logo Sign In

SpenceEdit

User Group
Members
Join date
31-Jan-2011
Last activity
10-Jul-2025
Posts
899

Post History

Post
#475377
Topic
Return of the Jedi - The Spence Final Cut (Released)
Time

I intend to leave it in. Though that used to bother me, it's so ingrained in Star Wars lore now that I cannot change it. Every piece of the EU would be totally nullified, whereas right now I'm only really getting in the way of one book (Shadows of the Empire.) Being an EU fan, I like that they are related. And I actually quite like the way it plays out in this version. With nobody telling Luke that Leia is his sister, he now figures that out by himself. It's quite a nice revelation. And since the love triangle in my version is non-existant, it doesn't feel like an easy way out of that any more. It takes on more meaning. It's a bit more powerful.

But again that's my preference, and I can easily understand why people want it changed. If anyone wants to take a stab at removing that subplot from my edits and rereleasing it that way, I'd be fine with that.

And to be less cryptic about your previous question, DVD on March 1st, AVI as soon as I can get it out. Which may still be March 1st. It all depends on when I get the effect shots so I can plug them in.

 

Post
#475304
Topic
Return of the Jedi - The Spence Final Cut (Released)
Time

Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed ROTS, I'm very proud of that one. There will be a version two coming by the end of the year for that, but it won't be radically different. Just a little bit of clean up and a little work on the ending (I really wish I had removed the "NOOOOOO!!!" scene)

Commentary is done, DVD creation goes well. Waiting on those shots from Bob and L8wrtr and this thing is ready for release.

Post
#475094
Topic
Return of the Jedi - The Spence Final Cut (Released)
Time

Haha thanks! I just watched the TPM teaser a few times for inspiration. It doesn't show a lot of the changes I made, but definitely the vibe I'm going for with the edit. Basically, you're going to get the movie you think you're going to get when you watch that trailer.

MTHaslett, if you are disappointed by this edit, I will be very sad, haha.

I also agree about Mark Hamill. His work in all three movies is exceptional, but he was always overshadowed by Harrison Ford. He's more fun and has more sex appeal so i guess people took less notice of Hamill. He does a fantastic job on all accounts.

re: Ewok on the Speeder. I cut it down a little bit, yes, but some of it is still there. He gets all of the Troopers to follow him now instead of just three of them, and the last shot we see of him is him zooming away with the Troopers in pursuit. It works better, and it feels a lot less silly. Again, the Ewoks are very capable in this version.

Post
#474996
Topic
Return of the Jedi - The Spence Final Cut (Released)
Time

Eh, I think it would work on its own. I'll be trying it out tonight.

I'm working pretty hardcore on the commentary track right now, it's so much fun. It should be insightful, but I've made some pretty silly observations, especially in reference to some of the aliens at Jabba's palace. I also couldn't help but do an impression of Yoda's death over that scene. I also keep finding myself humming along to the music, so I apologize for all that in advance.

There's also, rather humorously, one shot of boba Fett still left in the movie. He's still pretty far in the background and only appears for like 2 seconds, but he is there. It's not a big deal to me, as again, he's in the background. I just couldn't get rid of him there due to the framing of the shot, and he's almost unnoticeable. So you can play Where's Waldo with him, haha.

Any more ideas people have that they may want me to consider, speak now or forever hold your peace. By middle of next week, I want this thing done so I can focus solely on DVD authoring and finishing up the features.