracks for Rogue One and Solo, but not for the Sequel Trilogy. Since Disney has gained the rights for the soundtracks for I-VI, they haven’t published the complete soundtracks for the OT that had been published since 1997 nor the “Ultimate Edition” TPM soundtrack that had been published since 2000.

• Give Jakku a different biome
• Rey would initially live with her parents, who wouldn’t be anyone of importance.
• Instead of neo-Imperials, the villain would be an ancient, pre-Sith evil. The being that corrupted the first Sith.
• I’d have the formation of the New Republic and New Jedi Order occur during the movies rather than them coming and going offscreen.

of_Kaiburr_and_Whills said:

Okay, so here are my picks:

1. The sheer amount of cataclysmic events and wars that follow RoTJ. Seriously, it’s like Luke, Han, Leia, and Lando just can’t catch a break. Every 2 years something insane happens and of course they’re the ones that have to fix it. They never get to retire or live out their happy ending. I don’t have an issue with new conflicts starting up, but do they always have to be so intense and involve the same ten people? This is why I’m very picky with my post RotJ content, and why I prefer to just go by head-canon.

2. “Never tell me the odds” is apparently some sort of Correllian belief or something? Seriously? Not only does it subtract from Han’s uniqueness, its just stupid.

3. I dislike how the Fate of the Jedi series turns “the Ones” from the Clone Wars Mortis episodes into mere celestials. I always thought there was something much more spiritual and psychological with those characters and their planet. But no, now all the mystery surrounding them is gone and they’ve been reduced to some overpowered superhero villains.

4. Also, why is there a need to overexplain almost everything? I get that a great deal of EU lore stems from the old West End Games RPG where it made sense to explain certain things seen on screen, but still. The EU as a whole goes too far with this.

5. Vitiate is terrible. Way too overpowered and boring. Also, I’m not the biggest fan of KOTOR and that era, but having Vitiate be the reason Revan and Malak turn to the Dark Side is stupid. Completely removes any sense of agency and choice those characters had in their decisions.

Absolutely agree on 1, 3, and Revan and Malak being possessed by Vitiate. Revan and Malak choosing to turn to the Dark Side is a key part of their stories and characters.

Superweapon VII said:

Spartacus01 said:

I hate the post-1999 EU Jedi with every all of myself.

Agree. I can tolerate the prequel-era Jedi to an extent, but it really got my goat when their characteristics were applied to Jedi outside that era.

Which contradicted existing stories establishing that Jedi in other eras weren’t like that.

G&G-Fan said:

darklordoftech said:

At least George allowed Making Of books to be published and behind-the-scenes clips to be shown. Disney fired J.W. Rinzler.

Oh man, why’d they do that?

They didn’t like that he was revealing behind-the-scenes information about Star Wars.

The Legacy Era

Spartacus01 said:

Since I don’t like the way the Jedi are portrayed in Lucas’ Prequel Trilogy, then I don’t accept the Old Republic Era the way it was made in the post-1999 EU either, because the Jedi from the modern Old Republic Era are nothing but a copy and paste of Lucas’ Prequel Jedi. So, I created my own head-canon for the Old Republic Era, which rewrites a lot of stuff.
These are the major events:

• The Tales of the Jedi comics happen. After the end of the comics, there are several millennia of peace and prosperity in the Republic, until 2000 BBY.
• In 2000 BBY the Mandalorian Wars take place. The reasons of why the Mandalorian Wars happen are the same reasons of why they happened in the original Knights of the Old Republic lore, before The Old Republic MMO retconned everything. The major events of the Mandalorian Wars are the same that are described in the Knights of the Old Republic comics. However, Cassus Fett is replaced with a new character, as my Old Republic head-canon (just like my Prequel rewrite) respects Boba Fett’s pre-Prequel backstory, and so the Fett family doesn’t exist as such.
• After the end of the Mandalorian Wars, Revan and Malak fall to the Dark Side, revive the Sith cult and unleash the Jedi Civil War. The following events are similar to those described in the first Knights of the Old Republic game. However, the Jedi are more similar to the Jedi from the Tales of the Jedi comics, and look nothing like the Jedi from Lucas’ Prequels. Apart from this, Revan and Malak’s story is similar to what’s depicted in the first KOTOR. So, we still have Bastila and the other characters, Malak is still defeated, Revan is still redeemed, etc.
• After Revan’s redemption, the Republic continues to fight against the remnants of the New Sith Empire founded by Revan. The war goes on until 1000 BBY, when the Sith are definitively defeated in the Battle of Russan. However, a Sith survived the battle, and this Sith is Bane. So, after the defeat of the old Sith, Bane created the Rule of Two, established the use of the Darth title (which didn’t exist before him) and also established the red lightsaber rule for the Sith.

So, in my head-canon Palpatine and Vader are still Sith, but the Darth title and the red lightsaber rule were born with Bane. They didn’t exist before. Also, the Jedi Civil War and the New Sith Wars are merged into one single conflict.

Thumbs up to all this except that I hate the term “Jedi Civil War”.

At least George allowed Making Of books to be published and behind-the-scenes clips to be shown. Disney fired J.W. Rinzler.

That the TIE Fighter is actually the “Tie Line Fighter” and its predeccesors are “TIE Fighter” and “T.I.E. Fighter”.

Was that a common belief amongst fans?