The way adywan edited the Vader and Obi-wan duel in ANH:R is fine just the way it is with the exception of that score being added to it.
Should Anakin’s lightsaber be red during the duel on Mustafar?
Should ROTJ:R be recreated in the same way PT:R was going to be?
…what?
I think he’s wondering if Ady is going to completely restructure RotJ as he was planning to do the prequels.
That’s what I meant
Should ROTJ:R be restructured in the same way that PT:R was going to be?
FIFM
Is ROTJ:R going to be restructured in the same way that PT:R was going to be?
During the scene when Luke meets Biggs in the rebel hangar that was later added back into the film for the SE, there’s a bit of dialogue from Red Leader saying he met Luke’s father when he was a pilot as a young boy was removed
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ovJcIFwZ3k&t=15m50s
Since the OT:R exists for the OT alone, is there a possibility reinserting it?
During the space Battle of Endor, there should’ve been heavy casualties from both the Empire and Rebel fleet afterwards, not just a majority of the Rebel pilots surviving afterwards and most of the Empire fleet being destroyed.
For ex. during the Battle of Yavin, there were many casualties to Red Squadron where in the end only Luke, Wedge and a single Y-Wing pilot were the only ones who made it and not a majority of the Red Squadron pilots making it afterwards for a happier ending.
FIFM
NEW ADDITIONS
VHS
Emmanuelle 4 (1984) - the 1986 Canadian Cinema Plus Video features three scenes from the hardcore version.
Kickboxer (1989) - the 1990 Australian Palace Home Video release, while missing a few brief shortened scenes, is the most complete version of this film ever released.
Nightmare (1981) - the 1987 Australian Video Classics & Dutch Video for Pleasure releases are the fully Uncut versions containing over 1 minute of additional scenes.
LASERDISC
Backtrack (Catchfire) (1989) PILF-2246 - this release is the Director’s Cut. It contains 8 minutes of extended and alternate scenes.
Bad (1991) Z0300 - This is the fully uncensored version. The DVD release was cut by over 20 minutes.
Cafe Flesh (1982) Z0093 - the ending on the DVD release was cut by a few seconds.
Dangerous Games (1995) AVIV-1012 -The DVD release was severely edited by 13 minutes to create fake ‘mutiple angle’ footage. The LD contains the full uncut 87 minute version.
Diary of Anne Frank, The (1959) 1074-80 & 1074-85 - these are the widescreen editions featuring the original walk-in, intermission, and exit music tracks from the original theatrical run.
Immortals, The (1995) LT8011-C & — - These are the Uncut version of the film and are 6 minutes longer than the DVD release.
Jason’s Lyric (1994) 800633909-1 & ID3837PG - These releases are the Unrated versions that contain about 1 minute of extra footage.
Jimi Hendrix: Rainbow Bridge (1970) ID3931RH - this release contains an additional 17 minutes to the original film’s 108 minute DVD release.
Michael Schenker Group (M.S.G.): Hammersmith Live (1983) TE-D027 - this release is the longest version available after it was reissued and shortened under the title “Rock Will Never Die” for later releases.
Minako Honda: The Virgin Live in Budokan (1986) L098-1045 - this release contains an additional 36 minutes compared to the 59 minute DVD release.
Moontrap (1989) SWLD-3033 - This Japanese release contains several additional scenes that are exclusive to this version.
Object of Obsession (1994) ID3279AP - This release is the Unrated version with 5 minutes of additional scenes.
Once A Thief (1996) ID4058AP - This release is the Director’s cut with 12 minutes of additional scenes, a slightly different ending, and some of the dialogue is cut out in this version.
Other Woman,The (1992) ID2475M - This release is the Unrated version with 8 minutes of additional scenes.
Pamela Principle (1992) ID2502MR - This release is the Uncut version with 4 minutes of additional scenes.
Peking Opera Blues (1986) PILF-7063 & A015 - The DVD and Blu-ray editions are missing text that was part of the ending originally seen in the Theatrical version.
Program, The (1993) TL-1343 - This release includes a scene that was removed from all other releases of the film. It was cut by the studio shortly after the film’s theatrical release.
Ady has said the entire time that only the OT is canon for his edits, and when he still planned to edit the PT it would have been altered to match the OT, not the other way around. And that he won’t be editing anything to fit the Disney films since there’s no guarantee a future film won’t contradict something he did as we learn more about the new canon - best to keep it all internally consistent with the OT itself, since that’s less likely to cause issues.
This.
How would you rank the film’s in terms of best editing, best music, cinematography etc.
What are some films someone could recommend watching for someone like me who enjoyed these films?
So it’s about 10-13 minutes of extended footage correct?
What are the fans biggest complaint about TLJ?
The tape listed is 153 min and the original film is 113 min. But you did say extra footage is 10-13 min long so what’s the other 30 minutes?
What are the fans biggest complaint about TLJ?
Sea of Love (Thrillers Edition) - VHS. Extended version of the film. Nothing noted on the box. Contains deleted scenes from tv version but uncensored.
I can’t find anything on a Thrillers Edition, Could it be the Collectors Edition?
This is it…
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F372581935883
Great! Added.
It says 1 minute. That’s a gross understatement. I don’t remember how much difference it is but it’s probably closer to 10-13
Sorry, got the minutes mixed up. It should be around 40 minutes. Thanks for clarifying that.
Sea of Love (Thrillers Edition) - VHS. Extended version of the film. Nothing noted on the box. Contains deleted scenes from tv version but uncensored.
I can’t find anything on a Thrillers Edition, Could it be the Collectors Edition?
This is it…
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F372581935883
Great! Added.
Melody Time was released uncut on DVD in Australia.
Can you post a link that verifies this.
I will show a clip from this edition showing Pecos Bill smoking.
OK
The VHS, LD, and first DVD editions of Ace Ventura Pet Detective has this scene that wasn’t in the theatrical release. Subsequent DVD and Blu-Ray releases are the theatrical cut.
If the scene was realsed on DVD then it wouldn’t count.
Those shots looked very good.
Melody Time was released uncut on DVD in Australia.
Can you post a link that verifies this.
Something I’m not seeing any Prequel fanedit talk about are the designs of the PT ships compared to what you see in the OT.
I think the reason the PT ships look so much different is because the Republic was in it’s prime, everything was squeaky-clean like Star Trek
From an aesthetic level, I don’t get how you go from this
http://imgur.com/a/nTq1sTo this
http://imgur.com/a/KwY7mThe heart of what made the OT what it is were Ralph McQuarrie’s industrial designs.
This.
For Boba Fetts death, removing the goofy scream he makes when he’s hurtling through the air is a good place to start.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4xKHWQckfI&t=0m34s
Also, if you listen closely before he hurtles through the air you’ll hear “What the…?” is said in the same voice as the scream; not Jeremy Bullochs voice.
Whether if Disney/Lucasfilm created their own APT or if a group indie fan filmmakers with a million dollar budget and the best resources also did the same, what new canon, storyline etc. would we see (or would like to see) in an Alternative Prequel Trilogy?
For me, the dewback scene adds too many shots and drags the pacing down and screws up the music. I don’t mind keeping the CGI dewback in the original shot, though, but the added shots have to go.
I agree.
Very rare for a film like this to come out of the US during the late 2010s.
Is this the final version or will there possibly be more tweaks and updates to it?