logo Sign In

MeBeJedi

User Group
Members
Join date
10-Mar-2003
Last activity
10-Feb-2025
Posts
4,879

Post History

Post
#91356
Topic
Another Q for you audio experts - Stereo vs. Dolby Surround
Time
"but a DVD will play without a menu."

While this is technically true, I'd love to see you count how many DVDs you know of that DON'T have menus. (Personally, I can't think of any). A DVD without menus is the rare exception, not the norm. Your point is not incorrect, but it misses the reality of the situation: DVD manufacturers continue to list it alongside such things as director commentaries and deleted scenes, as if it's a real biggie, and it really isn't.

Now, if I recall, there was a DVD without chapter stops, but that was at the specific request of the director. I think it was a David Lynch film.
Post
#91200
Topic
Another Q for you audio experts - Stereo vs. Dolby Surround
Time
"So how come some videos say HiFi stereo, and some say Dolby Surround?"

Advertising, pure and simple. Terms are just being used interchangeably, just like different DVD companies use "Anamorphic", "Widescreen", "16x9" and "Enhanced for widescreen" to describe the same thing (and occasionally inaccurately.)

I love how many current DVDs refer to "menus" as a "feature" on the back of the case. It's not a feature...it's the standard. It's like saying "Buy our car, it's got TIRES!" LOL
Post
#91201
Topic
Who has caved?
Time
"Well why not make it that way in the first place?"

Actually, he claims he did, but it just wasn't as clear as it is now. (Yeah, right.)

"It was mostly due to changing public attitude about violence."

See above. BTW, if you've been keeping up with spoilers, ROTS is going to have far more graphic violence than any of the other films had. Are you saying the public attitude has changed back now? Doesn't mean Lucas should restore the original scene?
Post
#90625
Topic
Ratings creep and the rhodian who flunked out of the stormtrooper academy.
Time
Yeah, hate to say it, but it doesn't stick. Lucas and Spielberg both wanted to make their films more kiddie-proof, which is ironic, since ROTS may be heading into PG-13 territory. FBI agents holding guns in ET wasn't going to affect the rating, and shorter burns in the detention center wasn't going to do it either.

Lucas simply wanted these changes. No one was going to change the rating.