Smithers

Jeebus said:
In the dinner scene, I think you should really find a way to cut “I don’t want to you to race it’s awful I die every time you do it,” because that line is Tommy Wiseau levels of bad.

I like to keep the emphasis on “Watto makes you” because in my edit you’ll want to sympathise for Anakin, he’s forced into supporting his mother

I don’t know how I feel about the montage of the clone army. I feel like when you start showing the clones, you shouldn’t cut back to the senate. If it’s necessary to make the timing work, I think you should at least put clapping audio when you cut to those 2 Vurk.

I’ll try clapping sounds and the music is also too loud in that scene. I like to show the Senate approving Palpatine’s decision

Here’s a preview clip of a few scenes from my TPM edit. It will contain these scenes (note that these are a proof-of-concept, not finished products):
-Darth Maul lands on Tatooine (new music and new footage from fan film)
-The dinner scene (rearranged and rescored)
-Leaving Tatooine (added deleted scene, rescored and trimmed fight to remove confusing close up shots)
-Meeting on coruscant (Qui-Gon says “Obi-Wan will train him” rather than taking on Anakin himself, -Mace Windu states that the Queen has already left and orders the Jedi to follow her to Naboo in secret, Amidala is shown leaving)
-Senate meeting from AOTC (Palpatine is elected chancellor, Jar Jar is redubbed, and a montage of -the clone army is shown)
-Jedi on the blockade (Neimoidans redubbed, Qui-Gon says “this dispute” rather than “trade dispute”)
-Qui-Gon’s death (rescored, trimmed, and rearranged)
-Finale (rescored with the Shadow of the Empire OST and trimmed to exclude Gungans)

https://vimeo.com/163052348

Many sound effects are missing from these clips because they are very rough, give me your thoughts and suggestions. Thanks!

On another note, I’ll soon be recording all of Anakin’s dialogue once I buy a shotgun microphone. The young actor whom I’m working with has experience doing school plays, commercials, etc. and I think he’ll do great in the part.

My favourite moment is at 3:05

Could you send me the Episode 3 complete score? I only have Episode 2

This is a pretty cool idea! Can I use some of this in my fanedits? It may prove useful.

Swazzy said:

timdiggerm said:

Now that they’ve got Zod out of the way, it would make sense for the sequel to feature Luthor, Darkseid for the JL film, and Doomsday for the post-JL film.

This post greatly amuses me in retrospect

My bet is that timdiggerm loved BvS

Ryan-SWI said:

JJ looked very un-amused.

This still takes the cake: https://youtu.be/1zjAtb2Nqmg

MalàStrana said:

My all time favorites (more or less):

The Force Awakens
Jurassic World
Terminator Genysis
Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome
Tim Burton’s Alice in Wonderland
The last crusade
Ghostbuster II
Men in Black II
…

Those vary from good to ok. If you want to make a joke about bad movies then I’d suggest not throwing generally considered good ones into the list

Jackpumpkinhead said:

I’ll just leave this here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fkXx3snq_CQ

Awesome!

I don’t see how having a purple saber makes you seem darker, the only thing it does IMO is make the person wielding it look stupid

LuckyGungan2001 said:

TFA is nearly equal with ROTJ, but it has more of a sense of fun and adrenaline, which makes it an easier watch.

Agreed, there’s nothing bad about TFA overall whereas ROTJ has some pretty bad parts (Ewoks, “I’ve always known”, “A certain point of view”, etc.) I still love ROTJ but I don’t think TFA has anything that bad or stupid, we have nitpicks but it’s a good movie overall

SilverWook said:

Or is it? I think I suggested he say Oh Hai! when he breaks the fourth wall once before. 😉

“Oh hai! How’s your sex life?”

the '97 jabba is at least entertaining because of how terrible it is, the 2004 Jabba is just plain bad. It makes me wonder why they didn’t use the same model and textures as the one in TPM, it looks better than both of them

IKnowWhatYouDidLastSummer said:

TV’s Frink said:

So you like TFA?

No, of course I hate it which is why I put it one step above another star wars film that I actually like in a top 6 star wars things list.

Seriously how dumb are you?

No, of course Frink was serious, he never makes sarcastic posts.

Seriously how dumb are you?

irritating*

emanswfan said:

Wait, Star Wars was at one point going to be R-rated? Was it just that Leia scene

What leia scene?

The phone friendly theatres are cool for one reason: now we don’t have to see phones in our theatres. Every other argument in the article is completely stupid but I’ll take it for our cause

It says Episode VII in the title crawl (trust me, it’s the first thing I looked for) and it says VII here: http://www.starwars.com/films

TV’s Frink said:
-Kyro Ren

Shockingly common actually

It’s not out yet guys…

suspiciouscoffee said:

I’ve never read any EU outside of the Thrawn trilogy (not because I don’t want to, but because I can never find any pre-PT EU at bookstores here)

That said, if a Google search is anything to go off of, I’d say Starkiller easily.

Same here, although I bought splinter of the mind’s eye before reading the Thrawn Trilogy but that’s it

I like the enders game movie! It’s almost word-for-word to the book save for a few subplots being removed and an underdeveloped relationship between Ender and his siblings.

The hobbit movies on the other hand are a mixed bag, part 1 spends way too much time doing absolutely nothing, the second one is pretty good save for a few really dumb moments and the third one is a bloated cgi-filled mess with tensionless action. Watch spence’s version, it solves all of my issues with it

you could describe it in your first post rather than exclude the majority of us

Thank you for banning him, I was actually excited about updates on the edit, not updates on this guy’s thoughts

Oh crap, he normally has links in his videos, he doesn’t here 😦