Robbins, Tod - Unholy Tales
Four stories and a novel from the mostly forgotten Browning.
“Spurs” is the most (in)famous tale here, an this was optioned by Universal where Tod Browning fashioned it into Freaks. The story is of a midget and a bareback ride, though Robbins’ original is the more straightforward. While interesting to read, it has none of the shock of the adaptation.
“Silent, White And Beautiful” is narrated by an artist. Sculptor, by training. Decent enough, although sales barely keep him above poverty. A European, he opts to emigrate to America, ignorant that Americans have no taste for artistic endeavor, and certainly no coin to spend. An unsavory tale, this, yet the narrator’s elegant cynicism grows on you.
The main piece, the novel “The Unholy Three,” is the jewel of this collection. This had also been filmed by Browning (in 1925), with Lon Chaney, no less! Later remade as a talkie, Chaney again.
Both versions deviate from the source material, and not in a good way. Neither improve upon the book. For me, both are inferior by comparison.
The books shines the spotlight on two individuals: The young idler, Hector McDonald, who fancies his literary prowess and envisions a glittering career. The other character is the malevolent dwarf, Tweedledee. Equally consumed by ambition and dreams, equally thwarted, Tweedledee’s spirit becomes corrupt, and he declares vengeance upon the world.
Note – This might have made a superior film, but Harry Earles was no Lon Chaney.
Robbins writes with a punchy, vivid style. Not overly florid. His characters, good and bad, breathe and react in recognizable ways. He can also drop clever of phrase, one after another, without going purple.