Well, I'm not really worrying about the sound effect editing at this stage, just trying to get the structure of the edit in place. That will come later.
I'm going to recommend Kerr's Dark Force Rising, Stankpac, and actually my own edit of Ep. III as the ones I like to watch the most. (notice I didn't say best... I tried to cut Ep. III into a version I'd enjoy, and I was pretty successful, I do enjoy watching that edit.) Kerr's, though short, really changes a lot of things in a very interesting way. L8wrtr's version is sounding more and more interesting all the time, so that one will be good once finished too.
I'd say go for variety! The best thing about Star Wars is that everyone has a different idea of what makes it good for them. The different interpretations are endlessly interesting.
Braxietel said:
However, I was wondering if any sound effects or dialogue would be present in the final cut of the scene, it just seems to me that perhaps the use of Lightsaber sounds and the like might help the music tie into the visuals more. Anyway, just at thought. Really super stuff so far.
Yes.
greenpenguino said:
If you are going to use sound in the lightsaber fights, how about using the original clashing sounds from the original trilogy
Yes.
Thanks for the feedback!
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=0Q39QY6C
There she goes.
Well if you are in the US it should work, as it seems to be working fine for me.
I don't really know what happened with this faneditor, I don't know any of the history, but his cutlist sounds very interesting. I'm quite curious to watch this.
I enjoyed your creative use of foul language especially. Something about dicks that you said made me laugh for like ten minutes.
Yay!
Well done, gentlemen. Well done.
If this is not an April Fools joke, I think I will probably pack up my things and go. Any site that would ban such an important member for making an April Fools joke in his own thread is not a site I'd like to be connected to.
But the ridiculousness of that last sentence makes me think even more that it is an April Fools Joke.
This really is getting ridiculous, isn't it? Good fun though.
On a serious note, I really hope we've got this right and it is an April Fools Joke. It did read relatively convincing on the ESB:R thread, but at the same time I feel like Moth3r would've chimed in (and banned people from) this thread at some point to clarify. I'm leaning heavily toward joke, but I wouldn't be shocked if we've got it all wrong either.
See, I told you bloodnosethepirate was one of my sock accounts!
Leonardo, you sir just made my evening. Thank you very much for that.
stob this madness? that sounds a lot like "stab" which is a personal attack.
Ban.
I'm actually Bloodnosethepirate and ChainsawAsh as well.