TML

You know what's terrible for kids? The fact that the bad guys are portrayed as bad guys! The Death Star/Alderaan scene is a great example of this! Why doesn't Alderaan ALSO have a super laser that then shoots at the Death Star first! Wait, then that portrays Alderaan as a bad guy.... How about the Death Star ACCIDENTALLY shoots first and misses, then Alderaan shoots and misses, then the Death Star shoots and hits!

How about after Han shoots Greedo (After Greedo shoots first of course, but by accident, so it's not a bad example), Han attends Greedo's funeral and mourns Greedo's death for the rest of the movie! We can use a digital Harrison Ford!

Should I keep going? I have a whole list of these "Shooting First" jokes?

EDIT: Damn, I didn't want to post this great idea in the "Worst Edit Ideas"... I meant to post it in the adywan thread, can someone help me move this?

TheBoost said:

haljordan28 said:

Alexrd said:

haljordan28 said:

 

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

No.

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Between "Junkquels" and using "prequel lover" as a prejorative, I have to ask:

How old are you?

 GUY                    YOUR JST A PREQUEL LOVE          R! DON'T TY TO MADE A ARGUEMENT                     WITH ME, CAUSE YOR JUST A                   PREQUEL LOVER!

The Golden Idol said:

TML said:

 Thats it! I hate it when something bothers you, but you don't know what's bothering you about it, so it bothers you even more. If that makes any sense.

 I understand. But why does that bother you? It's not necessarily a mistake, Yoda could just have a (asymmetrical) crooked back.

 It just doesn't look natural and, in my opinion, that shot really makes him look like a puppet. But thats just me...

The Golden Idol said:

TML said:

ImperialFighter said:

 

Is it just me, or does Yoda look a little "off" in this scene? It's been driving me crazy trying to figure out what it is... I don't know, maybe it's just me.

 Is it because Yoda's hunch isnt in the center of his back but more to the right?

 Thats it! I hate it when something bothers you, but you don't know what's bothering you about it, so it bothers you even more. If that makes any sense.

ImperialFighter said:

 

Is it just me, or does Yoda look a little "off" in this scene? It's been driving me crazy trying to figure out what it is... I don't know, maybe it's just me.

haljordan28 said:

Alexrd said:

haljordan28 said:

KURTZ  NEVER GOT  FIRED  MUCH LESS HALF  WAY THRUGH   EPISODE 5.   HE LEFT   AFTER EMPIRE.   HE  WANTED NOTHING TO DO  WITH THE DIRECTIO   LUCAS  WAS TAKING THINGS.  THE SAME WAY  LAWERNCE  KASDAN  WANTED NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PREQUELS   AFER LUCAS GAVE HIM AN OUTLINE OF IT.

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

No.

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

 I'll be honest, I don't care for the prequels. But can't everyone have their own opinions? And him posting a link to "Whambulance" isn't saying how he's a fan of the prequels, he's just tired of hearing your complaining about then...

kenkraly2007 said:

I am finished with you guys thanks for nothing all you guys care about is making fun of me good riddance.

 Pff, who cares about family or crap like that? All I care about is Photoshoping some random guy into photos. Speaking of that.... *Opens Photoshop*

kenkraly2007 said:

don't you dare ever post my picture again. How dare you do that that is so mean. 

 I know right? You should see my mirror, it's the biggest douchebag ever!

haljordan28 said:

KURTZ  NEVER GOT  FIRED  MUCH LESS HALF  WAY THRUGH   EPISODE 5.   HE LEFT   AFTER EMPIRE.   HE  WANTED NOTHING TO DO  WITH THE DIRECTIO   LUCAS  WAS TAKING THINGS.  THE SAME WAY  LAWERNCE  KASDAN  WANTED NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PREQUELS   AFER LUCAS GAVE HIM AN OUTLINE OF IT.

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RTc32qBpAk

TV's Frink said:

TML said:

Wasn't this thread once about "Star Wars vs. Star Trek"?

Nope.  Read the thread title closer.

 Oh, silly me. It's about "Star wars v.s Star trek"... I'm sorry if I caused any confusion there, I will proceed to punishing myself by whip for my actions.

ChainsawAsh said:

• There was no Death Star at all - in the Lucas draft, there are two
• Han Solo died heroically in the climactic battle, sacrificing himself so the Rebels could win - in the Lucas draft, he's alive at the end
• Luke's sister was not Leia - in fact, he went in search of his real sister at the end of the film, setting up a sequel trilogy.  In the Lucas draft, Leia is Luke's sister, as in the final film.
• There were no Ewoks in the Kurtz/Lucas outline, while Ewoks are definitely present in the Lucas draft.
• Leia was crowned Queen at the end of the Lucas/Kurtz outline, left alone to lead the new government now that Han was dead and Luke was traveling through the galaxy in search of his sister.  Obviously, none of this is present in the Lucas draft. 

It's a damn shame that those ideas didn't end up in the final film...

Wasn't this thread once about "Star Wars vs. Star Trek"?

Leguman said:

 

So... All this is about a guy who hates the prequels, but who loves hearing himself thinking about it ?

 

 

 Thanks, Lieutenant Obvious, you've just been promoted to Captain.

Thank you Ewoks. If it wasn't for you, we would have a world full of traps that would go un-noticed. God Bless you furry, little creatures... *Salutes while single tear rolls down cheek*

haljordan28 said:

If god came down and told you the star wars universe is real and that if you wanted to go live there and  be trained as a jedi    but leaving meant you would have to give up all ties to your life here...family  friends  etc..etc    would you  go? 

Will God be nice enough to take a midichlorian test before you go off to train as a jedi? Because it would be pretty sad if your midichlorian count isn't high enough once you arrive...

Call me crazy, but from seeing his other threads, I think he's trying to tell us that he doesn't care for the prequels... Maybe if he makes 4 more threads it will make it clearer...

Bingowings said:

I hope Ady will forgive my rough vandalism but if his bridge shot can't be used in ESB:R maybe it could be reworked for a ROTJ edit, either as a set up for The Executor approaching the Death Star or Vader musing on the landing of the Tydirium.

 I really like that shot, it's a shame ady won't be using it in ESB:R. Hopefully it might make a return in RotJ:R though...

You know, theres a "Reply" button that makes you reply to a certain thread, you don't need to make a new thread for every thought you have.

TV's Frink said:

Why should we trust your friend?

 He actually knows Lucas! His dad works for Lucas and they always talk with each other! You wouldn't believe this, but my friend told me that they're making a new SEQUEL Star Wars trilogy! Insane, right?

Wow! Thanks for telling me about this! This is even more amazing than what happened to me yesterday, when my friend revealed to me that Darth Vader was ACTUALLY Luke Skywalker's dad. (Sorry to spoil it for anyone)

haljordan28 said:

If god came down and told you the star wars universe is real and that if you wanted to go live there and  be trained as a jedi    but leaving meant you would have to give up all ties to your life here...family  friends  etc..etc    would you  go?

 

I would in a heart beat.  I would miss my family to death  of course but  one day thats gonna happen anyways so hell yes I would  go  in a a new yok minute.  How about you all? go or stay?

 Well, I certainly hope for you that they have grammar schools in the Star Wars universe...

As I said before, amazing work ady. I hate to deviate from the recent clip, but I have a quick question about the Battle of Hoth. I remember seeing ady saying something about shooting/adding ground troops to the battle. Does anyone know if he means adding Snowtroopers to the shots or adding more Rebel Soldiers, or both?

adywan said:

CHRISTMAS CLIP TIME.....

I've decided to post this early because i don't know how much i will be online between now and Christmas with everything that's going on.

Enjoy :)

RAISING X-WING

 Oh ady, do you ever disappoint?

adywan said:

Lord Grievous said:

Is this amalgamation still in ESB:R?

No, That's gone. 

Really? Well thats a shame, the shot looks great. But it's your edit and in the long run, you probably know whats best for it.

Hey, is anyone else having troubles viewing the last page? I can only scroll down to half of it.....

How about we replace Boba Fett's voice with the voice of Jan-

Oh....