logo Sign In

MinchD36

User Group
Members
Join date
8-Aug-2022
Last activity
7-Jul-2026
Posts
84

Post History

Post
#1687733
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

I feel the Sequels would be better received if they revealed in Starfighter that Rey had become a Sith but that wont happen i feel Starfighter is in danger of flopping at the box office if Rey appears doesnt Lucasfilm know that the reason Star Wars is losing popularity is because of the Sequels? not mentioning them and pretending they dont exist would be best for everyone just cast Amy Adams as Mara Jade dont mention Rey or Kylo Ren and everyone will be happy next year when they see Starfighter

Post
#1687731
Topic
Maul: Shadow Lord
Time

Honestly the Darth Maul vs Darth Vader battle felt forced and rushed it would have been better if Vader had appeared in another season because when he did it felt like a desperate attempt to get viewers and Filoni is afraid to use Darth Talon we know Lucas wanted Talon as a villain and i dont understand why they dont just say that Devon is actually Darth Talon i watched the show for her

Post
#1687730
Topic
Maul Shadow Lord was released at the wrong time
Time

Devon should have been Darth Talon i hope thats the case in the next season i also would have liked the show to be live action i would have loved to see Darth Maul again in live action i honestly feel that Star Wars is losing a lot of popularity these days because shows like Andor and Maul Shadow Lord would have been more watched in another era

Post
#1687727
Topic
What do you LIKE about the EU?
Time

The Clone Wars Multimedia Project is more faithful to the movies Anakin doesnt have a Padawan he is just a Knight until the end of the war Darth Maul doesnt return General Grievous is a feared villain Ventress is a Rattataki in the EU Dooku is more of an Anti Hero the entire story of Jango Fett and the Clones being trained by Mandalorians the Darth Plagueis novel and Cloak of Deception helped improve the Prequels

Post
#1687726
Topic
What do you HATE about the EU?
Time

Some Post ROTJ stories havent aged well and there is a lot of filler but the Jedi Academy Trilogy all the stories featuring Mara Jade and the New Jedi Order are incredible i also like Legacy of the Force even though i know its divisive in the fandom and i dont like Star Wars Legacy comics that much anymore SWTOR game lore is very bad and ruined KOTOR games lore the Disney EU novels like High Republic and Thrawn Disney novels are good but everything related to the Sequels era is very bad

Post
#1687721
Topic
Which one do you like more? The Prequels or the Sequels? And why?
Time

I prefer the Original Prequels not the Filoni and Lucas version with TCW Ahsoka and the Resurrected Darth Maul im talking about the Original Clone Wars the Multimedia Project the Sequels for me dont exist i like Disney material but the Sequels never happened i wouldnt be surprised if Disney Retconned the Sequels if the Star Wars movies continue to flop at the box office

Post
#1568219
Topic
What do you LIKE about the EU?
Time

I like how the Old Expanded Universe Star Wars felt very nerdy was like a true Sci-Fi saga that could compete with Star Trek Dune or Warhammer 40k there was a passion for the stories they felt memorable in Disney Expanded Universe the novels are very meh very generic and not so memorable stories my favorite era in the EU was the Yuuzhan Vong War the New Jedi Order are my Sequels to the OT

Post
#1568216
Topic
I think Ulic Qel-Droma's character was the EU's version of Anakin
Time

Exar Kun being a Sith using a blue lightsaber is very similar to how Anakin after falling to the dark side in Episode 3 used his blue lightsaber to destroy the Jedi Darth Maul lightsaber was inspired in Exar Kun lightsaber so there is a possibility that Lucas took the character of Ulic Qel Droma as a base or inspiration for Anakin Skywalker in the Prequels

Post
#1568214
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

I think Anakin Skywalker fall would have been much more tragic if Anakin had been a character very similar to Luke the Anakin of Lucas Prequels is a kind of a jerk and arrogant that it is difficult to feel empathy for him i know that in TCW they try to fix this but i think that if Anakin had been a more likeable character his transformation into Darth Vader would have been a lot more tragic i think Lucas dropped the ball with the Prequels the idea was good but it needed a better execution but well Disney Sequels are worse than Lucas Prequels so at least i admire Lucas creativity