logo Sign In

Lord Haseo

This user has been banned.

User Group
Banned Members
Join date
19-Apr-2013
Last activity
2-Oct-2017
Posts
4,841

Post History

Post
#1007978
Topic
Is a <em>Star Wars</em> movie your favorite movie?
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:

The Leigh Brackett draft of TESB didn’t have Vader as Luke’s father. That’s a strong enough indicator to me that Lucas hadn’t thought the idea up yet.

Well that draft was obviously written post STAR WARS so it’s possible he could have strict orders not to include that bit.

Also this is pure conjecture but perhaps the “No, I am your father” plot twist was a throw away idea that he had while writing STAR WARS and revisited the idea while making ESB.

EDIT:

Density beat me to it dammit

Post
#1007938
Topic
Is a <em>Star Wars</em> movie your favorite movie?
Time

dahmage said:

Lord Haseo said:

dahmage said:

TV’s Frink said:

I’m 77% to 80% sure I saw ESB first because it was on HBO.

clever, but not asking for love. this is a good post.

Well he’s getting it whether he wants to or not. Accepting my love and letting it fester inside him is something that’s within his control.

lol. you know, after i posted this i realized that it looked like i was dissing your post somehow. i wasn’t. but it did obviously affect my wording.

I actually didn’t fully understand what you were trying to convey. I just picked the most likely scenario and ran with it 😄

Post
#1007924
Topic
Is a <em>Star Wars</em> movie your favorite movie?
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:
Not only does the franchise’s long slide into universe-shrinkage

I don’t think one should blame something good for how it was used in future installments or other franchises. A good example is the fact that Vader was such an awesome villain that George literally made him Space Jesus in the PT. Should we blame Vader being awesome for that?

and revisionism begin with TESB

Elaborate please.

but TESB is very different in tone and feel from SW; many fans may have fallen in love with Star Wars for the optimistic, swashbuckling nature of the original film, and may have found the grittier, grimmer nature of TESB a harsh, unwelcome departure from that.

I can see that but there were plenty moments of levity and STAR WARS was clearly made to be the 1st act in a 3 act story. To go in another direction would have been George not staying true to his original vision. That’s just how I see it though.

Post
#1007840
Topic
Rogue One * <em>Spoilers</em> * Thread
Time

I think the line about taking chances should have been saved for the movie. It was a pretty strong line of dialogue.

EDIT:

Speaking of Jyn, I really think I’m going to like her. Having her family ripped away from her, her saying she’s not used to people sticking around when shit hits the fan and her overall demeanor in the scenes where she’s rallying the troops are all things that will make me certain that this is a character I can get emotionally invested in.

Post
#1007811
Topic
Is a <em>Star Wars</em> movie your favorite movie?
Time

joefavs said:

I get it when it’s folks who were around for the original releases.

Yeah, maybe some people were so blown away by STAR WARS that literally nothing can ever top it in their minds. I’m always wanting to experience the next best thing so my mindset doesn’t allow for such mental barriers

You (I’m assuming) and I grew up with an OT box set.

Not exactly. I watched the OT in it’s entirety for the first time when I was 16. I had seen TPM, AOTC, ROTS, SW and the end of ROTJ (my Mom really fucked up with this one) when I was younger) before I had seen ESB and the entirety of ROTJ.

We first saw them in rapid succession and they’ve always seemed like parts of a whole. I imagine living through a three-year gap between installments gives you a much different perspective. I can definitely see how people might only dig the original, especially since it functions so well as a standalone story.

TV’s Frink said:

I’m 77% to 80% sure I saw ESB first because it was on HBO.

I love you.

Post
#1007223
Topic
Rogue One * <em>Spoilers</em> * Thread
Time

darthrush said:

Lord Haseo said:

Kristian Harloff tweeted that it is revealed someone in the Catalyst novel (who will obviously be in Rogue One) is Force Sensitive. All I hope is that character is not Jyn.

Do you watch the show he hosts? Collider Jedi Council? It’s awesome. I listen to it in podcast form on my iPhone. And on the topic of Jyn possibly being force sensitive, I would HATE it. Would bring down the movie a whole level for me. One of the big points Lucasfilm has said about Rogue One, is that it will be more grounded than any of the other Star Wars movies with no force users other than Darth Vader. This would really piss me off.

Yes but I watched less frequently after the TFA buzz died down and information was scarce. I initially knew him from the Schmoes Know channel