OzoneSherrif

in ROTJ the script had extra dialogue when force ghost Obi-Wan is talking to Luke on Dagobah. eventually he mentions that Owen was his brother.

i'm glad it was cut out it seems more natural that Owen was Anakin's brother. i can't recall anything in the OT that contradicts that assumption.

fishmanlee said:

the clone wars TV series isnt presented in timeline order

i hadn't noticed.

Diego said:

So far in this season we've had Greedo, Tarkin and Sy Snootles from the OT, Qui-Gon and Darth Maul from the PT, have they run out of ideas??

How long til we get a three episode arc featuring Stupid Kid Han Solo?

pretty likely considering young orphan boy Solo living with the wookies on Kashyyyk was in the script for ROTS. Lucas may want to rectify that mistake.

I always had the impression that Tarkin had some familiarity with Obi-Wan. since in ANH he's like "Obi-Wan?! surely he must be dead by now"

I'm sure it's been mentioned but it's probably at the tip top of my list of needed fixes.

Vader's severed hand wound that isn't fooling anyone. you can clearly see the actor's wrist bent... i can't believe they didn't catch that. i noticed that when i was little. and what a time to be taken out of the movie ugh

Yep, even with Broderick as the star.

awww

i don't ever want kids though

Why was Vader giving him shit for not having the Death Star completed already? just being an asshole i guess

brash_stryker said:

Speaking of sounds, I've recently bought 'The Sounds of Star Wars' book. The one with the (surprisingly good) attached sound module. I'm at this very moment ripping all 256 sounds off it via the audio jack. Now obviously I don't know where to mention this as it's not just relevant to the prequels - there are sounds from all 6 films and some from The Clone Wars too, but would anyone be interested in me making it a download? There are sounds in here I've never found anywhere else.

Would it be worth making a dedicated sound effects thread where I could assemble an archive of the sounds I've gathered and other people could add to it?

yes plz! :)

adywan said:

The one thing that makes the troopers looks really fake is when they have their helmets off. Placing a real head on a CG body just didn't work and the ones where they are fully CG their faces looks so fake.  Why the hell didn't they just build a few costumes for these shots?

I'm hopefully going down the real-trooper route when i get to the PT. Also they won't be clones of Jango. Jango will have been hired to recruit the best mercenaries from all over the galaxy for the cloning process so there would be a variety of clones and you can have different voices, which would tie that into the OT where the stormtroopers don't all sound the same

cool. i'm guessing you'll recreate the Clone armor as seen in the prequels when you go with live troopers? so that they will mesh with all the CG troops.

i've always disliked the Clone helmet designs which were basically a hybrid of the Mandalorian & Stormtrooper helmets. one a little more Mandalorian the other a little more Stormtrooperish. seemed like a strange unnecessary connection considering that there is no resemblance between Boba Fett's helmet and Stormtrooper helmets.

The Clone Wars series would be fun (aside from the boring episodes centered around politics or extremely minor characters) if it didn't ruin continuity all the time.

as it is i can't reconcile any of it with the original trilogy. or the prequels lol

I would have liked to have seen R2 and C3PO make an appearance somewhere just once.

Boba Fett too. a squad of Mandalorians in shiny armor. holy shit look there one of them is Boba Fett! and that's all you see of him. he isn't RUINED.

Anchorhead said:

TheBoost said:

Lucas dies. World mourns. Consumer and liscensee confidence in the "SW" brand drops.

The OOT is released in a pristine restored BluRay condition. Rereleased to theaters. Sells millions, revitalizing company.

Great - right about the time I turn 65....

"I haven't watched Star Wars since... oh, before you were born" 

 

I can't stand the prequels even in fan edits. sure it's better when the most offensive parts are removed and scenes are trimmed but still that's a far cry from making them entertaining.

i used to not ever being able to understand Yoda on his death bed

I wonder why in the ESB duel Vader remarks "impressive, most impressive" when all Luke did was a simple force jump. seriously that was impressive? what about all the commonplace force powers the Jedi flaunted all the time as depicted in the prequels? not a big deal.

of course building your own light saber will get you a "INDEED you are powerful as the emperor has foreseen" out of Vader too.

Thing that irks me the most is when the prequel Jedi constantly twirl the lightsaber in one hand for no reason. i guess it's just fun

beautiful work!

Yep it'll be my go-to version whenever i want to see ROTJ!

ewwww is that liquefied brains coming out of the eye socket?!

Been watching the Return of the Jedi: Dan Edit (by Yads)

does he post here? he cut out a lot of the silliness. it's awesome.

anyway, i just now realized that when Stormtroopers & Biker Scouts speak none of them have the clicks right before you hear their voice and the click when they're done speaking! small detail yet very important in my opinion.

nice holograms.

but i think overall the PT overdoes it on the holograms. they're everywhere. if some could be edited out it would be nice. it wasn't even necessary for that alien to appear as a hologram to the battle droids. plus how is that hologram getting beamed there? there's no hologram emitter base. it's just a hallway.

it needs to be in Adywan's edit. but he should edit down Vader's lines.

wow that great. should have been in there since the beginning

but the laser that hits that cannon completely destroys it. maybe it already came that way. like how their ships are dented and dirty too.