logo Sign In

SilverWook

User Group
Members
Join date
9-Dec-2004
Last activity
6-Apr-2023
Posts
22,080

Post History

Post
#367122
Topic
Forget about the ridiculous and unnecessary changes...
Time
Jonno said:

 

They're on the Dr Gonzo laserdisc transfers (maybe others too - Editdroid?) IIRC they're fairly intermittent, rather than wall-to-wall observations, but I suppose commentaries weren't all that common in 1993 and the potential had yet to be fully realised.

I agree that after-the-fact commentaries are generally best, as are those recorded 'live' with one participant or a small group (I'm not sure who these cut 'n' paste jobs are supposed to impress - as someone already mentioned, it's not as if we haven't heard it all before).

Criterion had been doing commentary tracks for several years by 1993. (They invented the idea!) If they couldn't get someone who was still living, they got the best historian to discuss a particular film. In the case of Robinson Crusoe on Mars, they made good use of an interview the late director had given in the 1970's. His remarks were synched up to relevant scenes.

The "Definitive Collection" was rightly razzed for the long gaps of nothing and not getting remarks from key personnel no longer working at ILM. Not to mention some of the worst packaging in the history of the Laserdisc format. ;)

Post
#366956
Topic
Info Wanted: ESB/ROTJ Audio Mix questions...
Time

That's interesting if it's the case. They would have had to make a new "glass master" disc to add a digital track to any reissue. I don't know what video format the master tapes would have been at the time. Could they have simply added a digital track and left  the original analog alone?

Are you listening to the analog with the CX noise reduction on? Leaving it off can often make things sound a little different. Some later Pioneer models are guilty of having lower analog output to make the digital sound "better".

Post
#366550
Topic
Forget about the ridiculous and unnecessary changes...
Time
skyjedi2005 said:

Also people praise Gary Kurtz but other than being involved with The dark Crystal and Return to OZ after leaving Lucasfilm what has he done?

Not even the Godfather has had the impact on generations of people that the original star wars trilogy has.

 

Gary's latest project. Maybe you've heard of it. ;)

http://www.5-25-77.com/

It's sad that when the AFI picked Star Wars to represent the entire 1970's for a retrospective of movies made in the 20th century, Lucas missed the whole point, and mandated they show the special edition instead. :(

Post
#364696
Topic
ROTS: Dogpile Anakin!!
Time
fishmanlee said:
SilverWook said:

I thought the younglings were only ever given the "safety scissors" version of lightsabers to begin with? The blades are too weak to do much damage?

 

isnt that EU stuff?

and i guess GL's relatives must be spoiled cuz his [grandson?] killed some clones

I'm was thinking of the little ones we saw Yoda training in Episode II. Who would be insane enough to give a six year old a full blown lightsaber? Padawans would be cutting off limbs daily!  I'm sure the older kids like the one who was fighting clones get the real thing, or else he grabbed someone else's saber.

 

Post
#363221
Topic
Info: "making of star wars" film reel set - for sale on ebay
Time

I'm sure they were. It's just most old copies that pop up tend to be rentals and are worn out. The Magnetic video label release was generally not for sale.

Putting one hour on a 16mm reel means a bigger reel. And apparently not all projectors can handle bigger reels. Note how all the 16mm Star Wars prints we've seen are all three reelers.

Post
#363209
Topic
Info: "making of star wars" film reel set - for sale on ebay
Time

The Japanese LD has usually been expensive to get. The early 80's LD is easily one of the worst rotters in the history of the format.

I have all the Japanese making of LD's except this one. All those releases have Japanese subtitles.

The last VHS release was a cereal mail-away promo that inexplicably replaced William Conrad's original narration! (This has the Vader face art.) The original came out very early in the days of home video, and finding a playable copy would be a crap shoot.

It this film print isn't pink city, it would be interesting to make a hybrid version with all the movie clips in proper widescreen. :)

Post
#362756
Topic
Star Tours - preservation dvd (Released)
Time

They make new prints of ride films on a regular basis. (But probably run them to death.) There is more than one copy around! The original negatives ought to be sitting in a vault at Disney or ILM.

It's a safe bet the ride makeover will put in HDTV screens and be able to switch "destinations", so I doubt the original footage will vanish completely either.

I gave someone on here a copy of my capture of the Gil Gerard special several years back. Wonder if that's what out there now?

Post
#362548
Topic
Star Wars/Hidden Fortress
Time

The problem is nobody gets the difference between paying homage to something and ripping it off.

Back in 1977, the letters column of the late Cinefantastique magazine was full of rants from cranky people listing everything Lucas "stole" from. The fact Tatooine was a desert planet, and there was a reference to "spice" had some Dune fans pissed! IIRC, everything from Forbidden Planet to the Lensman novels were also mentioned. Others wondered what happened to the Lucas that had made THX-1138!

(Of course, some less informed critics would later claim the 1984 Dune adaptation was ripping off Star Wars. Go fig.)

Far fewer people ever catch the homage to the WWII epic "The Dam Busters" in the final Death Star Battle. Or that the medal ceremony looks like something else from WWII!

If any SF film is a Kurosawa clone, it's Battle Beyond the Stars. ;)