LexX

DarthBo said:

 

Sluggo said:

The tweaked version of Yoda looked a little yellow for me

+1, to me the close-up of Luke on Bespin looked a bit too colourful as well

Can't say I see much point in the ESB tweak tbh, the V3 looks perfect as it is :-)

 

+1. but a little more lightness doesn't hurt.

Moth3r said:

"2.0 Surround" would be a more accurate description than plain old "Stereo".

Is there a difference between them?

I haven't watched many remakes or reboots but the ones I like are Batman and Bond reboots. Both series were going into the toilet so a reboot was needed. Also the new Superman series could be fun since the last film wasn't.

EyeShotFirst said:

Found this, never seen it before, if I did I don't remember it. Could be a cool DVD cover if somebody had a biggun'.

 

It says no hotlinking, can you link it somewhere else?

To suggest something, I'm not sure if the order of the soundtracks has been finalized but I'd recommend ChainsawAsh's order for them. :)

Btw, do TESB and ROTJ need any color tweaking?

ChainsawAsh said:

I think your tweaks look fantastic, DJ, and I'd venture a guess that it's the the best it can look without going scene-by-scene.  I wouldn't expect you to be willing to do that.

I do have to say that I'd be quite disappointed if you decide not to use your tweaks in the final V3, too.  I still think I'm going to do a scene-by-scene coloring for my own use sometime down the road, but if the screencaps are any indication, your tweaks will please the vast majority on here.

Agreed!

Those look way too green.

I liked the last color tweaks and I thought everyone else liked them, too. I'd prefer that to the "as is" version.

GOLD... That's funny, that's what it should be.

ChainsawAsh said:

Double post, sorry, but I just saw this:

LexX said:

the whole Death Star sequence seems to have a bad green cast throughout (the scene I selected was almost the least greenest) and all of these shots, too, could use shifting towards magenta. So while there is some green in DS walls etc. I don't think they should be as green as some of you have tweaked them. If you've seen promotional images etc. DS was never green.

The Death Star sequences were originally color timed so the walls were a shade of greenish-blue instead of solid gray.  Those caps are fairly accurate, though I think they are a little too green.

Sorry, didn't know that. But yeah, they aren't 100% accurate either.

ChainsawAsh said:

I like them better with the corrections than without.

Me too.

Here's some more 70 mm slides from the discussed scenes. Now, the whole Death Star sequence seems to have a bad green cast throughout (the scene I selected was almost the least greenest) and all of these shots, too, could use shifting towards magenta. So while there is some green in DS walls etc. I don't think they should be as green as some of you have tweaked them. If you've seen promotional images etc. DS was never green.

Well, that's pretty clear that senator Palpatine would become emperor Palpatine, but I think it's also clear that Palpatine is also Sidious. I remember before TPM came out it was a little difficult to tell who was who when there were Palpy and Amidala playing other roles which seemed a little weird.

I think DJ's shots look great.

The Aluminum Falcon said:

Fritz, I know that earlier you said that it seemed like the ESB bootleg was a transfer from a 35mm print. How do you know of this and are you sure that it's not a 70mm one? Did you check if it has any of the differences listed in this thread?

He did.

In my opinion Yoda and the emperor do know about each other and that's also mentioned in the novelization of ROTJ.

Also I never liked Yoda when I was a kid but after they made him even worse for the prequels which I'm now trying to forget forever, I've grown to like him more.

Sluggo said:

Filthy Pierre said:

fishmanlee said:

Filthy Pierre said:

Tobar said:

Yeah the one trooper when they're talking about the new BT-16, I like the one trooper's response, "Yeah some of the other guys were telling me about about it, they say it's...it's quite a thing to see."

 

Yeah that was a good. It made the stormtroopers more relate able than just canon fodder for rebels.

"You seen that new BT-16?"

"Yeah some of the other guys were telling me about it. They say its quite a thing to see."

"What was that?"

"Its nothing, outgassing, don't worry about it."

The original trilogy had some of the best background acting ever. Its what makes it the greatest movies ever made. Giving lines to Stormtroopers was a brilliant move.

fixed!

Replayed it over and over and high volume and I don't hear it as outgassing. Still sounds like top gassing. Then I play it at low volume and your right. Its outgassing. Something to do with the exhaust port I bet.

Thanks for the pickup.

Your ears can deceive you, don't trust them.  What do the scripts say?  And don't the DVD's have optional subtitles?

If I remember correctly, it was top gassing in the script?

EyeShotFirst said:

LexX said:

EyeShotFirst said:

That is one of the problems with the prequels, there wasn't any moments that sucked me in.

I thought there were many moments that sucked.

The prequels aren't even quotable. The OT is full of awesome quotes.

The only dialogue I can quote is Jar Jar and every time Anikan opens his hole and says something stupid. "I hate sand."

You may want to read that again. :P

EyeShotFirst said:

That is one of the problems with the prequels, there wasn't any moments that sucked me in.

I thought there were many moments that sucked.

doubleofive said:

 

Anchorhead said:

doubleofive said:

TK-421, the only canon stormtrooper named in the OT.

Even though we don't see it in the film - I bet he shot first too. Han was just defending himself.

;-)

*applause*

Nice one, Anchor.

 

Wasn't there a stormtrooper blaster sound in one mix and then Han's blaster on another? So maybe he did shoot first. ;)

Quackula said:

I like the one that wonders if it's another drill.

Funny you should mention it, that was once translated here as the machine which drills holes in subtitles. LOL

Moth3r said:

From first viewing:

Clip 1 definitely seems out of sync. I reckon it's the delayed one.

Clips 2 and 3 both seem in sync on first viewing, although I have a feeling that Clip 3 is the more natural. So I would guess that Clip 2 is the one where the audio is ahead.

Agreed.

When Vader says "If you will not turn to the dark side, perhaps she will" hitting Luke's soft spot.

LeeThorogood said:

My vote would be for a more theatrically accurate crisp coloured, V3 please. :)

+1

Sounds great. So will these "original" mixes be in the GOUT v.3?

none said:

Here's another example of a production talking about the impact of the Original Star Wars but showing a Special Edition clip.

Twentieth Century Fox: The Blockbuster Years (TV 2000)

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0320996/

~41:55 they show the SE shot of Han running around the DS corridors and meeting up with the enhanced large crowd of Stormtroopers.

I think that's mainly because LFL won't give any original film footage from the OOT since 1997.