logo Sign In

Tobar

User Group
Moderators
Join date
13-Sep-2006
Last activity
18-Jan-2026
Posts
5,353

Post History

Post
#722708
Topic
What do you HATE about the EU?
Time

Noah Niedzolkowski said:

The way how in the prequels they added way too many new planets, many of which were similar to the original trilogy's planets (for example: Geonosis is pretty much exactly the same as Tatooine), and seemed to forget about most of the planets from the original trilogy. For example: we never see or hear of Bespin, Yavin, Endor, Dantooine, Hoth, Dagobah and many others in the prequels

 Um first, this is an EU thread.

Second, there's an entire galaxy out there, why keep revisiting the same planets over and over again. It's a vast waste of potential. It also would have made zero sense to revisit most of those planets as:

  • Yavin IV - secret base
  • Endor - secret base
  • Dantooine - abandoned secret base
  • Hoth - secret base
  • Dagobah - secret hideout (which is featured in a ROTS deleted scene.)
Post
#722700
Topic
<strong>STAR WARS: REBELS</strong> (animated tv series) - a general discussion thread
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:

And to do that they have to create a DayGlo Mandalorian graffiti artist?

I'm trying to remain cautiously optimistic towards this show, but this is looking more-and-more like a good example of the cure being worse than the disease.  

 On the surface of it, I'm not all that happy with the character either. But we'll have to wait and see how the character develops over time in the show before passing final judgement.

Post
#722087
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

Expendables 3 (2014)

Disposable.

The Survivors (1983)

Candice Paluso: Listen, this is gonna sound like a really stupid question, but, uh, aren't you guys gonna get really bored out here if society doesn't collapse?

Donald Quinelle: I wouldn't worry about that. Wes says society is heading for the big "flush". And we're going to be the ones who are clinging to the rim while everything else goes down.

Candice Paluso: Eeew!

Sonny Paluso: What're you going to do if things get better?

Donald Quinelle: Is the air getting better?

Candice Paluso: That's true.

Donald Quinelle: The economy? The Middle East? Arts, literature, television, US Presidents improving?

Sonny Paluso: Anyone can nitpick.

Donald Quinelle: Sonny, name one thing that's gotten better in the last ten years.

Sonny Paluso: [Sonny is stumped]

Donald Quinelle: See?

Candice Paluso: Video games.

Sonny Paluso: Video games! There you are.

Donald Quinelle: Alright, I acknowledge that.

Well that was certainly something. A film that's surprisingly still relevant.

Post
#721804
Topic
Ignorance in the Star Wars Galaxy
Time

TheBoost said:

Even the PT shows this. Queen Amidala has to physically fly to the capital to explain what's going on. They don't just flick to the GoogleNaboo app.  The Trade Federation denies it. 

All this strongly implies that mass communication in the SW universe is difficult, inconvienient, and not generally a priority.

 Amidala had to flee Naboo in order to avoid capture.

Why doesn't she message Coruscant once they've landed on Tatooine? Remember, she receives a message from Governor Bibble urging her to contact him. Qui-Gon tells her to send no reply. Why? Because her reply could be traced back to its point of origin. Same for if she sent a message to Coruscant. So the only safe thing to do was maintain radio silence until they safely made it to their final destination.

You also forget the intergalactic message between Obi-Wan on Kamino and the Jedi Temple in AOTC.

What doesn't make sense is why Obi-Wan can have a live conversation between Coruscant and Kamino which is described as being "beyond the Outer Rim." But then later has to relay a recorded message from Geonosis to Tatooine before it can reach Coruscant.

Post
#721661
Topic
What we like about the Prequels
Time

Bingowings said:

ObiWanKennerobi said:

We know Anakin was a great guy because Alec Guinness can actually act. When he says "and a good friend" it is said with such a glowing genuine warmth and wistful nostalgia, it simply couldn't have been any other way.

Everyone argues with their good friends.

 Once in a while maybe. But not all the bleedin time..

 Devil's advocate:

=P