logo Sign In

Vaderisnothayden

User Group
Members
Join date
30-Oct-2008
Last activity
27-Apr-2010
Posts
1,266

Post History

Post
#358968
Topic
TPM: A Decade Later
Time

TPM definitely had more to it than the other two, even apart from Neeson's performance, but let's not make the mistake of praising it too far. It's still a very artificial film, sometimes painfully sweetened, with some really dumb stuff, not to mention the torture of the podrace that was obviously designed to appeal to the tastes of pod people. I've just been watching Unforgiven. Now that was a real movie.

Post
#358661
Topic
was mace going to the darkside?
Time
AxiaEuxine said:

Pulp Fiction was one of the most overrated movies ever, I just dont understand what everyone saw in that film.

It was pretty good, but definitely overrated. The most overrated Tarantino film is Resevoir Dogs. Load of crap. I find Tarantino to be a very much overrated director/filmmaker, but then there are a lot of those.  

Post
#358656
Topic
Hidden items in OT and other SW
Time
skyjedi2005 said:

Haven't you been on these boards long enough to know that Anchorhead only likes star wars '77 as far as the films are concerned, without having to ask.  Or are you just being funny? lol.

Considering Anchorhead has reverence for the original film that started it all that Lucas has tried to destroy and bury, therefore Anchorhead is welcome here.  I agree that none of the sequels, prequels or whatever recreate the magic of the original film in 1977.  Though Empire Strikes back and Return of the Jedi oot versions come close, but the prequels are like a million miles short of that.

 

I think ROTJ and ESB recreate the magic of ANH, and surpass it in many ways. I'm not quite prepared to describe ANH as the weakest of the trilogy, but I come close. It's such a great film, but the other two (as I said) surpass it in many ways.

Post
#358185
Topic
TPM: A Decade Later
Time

Yeah, it wasn't until AOTC that I realized the PT was fucked. I wasn't crazy about TPM when I saw it, but I still was in a not-very-critical mindset and focused on its limited better aspects rather than its faults. I still had some faith in Lucas (god knows why). Then AOTC came along, with Hayden Skywalker and all that shit and the total emptiness of the movie and I realized Star Wars had lost its way. I viewed TPM more critcally then. After that, I didn't expect much from ROTS, but ROTS stil managed to disappoint my meager expectations.

Post
#358061
Topic
Something you all might enjoy... vintage style, custom made action figure cardbacks
Time
bkev said:

lol, Axia.  You can thank Vaderisnothayden, who's views not all of us agree on per say.  And whether we do or not, he's definitely the most outspoken.  Just don't lump us all together... I for one enjoy the action figure things that I've seen; just haven't commented.

On my end though, I apologize for contributing to the Dragonball discussion.

 

No you can't thank me. I didn't bash the prequels here. If you're going to blame me for something at least blame me for something I actually did. What is it now, if anything happens point the finger at Vaderisnothayden? If you want to thank someone, thank DarkFather for the way he talked to Axia, which started all this.

Post
#358024
Topic
Secret Star Wars Production Shooting in Hollywood - for Star Tours
Time
skyjedi2005 said:

I hope lucas is not directing the footage of this secret production, or rick mcallum.

I'm not really interested because you know Boba's going to sound like Jango Fett and not the pre 2004 real boba fett voice by Paul Wingreen. 

Plus Fett was a small character in the original films and now in the current EU is almost becoming even a bigger character than Luke Skywalker.  Which is laughable.  He was one of the baddies cronies in Empire.  He was Vaders bitch.  Now hes the greatest thing since sliced bread.  All the more btter for Lucash to sell action figures.

I was a bit annoyed when he was in star wars special edition to pander to the fanboys, as he had no place there.   And i bet you he was not the real fett under the suit Jeremy Bulloch.  Just some extra.  The same probably on star tours.

Just like on Empire Strikes back special edition it was not Dave Prowse in the suit for the new footage.  Don't even get me started on how he was not in episode III and they put Hayden in the suit,lol.

I'm not really interested because you know Boba's going to sound like Jango Fett and not the pre 2004 real boba fett voice by Paul Wingreen. 

Yeah, it won't be the real Boba Fett.

Plus Fett was a small character in the original films and now in the current EU is almost becoming even a bigger character than Luke Skywalker.  Which is laughable.  He was one of the baddies cronies in Empire.  He was Vaders bitch.  Now hes the greatest thing since sliced bread.  All the more btter for Lucash to sell action figures.

Yeah.

I was a bit annoyed when he was in star wars special edition to pander to the fanboys, as he had no place there. 

Yet one more silly poorly-conceived SE change. And it's Lucas's original 1977 vision I'm sure.

Post
#358022
Topic
Something you all might enjoy... vintage style, custom made action figure cardbacks
Time
skyjedi2005 said:

Yeah VaderisnotHayden pretty much rivals even my hatred of the prequels and surpasses it with flying colors. Which does not seem quite possible,lol.

I find myself mostly entertained by his posts and find myself laughing when he goes into how inept the mustafar duel was.  Or he basically talks about Lucas plain ineptness since star wars ended in 1983 and got rebooted in 1997 as special crap editions.

:)

 

Post
#358021
Topic
Something you all might enjoy... vintage style, custom made action figure cardbacks
Time
C3PX said:

I mean just check out post #10 of this thread, it was all light hearted and happy in here, and studdenly your post comes along.

At any rate, you obviously seem to have some issues with DF. And that is great. I support you in your issue taking, not wanting to sound like I am trying to play mod here, but why not try to keep the little thing between you two confined to whatever thread it started in. The last thing the rest of us want to see is this popping up in every thread the both of you post in.

DarkFather was treating Axia like shit in a way that reminded me of how he treated me. I couldn't ignore that. And he was promoting a really ugly philosophy. Maybe you found that fun, but to me it looked revolting. I don't consider what DarkFather was saying to be "light hearted and happy". It was insulting talking down to somebody plus promoting a wolf pack/chase after popularity attitude. As it is, I usually ignore DarkFather, but this time it was very hard to ignore. It's ludicrous to suggest I get into trouble with DarkFather on every thread we post on. I hadn't talked to or about DarkFather for a good while before this. But somebody had to point out that how he was treating Axia was wrong. It certainly wasn't going to be you. You were too busy finding it fun that somebody was being treated like shit. And I didn't mean what I just said to come off so aggressive, but you seem to be failing to see that it wasn't just fun and games and could actually bother somebody, and I find that disturbing.

C3PX said:

I know you are in the majority around here

Very often I'm in the minority in my views and some people seem to find it offensive that I stand by my opnions when I'm in the minority. 

Post
#358019
Topic
Something you all might enjoy... vintage style, custom made action figure cardbacks
Time
C3PX said:

No, what Dark Father throws around is mostly just humorous musings.

In your case it isn't just simple criticism, and I know you are in the majority around here, as I'd actually usually tend to agree with your negative comments for the most part regarding the PT, EU, and the general states of SW fandom. But your brand of negativity is just so heavy handed and out there and repetitive, it even brings me down. I have generally been one of the one accused of being too harsh and negative toward the PT.

No, what Dark Father throws around is insulting people and talking down to them and acting like he thinks he knows better than anybody else. Very much negative.

But your brand of negativity is just so heavy handed and out there and repetitive, it even brings me down.

In other words, there's something wrong with putting any feeling into an opinion? You're calling negative something that isn't in any way negative. Enthusiastic maybe, heartfelt maybe, vigorous, not negative. In fact, I'd say it's your reading of it that's negative.

And I've been amazed at how negatively my attempts to introduce interesting discussion and fun have been received. It's not me that's negative. 

Post
#358015
Topic
Something you all might enjoy... vintage style, custom made action figure cardbacks
Time
C3PX said:
Vaderisnothayden said:

Yeah, Axia should ignore all the stuff about packs and popularity...

No! That was getting to be a really amusing conversation. We just need more participants to throw in their two cents. At least DF throws around amusing and off the wall discussion topics, rather than going around pissing down the place with negativity.

 

I'd say what DarkFather throws around is definitely negativity. Very negative indeed. Whereas, if you're trying to make a comment on me, criticism isn't a negative and nor is thinking differently from the majority. And I've been amazed at the negtivity with which my attempts to introduce interesting discussion have been received.

 

Post
#357849
Topic
Something you all might enjoy... vintage style, custom made action figure cardbacks
Time

Oh god, DarkFather has another target for his bullying. Newsflash to DarkFather, not everybody buys that you're this super-wise guy who's qualified to advise us all on what you think we should do.

I like them. Then again, it's their approval you want. Making threads like this is one of the more harder ways to do that. To become part of an already established pack, you're going to have to buddy up with the Alpha Male. Don't let man-made forum ranks deceive you. The moderator is only Alpha from a shallow perspective. Look for the one that everyone agrees with most, asks the most questions to... the one with the most social proof. Time is running out before the precedent you've set becomes cemented in the pack's collective mind, Axia. You're a straggler. Nobody wants to be the straggler when night falls and DarkFather rises. Tick tock.

Puke me out. If this place runs by the law of the pack then we should do our best to go against that. The law of the pack is pretty low down and unevolved. And to hell with nonsense about whoever's the "alpha male" and kissing his ass. God, how low can you get. Screw the "pack". We're not a bunch of wild dogs. Axia should just do his thing and not worry about getting approval from anybody.

I'm sure I'll get some silly reply from DarkFather, but he shouldn't expect me to reply to it. I'm done playing to his tune and responding to his baiting. I shouldn't have let him give me so much shit before I quit responding, though. Sorry to see another person getting his shit though, even if it's pretty mild compared to the deeply insulting stuff I got thrown at me.

Seriously Axia, just keep posting your views and don't fret over what anybody thinks of you.

Post
#357815
Topic
TPM: A Decade Later
Time

TPM is the only prequel in which the any of the main characters work well. Neeson as Qui Gon is great. Portman is mostly good as Padme. In contrast to how she was awful in AOTC and ROTS. McGregor is better than how he was in the later two prequels, more genuine, though still hardly inspired. Of course, the film doesn't do great with Anakin, but the later prequels do even worse. In the later prequels I found I couldn't give a fuck about any of the main characters, which seriously took from the story. TPM was better on that front.

But the final lightsaber battle in TPM is overrated. It's good in some ways, but it's overdone and the music is overdone. There was no need to beat the audience over the head with the message "This is Epic!" They did that even worse in the ROTS battle on Mustafarted, of course, and that battle had zero value, while the TPM one had some.

The podrace we could all have done without.

TPM totally broke the unspoken rules of star Wars films by loading on obviously cartoon characters. In the OT, some creatures were unconvincing, but the aim was to make them come off as real as possible. The OT tried to make things seem real. In TPM, we're hit with a lot of creatures who seem to be designed with no effort to make them come off real. This includes not only the CGI characters but also the cartoonish Trade Federation guys, who were really annoying, and the droid soldiers, who were just done as a joke (the OT never made its villains just a joke like that).

 And the cgi backgrounds helped (along with the cartoon characters) to give a very unreal feel to the film. Admittedly the OT used some matte paintings for backgrounds, but TPM sometimes really went out of its way to make things look unreal when that could easily have been avoided. This of course did not improve in the later prequels.

 The OT worked by bringing imagined things to life and making them seem real. TPM failed so badly here. TPM's reality fails to convince.

Post
#357363
Topic
Question about the 85 mix
Time

In 1985 Ben Burtt remixed the OT's soundtrack and added the mono's 3PO tractor beam line in. This was for the VHS. Does anybody have any idea did the new mix have any other changes from the original theatrical versions (the stereo in the case of ANH) and what those might have been?

Also, was any new material recorded for the 85 mix or was it just made of material that was previously in existence?