Ripplin

ImperialFighter said:

Personally, I've advised certain various friends and their brats who hadn't yet seen any of the Star Wars saga, to start with 'A New Hope' (Adywan's version of course) and the rest of the Original Trilogy, before seeing the Prequels, regardless of the numerical order.... :)

It would certainly help people to understand how vastly disappointed we (as long-time OT fans) all were with the PT.

Yeah, I wouldn't mind the number of AT-ATs staying the same. Kinda shows their arrogance, like "as if they'd beat these indestructible machines. Let's just send a few down and get this over with." But adding in another AT-ST here and there could be neat.

And to Shadow, I completely agree about the design element of the PT. It's my favorite part of it, in fact. I don't like it all, but I do like the fact that with each succesive movie, the machines and troopers got closer in design to the OT ones. That's something I looked forward to going into Episode III. And I have a feeling you will definitely see some of your suggestions put into the film.

I love that you're adding images to go with your suggestions, Shadow! :)

That first example with the Falcon looks great! As for the prequel machines, "nooooooooo!" An interesting idea, but certainly not my cup of tea. ;)

Wow, 500 is great! Thanks, Jay. Very nice! :)

And yes, I think the PM box search would be good. Sometimes we'll have a ton of "Re: [whatever]" messages, and you have to go through all of them just to find one link or tidbit of information or whatever. Things could be sped up tremendously in some cases.

adywan said:

My thought on the whole stardestroyer placement issue is that all the stardestroyers have all just returned from deploying the probe droids around the various systems and are now regrouping with the Executor, so they would be facing all directions and not uniform in placement

Just what I've always thought. The SSD is like a homebase and the rest are just coming and going, meaning they'd be facing in different directions. :)

Oh, and Ady, I would love to contribute towards the monitor and whatever else. My job future is a little fuzzy at the moment, but I'll try when things are clearer! I certainly would have done so towards the HDD a while back had I known at the time.

And DarthBo, thanks for the space slug. I was away all day and didn't get to respond. :)

classicrock1169 said:

Covenant said:

classicrock1169 said:

So I decided to watch Adywan's edition first. :) It was great looked very great very clear the lasers were very defined I enjoyed it very much. Thanks Adywan I can't wait till the Empire Strikes Back I might even hold off watching ESB all together (I have never seen it before) till your version comes out even though I have already bought the 2 dvd set.

 

Just so you know... generally speaking... Empire is thought to be THE best of the entire saga...

 

Generally speaking...

 

;' )

So do you think I should wait till adywan releases his version or should I just go ahead and watch the version I have. I might be expecting to much if I don't what do you think.

Even in SE form, ESB is the least messed up of the three. Even Adywan has said it is already a nearly perfect movie (which it is) and his edit will be much more cosmetic than Star Wars was. So, by all means, DON'T WAIT! ;) You'll kick yourself if you do.

Having gotten up to over 140 total messages already (down to around 120 after deleting a bunch), I'm wondering what the significance of your "at the moment, 200 total messages" is. ;)

More would be great, but if it's not possible, at least 200 is a monstrous amount compared to how it was before. Heh.

Looks great! :) Though, the way it's positioned, that shadow looks kinda funny now, like it's joined with the guns. Haha. It looks like a four-eyed alien slug or something. Maybe I shouldn't have said anything...

vbangle said:

Bad media.

I've burned a couple of dozen Memorex DLs and have never made a coaster, so to me, they're not "bad" per sé. I would never recommend them to anyone, though. ;) It also helps that I never burn them at max speed, either. That's a problem that many just don't seem to understand.

Yeah, I'm sure most people wouldn't be bothered if the stripes on his pants stayed as is. What we really need to focus on is adding references to the Kaiburr crystal!

GoodMusician said:

there's an AT-AT that shoots a soldier and then it shoots the shield generator... do you think it would HONESTLY take the time to do that?

Odd, to be sure, but I've always liked it, partly because of the cool laser sounds and how busy that area looks. Besides, it takes all of two seconds for the whole thing.

I wish this was April 1st...

Very sad news indeed. Maybe the responses weren't exactly overwhelming like they were with Revisited, but there was definitely a strong fanbase for these edits. As others have said, this was one of the more interesting ideas we've ever heard of for Star Wars edits. I hope something can still be done with these. Maybe ADigitalMan can do something... He knows the score.

Anyway, thanks and I wish you guys all the best.