logo Sign In

SpenceEdit

User Group
Members
Join date
31-Jan-2011
Last activity
10-Jul-2025
Posts
899

Post History

Post
#482852
Topic
Return of the Jedi - The Spence Final Cut (Released)
Time

Oh, and there's been some comments about the scene where Han and Leia get captured and Luke senses that they are in trouble. I know that moment isn't perfect, but that footage is being completely repurposed for something it wasn't intended for, so I was a little limited in what footage actually exists. I did what I could with it, and tried to have the moment resemble the scene in Empire when Leia sense Luke after the Vader duel. It's kind of impossible to make that moment perfect, but I'm happy that it works well enough.

Also the pace at Jabba's was very tricky. It didn't make sense to spend a lot of time with the droids getting into Jabba's, as he's already been established in an earlier scene. When Luke finally arrives, it's time to get down to business, so I didn't want that to take too long. In addition, I really like not knowing why Bib allows Luke to enter, and then it gets revealed later that he's being mind tricked. It's kind of a fun moment and allows for a good reaction from Jabba.

When transitioning from Tattooine to the fleet, I wish there was an additional scene to put in there, but it didn't really exist. Again, a lot of these issues with the pacing at the beginning are a byproduct of my lack of material. I just had to do the best I could with what I had. Being a rather radical departure from the original, it was never going to be perfect. But in the spirit of doing something interesting, I'll settle for it just being "good."

Post
#482850
Topic
Duel of the Fates (* unfinished project *)
Time

Just cut a test of my prologue scene. Really cool. I need to do some narration tests as well.

My plan is that, in the next two weeks, to release a workprint version of the first 15 minutes or so, just to show what this is really going to be like. It won't be final, but it's narration, effects, new music, the whole thing. Think of it as a proof of concept.

Post
#482789
Topic
Return of the Jedi - The Spence Final Cut (Released)
Time
You just pinpointed something I love about Star Wars. I think I touched on it in thee commentary, but I love how Star Wars means different things to different people. All of the cuts and changes you found unnecessary I found completely essential. Cutting back on Han didn't bother me because I feel he was terribly handled in the original, but some of the things that are missing bother you. Its why Star Wars is so great. Thank you very much for your review and I'm glad you enjoyed it. If you decide to do a second viewing, I would suggest listening to it with the commentary. It might make more sense of my choices, whether you agree or disagree.