logo Sign In

Tyrphanax

User Group
Members
Join date
2-Nov-2010
Last activity
14-May-2024
Posts
6,821

Post History

Post
#988981
Topic
Ranking the Star Wars films
Time

TV’s Frink said:

I think at this point I’m ready to put TFA above ROTJ. To put it in terms of albums…

Star Wars and ESB are masterpieces, not a bad track on either album.

ROTJ has some of my favorite songs but overall I think TFA is a slightly better collection of songs.

For the PT, Lucas kicked out all previous band members and made three albums without any other creative input. TPM at least felt like the same band was responsible, but some of the songs are just embarrassing. ROTS was an album that tried to hit all the notes from the original band but failed miserably. AOTC was created by putting a bunch of instruments in a trash compactor.

What a great way to put it. I agree.

Post
#988926
Topic
General Star Wars <strong>Random Thoughts</strong> Thread
Time

Lord Haseo said:

ray_afraid said:

Yeah, I guess it was the people with them doing dumb things, not the sabers…
But I didn’t remember the absorbing thing, so I’ll stand by my original statement. Even if that is the only dumb thing they do, it’s plenty.

Obi-Wan used it to absorb Dooku’s Force Lightning in AOTC.

That scene is much worse than Mace doing it in ROTS in my opinion. He just shrugs it off like it’s a goofy toy, when last time we saw it, the most powerful Dark Sider in the galaxy was using it to dismantle two of the (arguably) most powerful Jedi ever.

Post
#988912
Topic
Rogue One * <em>Spoilers</em> * Thread
Time

ZkinandBonez said:

canofhumdingers said:

ZkinandBonez said:

Well, at it seems people will soon be able to buy an action figure of an “Imperial Ground Crew”, which I personally find really funny.

I mean this guy is basically just the Star Wars equivalent of this guy;

And what kid wouldn’t want an action figure of the guy who waves two lights at landing TIE-fighters?

I dunno, did this guy ever get an action figure?

Source

Actually… Yes he did…

Though, sadly, he didn’t come with the wands.

Dang it.

Now the kids can’t have a complete set of Imperial and Rebel ground crew.

Well, at least we have three George Lucas action figures to choose from.
(I especially like the blue one, I mean seriously, what the hell is that supposed to be even?)

He’s this guy

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Papanoida

Post
#988842
Topic
Episode III: Revenge of the Ridiculousness
Time

TV’s Frink said:

Tyrphanax said:

Are there flashes of the Star Wars crawl/theme in the snow? I never noticed before.

?

Whoa, really? The times when Vader’s vision is starting up, there’s the television “snow” and it looks like the Star Wars opening crawl pops in (offset slightly) and like a note of the theme plays. Am I just inventing that connection?

And I’m pretty sure the song is the guitar solo from ZZ Top’s Cheap Sunglasses? Sounds like a different version than the one I’ve heard though.

Nope.

Hint: The song title is relevant to the scene. I only discovered it by Googling the relevant word.

It’s Edgar Winters’ Frankenstein then (which makes way more sense)! They have insanely similar riffs.

Also, I have no idea why I said Pink Sunglasses. It’s Cheap Sunglasses. Jeez, my brain is going.

Post
#988807
Topic
Episode III: Revenge of the Ridiculousness
Time

Are there flashes of the Star Wars crawl/theme in the snow? I never noticed before.

Man, I loved it. Never laughed at a death scene like that.

I have to say that I thought it would be funny if Vader answered “no” to Palpatine asking if he could hear him, but it would probably step on the Angel joke.

And I’m pretty sure the song is the guitar solo from ZZ Top’s Cheap* Sunglasses? Sounds like a different version than the one I’ve heard though.

I think it works well cut together, I wasn’t having trouble keeping track of the jokes.

*I originally said “Pink” Sunglasses and I have no idea why. How embarrassing.

Post
#988724
Topic
Episode VIII : The Last Jedi - Discussion * <strong><em>SPOILER THREAD</em></strong> *
Time

Tobar said:

Haha, well here’s an…interesting theory.

Whoof. That’s one of the dumbest theories I’ve ever heard.

Let’s deconstruct it like I did with the equally-spurious “Rey is Palpatine’s Granddaughter” theory!

Similarities to Anastasia aside, Rey being Han and Leia’s daughter is goofy as far as I’m concerned. Makes no sense to me that Han and Leia would be so heartless as to just dump Rey on a planet alone. That’s messed up. And then when she shows up in their lives, they don’t bat an eye? Nah. Not buying it. Sure, maybe she was kidnapped or something and sold into slavery, but I just don’t see her as being a Solo because there’s literally no reaction or exposition about it.

The way the original theory keeps saying that they’re alluding to Rey (by saying “it”? What?) in the film and that “It could mean Ben, but IT DOESN’T!” Of course the tragedy is Ben’s fall to the dark side. There’s no reason to believe otherwise.

The part where the guy goes on about Boba “witnessing that Vader had a son” didn’t happen. Boba doesn’t know Vader is Anakin, Boba doesn’t know Anakin had a son, the only thing Boba learned about Luke in their tussle in the comics is Luke’s name, and he feels it’s not very helpful information an then he leaves because Vader doesn’t say anything. He isn’t there when Vader reacts. So that’s nothing.

The next part just… what? “Mandaloren” What? How high was this person when they came up with this shit? Mandaloren armor? Just… you’re embarrassing yourself, dude. I don’t even need to say how stupid this is. Also, they use the term “Mandalorian” in The Clone Wars and Rebels, so…

The First Order part implies that there was at one point a “Mandaloren” (god that’s stupid) power in the galaxy that we’ve never heard of. Nope. Plus, in this canon, what connection does Boba have to the Mandalorians? His father, sure, but he doesn’t seem to have any connection to them in The Clone Wars.

“Not human but humanoid” meaning that he’s a clone is technically correct but very much a reach. Not buying it.

The rest of it is meaningless. So Snoke knows who Han Solo and the Millennium Falcon is, he was only the Rebel hero who helped destroy two Death Stars and end the Empire. Even Rey knows the legends. It’s all just guff. Not to mention Boba Fett is a bounty hunter and why would he suddenly become a space wizard emperor to get back at Han? One of the most spurious theories I’ve ever heard. Can’t wait to see it not happen in the theaters.

Post
#988696
Topic
Rogue One * <em>Spoilers</em> * Thread
Time

NeverarGreat said:

imperialscum said:

adywan said:

The Dark Empire said:

I am not looking forward to see shoretroopers, woodtroopers, deathtroopers, watertroopers, sandtroopers or hover tank troopers and what so ever is about to come.

Then you won’t like Episode 4 because they have Sandtroopers 😉

Technically sandtroopers they were just stormtroopers with some extra gear, which is how it should be in most cases. Since stormtroopers were supposed to be elite units, I am still waiting to see regular army. It would be much better instead of some new dumb ideas.

In the OT we get introduced to Snowtroopers and Scout troopers after ep4. So, did you have a problem with those, or is this just because they are something new? Because, if you didn’t have a problem with the introduction of those, then you are being a bit of a hypocrite.

I had no problem with snowtroopers because the change of armour was justified by the extreme conditions. I had no problem with scouttroopers because they were an entirely different type of unit (i.e. not infantry). I have problem with beachtroopers (or whatever) because it doesn’t make sense for them to change armour just because they go to a beach. It is not an extreme condition like frozen Hoth. If stormtroopers did not require to change armour when they went to a very hot place like Tatooine, I don’t see the reason for them to change it when they go to a beach (unless when they go for R&R, but then they need a swimsuit, not an armour).

Small quibble: The films never actually state that Tatooine is supposed to be hot. In fact, Mike Verta is of the opinion that Tatooine was originally graded to look desolate and cold.

That’s an interesting theory.

Post
#988576
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

Two more tonight.

Quantum of Solace (2008)

I had actually seen this in theaters when it came out, but for some reason I didn’t remember any of it at all. Upon this second viewing, I think I know why. It felt like an older Bond film in terms of structure, but with none of the charm and no innovation (not to mention terribly-edited, Michael-Bay-esque action scenes and the worst theme song I’ve ever heard). It hits the usual Bond notes well, but that’s about all it does. It’s just there. Not amazing, not terrible, just… there. A fairly forgettable film.

2.5/5

Skyfall (2012)

I actually started Skyfall and had just gotten to the part where Q was introduced and realized that I didn’t remember anything of Quantum of Solace. I know it has no bearing on Skyfall, but it felt wrong to go into it not remembering what happened beforehand.

After mostly sleeping through Quantum and getting back into Skyfall, the difference was obvious. It had everything Quantum was missing. It had charm and wit and smart writing, wonderful characters, and great action. Silva is a great villain in the vein of Alec Trevelyan (a rogue agent with an eye on cybercrime, and my favorite villains are rogues), Bond is almost right-out-of-the-novel Bond, Q is a filthy Millennial but manages to be respectable and smart and humorous, M is just fantastic, and all the support are great as well.

Where Quantum hit all the Bond notes, Skyfall shows that you can take that same old dog and teach it new and very exciting tricks. Quantum was the Bond formula, but Skyfall was the Bond feel.

Spoiler time, again if you’re like me watching years-old movies.

I was initially sad about M’s death, but as it was happening, I began to realize that Judi Dench couldn’t hold the role forever, and that she’d served admirably as one of the best M’s in the series so far (certainly the most-developed character) and that her passing was very dignified and well done. A strong end to a strong character.

Early in the film I was thinking about Mallory’s name and thinking “Hrm, was one of the male M’s a Mallory?” and sure enough, who occupies the office and the title at the end of the film but Mallory himself. I think he’s a perfect fit and most definitely has a modern Bernard Lee appeal to him. I couldn’t be happier.

And, of course, Moneypenny. I think she’s perfect. I enjoyed the banter and I think that Naomie Harris is fantastic in the role. I really enjoyed this all being set up slowly during the film and then all falling into place in the final scene (and it was nice to see some people out in the field). The moment I saw the coat rack, I thought “so is James going to toss his hat up there?” and it took me a second to realize I was meeting the old gang again. The layout of the offices (especially M’s), was so classic. When Bond said they were going back in time on the way to his old family home, he meant it. Even the titles were miles better than recent entries. I love the return to form and I’m very excited to see Spectre now.

4.5/5

Post
#988486
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

Welp.

Just finished Jurassic World. I haven’t really sat down to really watch a movie in nearly a year, but I figured I could take a day off the thesis and get one out of the backlog. Be forewarned that there will be spoilers in here if you’re like me and don’t watch movies.

I went into it expecting fully to not like it. I’d had most of it spoiled by now, so I had all these things on the tip of my tongue, ready to say about the movie.

Turns out, I thought it was pretty good.

It has a lot of flaws, for sure. The Indominus Rex and the domesticated raptors were stupid like I thought they would be, but not nearly as heinous as I expected (going in I had already justified both, because of course we’d try breeding new animals, especially considering the Wu/Hammond discussion in the Jurassic Park novel; and of course we’d try domesticating them for other uses). However, I think that they handled the “bioengineered dinosaurs for military use” so, so, so much better than that stupid human/dinosaur hybrid concept.

There were also scenes like the pterasaurs being stupid(?) enough to just fly into a helicopter? What? And the death of the co-pilot? Really? Also, would animals escaping just attack a group of people like that? I don’t feel like that would be the first thing on their minds, but maybe I’m wrong. I don’t get why they didn’t just disperse once they left the aviary and all just made a beeline in a mix-species flock to attack people for no real reason.

I thought that Zara’s death was far overdone and that Masrani was a great, Hammond-esque character (genial billionaire who wants to provide an amazing experience for people but who doesn’t have a clue how things really are) who was mostly wasted. I think one of my biggest issues with a lot of the movie was its gratuity in terms of death.

Initially I was annoyed by the dinosaur reveal, since they’re introduced in a very matter-of-fact way. There are just dinosaurs. But I think that was the point: it’s been 22 years, people know. People are “bored of dinosaurs,” which leads us to the events of the movie. The way everything is sponsored and “brand-dealed” up is a great satire of just how this kind of thing would be in real life.

The gyrosphere seemed like a bad idea, considering the kids have control and start a stampede with one, it seems like a liability waiting to happen despite what Jimmy Fallon said.

I think the worst part of the movie is that the Indominus Rex is part velociraptor and so suddenly, that means the velociraptors that imprinted on Owen, that he raised and trained from birth suddenly switch alphas magically? That’s not how domestication works. And the fact that the Indominus Rex, which up to this point has been indiscriminately murdering everything it can find, suddenly bros up to these tiny things it has very little in common with? Stupid.

All of that would have been forgiven, even, as a “hubris of man” situation that is the whole point of the series (the raptors are wild and can’t be controlled), but then in the final battle the raptors just suddenly decide to flip flop again? Why? And then when her entire pack is dead, Blue decides to ignore the animal instinct of self-preservation and just fight a battle she knows she can’t win in order to “team up” (what?) with the Tyrannosaur to take down the Indominus. None of that makes any sense.

That said, I was cheering my way through the final battle in spite of myself. It was another allegory about nature vs. man, I thought, with the “real dinosaurs” triumphing over man’s attempt at control. And the part where the Tyrannosaur bursts through the spinosaurus skeleton was pretty great, too. Fuck that guy. It was also nice to see that Tyrannosaurus was an old friend.

Lots of little nods in the movie were nice. Mentions of Hammond and Malcolm’s book, the spinosaurus bit mentioned above… and the whole section in the old visitor’s center was great. That’s one of my favorite parts of the franchise, the exploration of the monuments to the hubris of man. It’s why The Lost World and the game Trespasser stick in my mind, I love the idea of exploring that universe and trying to find out “what went wrong.”

There were also a few nods to the original novel that surprised me. The waterfall, taking the jeep (which isn’t that much of a reference, granted), triceratops riding, exploding raptors… I enjoyed those. I think the best was the allusion to the Wu/Hammond conversation about the reality of the dinosaurs from the book. That has always been one of my favorite parts of the novel.

I thought all the actors did a great job. D’Onofrio was great at being the InGen bad guy, Pratt was a bit goofy but still did a good job of being a… game warden? What was his role? But he was a cool character nonetheless. Bryce Dallas Howard was great as the “too busy to function” detached businesswoman who becomes human as things fall apart, and even the kids were good, though Ty Simpkins was a bit “know it all kid” tropey for me. Lowery was a good character too, and I feel like he may be a bit of a nod and wink to the fans.

I think that B.D. Wong’s reprised role as Henry Wu was the most disappointing. He seemed to have learned nothing from the failure of Jurassic Park and if anything had even more crazy hubris than before.

This is dragging on and on, so I’ll get to the main failing of this movie and of all these reboots, soft or otherwise, in recent years: They always seem to fall into the trap of being “more” than the last one. They always have stronger and more skilled characters, bigger and meaner bad guys, smarter and quicker geeks. It’s like an arms race, as a friend of mine put it, and it annoys me. You don’t have to top the last thing to be as good or better. And I think that’s where this movie fails the most, and where a lot of reboots fail: you can see the amazing movie in there somewhere, but they just didn’t fully excavate it, which is sad.

And, of course, with all modern movies and all modern blockbuster action flicks, the over-reliance on CGI was rampant. I cared less about this than I thought I would initially (the first minute or so of the movie is full CGI) but it’s still there and the film is less for it. More practical shots would have really helped sell the CGI, just like with Jurassic Park.

So yeah. I’ll let it have “good,” but only just. Not anywhere close to the same level as Jurassic Park, but not anywhere as bad as is sequels (both of which I enjoy as fun dinosaur flicks). I’m not sure I’d make a point to sit down and watch it again (and I re-read Jurassic Park once a year), but I wouldn’t change the channel if it was on.

3.5/5

Post
#988436
Topic
Video Games - a general discussion thread
Time

Intricated isn’t a word, dammit!

But yeah, I think the only reason New Vegas has a bad rap is because the launch was really poor compared to FO3. That’s why I didn’t ever bother to pick it up (though I apparently did at some point because it’s in my Steam library).

I’ve heard over and over that it’s a really great game, so maybe I’ll give it a spin sometime.