logo Sign In

Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda

User Group
Members
Join date
20-Sep-2006
Last activity
30-May-2025
Posts
3,220
Web Site
http://www.hardbat.com/puggo

Post History

Post
#607307
Topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Time

Dr.Olds, try to understand that the members of this forum are working very hard to do restoration and preservation work on Star Wars.  The purpose of this site isn't to crack and distribute films that are available.  Rather than coming here expecting people to give you things and then complaining when it's not easy, try understanding that most of the folks here are working on restoration efforts, not distribution efforts.  So be nice, and be patient.

I don't even have Harmy's disk yet, and I'm one of the oldest and most active members of the forum.

Post
#598840
Topic
GOUT Bugs (and DUDSbtEoEE)
Time

I do consider the non-anamorphic format to be a bug.  Why?  Because industry standard at the time was to release widescreen movies anamorphically. It shouldn't have been necessary to state that it was anamorphic; a reasonable presumption is that it would be.  It's also the first thing that fan edits correct when using GOUT as a base - something LFL should have done from the start. So it is obviously for all practical purposes a bug that should have, and could at zero cost have been, fixed.

If a DVD of Wizard of Oz came out and it turned out to be black and white, would it not be a mistake because the label didn't say "in color"?  No, certain things are just presumed.  If it skips, would it not be a mistake because the disk didn't say "won't skip"?

Perhaps if the disc included the label - "disclaimer: outdated crappy non-anamorphic f-ed up transfer", then there wouldn't be any bugs!