- Post
- #684024
- Topic
- Fall to the Dark Side?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/684024/action/topic#684024
- Time
"It turns out that your thread here is only mostly dead!"
But yeah, as long as this is being debated again, I'll explain the idea I originally posted here (Post 4)
Anakin's turn should not have happened slowly as people have suggested. It should have been fast, for Luke's near-turn to the Dark Side was fast. It is important that we as the audience not know precisely how Anakin falls only when Luke does, so that we can identify with Luke in the OT and share his fear of the unknown.
The path to Anakin's fall should be subtle, so subtle for the audience watching the prequels that they would at first think it impossible for Anakin to have fallen. It's all in the framing of the story. In Episode 4, Luke displays grief and rage at the loss of his relatives and Obi-wan. We should sympathize with this, not be fearful lest Luke turn to the Dark Side. So the dangers of the Dark side should not be revealed until Episode 5. The prequels show only the light side of the Force, a power without a downside. Naturally the audience would then sympathize with Anakin as he feels anger and as he quests for more power. He has power by Episode 3, yet Obi-wan has failed to sufficiently warn him about the power of the Dark Side, lest it interfere with his development. Anakin's powers are sorely needed after all, and there is no time to do things the "right" way. So Obi-wan fails as a teacher.
Finally Anakin confronts Palpatine at the end of Episode 3, knowing full well that the new Emperor is entirely evil. The Emperor however plays on Anakin's fears, and in his domain of evil, he forces Anakin to fight his own worst enemy, as Luke fought his manifestation of Vader in the cave on Dagobah. This emanation is the sum total of Anakin's fears, and it overwhelms him. The Emperor claims that this mysterious cloaked warrior is the pupil that Obi-wan failed to fully train, and from a certain point of view, this is true. The Emperor gives this figure the most evil sounding name he can think of: Darth Vader, so as to play on Anakin's fears. Finally, as Episode 3 closes, we see a cloaked figure step out from the Emperor's palace, his face darkened and mysterious. We assume that it is Obi-wan's secret apprentice, now revealed as the most powerful Jedi in the galaxy. It is only in Episode 5 that we have the information to understand the truth, for when Luke fights Vader on Dagobah, we realize the illusion of Episode 3 for what it is. The Emperor does not try and pull the same trick on Luke because he knows that Luke has already fought most of his inner demons, and only by goading him to anger will they succeed in turning him.