logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
18-Aug-2025
Posts
1,531

Post History

Post
#1469773
Topic
Crafting the Illusion of a Wider World
Time

Yeah its lame it returns to Tatooine, and other than Endor their isn’t anything new. George always planned a bunch of different locales in the OT but because of the budget their was very few. We never got to see Alderaan, even Imperial Center aka Coruscant wasn’t added until the Special Edition.

What the OT did well was the used universe or worldizing. What Donner called Verisimilitude.

The prequels looked like a videogame. And the Disney movies are far too perfect looking and digital, even rogue one which comes the closest isn’t as gritty looking as it should have been.

The only places that seem kind of believable are Jakku and Ach-To in the sequels.

Post
#1469148
Topic
What are you reading?
Time

I just got Kaldar World of Antares in a collection of stories and also Edmond Hamilton’s Return to the Stars the sequel to the Star Kings.

I haven’t read one of his books since i read Star Kings.

Looking forward to reading some of this old pulp Sci-Fi.

Edit:
Kaldar was really bad, it was very poor Burroughs pastiche. The most remarkable things in it are a Star Trek like matter transporter that can move the person to a far away planet, and a Star Wars like lightsaber laser sword.

Post
#1467994
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

By definition Disney Star Wars is fanfiction because it isn’t from George Lucas. So i’m not surprised.

I haven’t seen Book of Boba Fett it or Mando for that matter beyond the Luke Skywalker episode and the first season episode 1.

Filoniverse is fanfic its always been. Its never been on the level of Star Wars 1-6. Even though Disney elavated it to such a canon status.

By no means is that condemnation the EU was also fanfic and so is the new EU.

I think that only the works from Lucas should be seen as canon, even bad ones.

I like Filoni fanfiction to a certain degree. I enjoyed Clone Wars and Rebels.

Post
#1467323
Topic
The original Force Unleashed is the best Star Wars game.
Time

I kind of like the sequel, liked Juno Eclipse.

Starkiller is okay sort of. Though Vader having a secret apprentice is daft.

And the way Palpatine and Vader are portrayed is silly, almost Saturday morning cartoon villain.

The original game is fun in terms of gameplay but as an EU story it was never going to fit inside canon.

Now its completely non canon due to Disney.

Post
#1465926
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

I watched Ghostbusters 2 and its kind of underrated. I think i might have been unfair in my earlier assessment of the movie.

Still think Vigo is a weak villain and the character Peter MacNicol plays is annoying.

But everything else sort of works. Its only damned for being too pedestrian and too late 80s. But i think Bill Murray is pretty good in it, and so is Sigourney Weaver.

Everything since has sucked. If they weren’t going to do a Ghostbusters 3 they should have left it alone.

I love Pacific Rim, but only the first one. Its like a live action anime. I loved every single moment of over the top cheese. Pure fun. The sequel is one of the worst movies i’ve ever seen its barely better than the second Independence Day.

Post
#1465696
Topic
What's the most "hypnotic" movie you've seen?
Time

Star Wars is the only picture i’ve ever seen a standing ovation at the end with people cheering and clapping. And that was for the 97 version. Would love to see what kind of response a showing of the original version would get.

Star Wars being hypnotic for me that would be seeing Return of the Jedi i was like 5 or 6 when i saw it.

That scene on the skiff where Luke salutes Artoo and his lightsaber is launched to him. Had me enraptured.

At the time i hadn’t seen a lot of movies and never saw pirate movies, or swashbucklers so it was quite exciting.

When Luke strides into Jabba’s in black cloak like he owns the place, i thought that was cool. As i did the hologram to Jabba scene. And the death star battle at the END and Throne room confrontation.

As for Indiana Jones, Raiders gets me every single time it hooks me in from the opening.

Post
#1465512
Topic
George Lucas's Sequel Trilogy
Time

THE EU was canon up until Filoni Clone Wars. It obviously had to be struck from canon when the lore between Clone Wars and the EU were at odds and Filoni regarded it as fanfiction. And if George was to ever make his sequels it would have been erased anyway. Even Zahn and KJA knew this in the 1990s.

George never really saw it as his Star Wars, but he was free to copy ideas and characters and places from it.

Post
#1465508
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

Ghostbusters Afterlife. It isn’t a bad movie about family, but its a bad Ghostbusters movie. I don’t know why i bother i should just stick with the first one. Every single sequel has been incredibly disappointing and i just keep setting myself up.

It was cool for 5 minutes when the original cast shows up and i smiled and had nostalgic feelings. But it was a waste of 20 dollars.

The kids all do a decent job, but i wanted Ghostbusters 3.

Watched Army of Darkness. Super Cheesy but also super fun. I haven’t had such a good time watching a movie in ages. Bruce Campbell is so good.

I watched All 4 Men in Black movies. Film 2 and 4 aren’t that bad and i honestly don’t understand why they are hated. And i also don’t get why people act like part 3 is the best. It isn’t that good. Tommy Lee Jones is barely in it. Brolin is overrated in this film.

Post
#1464677
Topic
George Lucas's Sequel Trilogy
Time

I thought he said after Indiana Jones IV Lucasfilm was moving from the silver screen into television. This was before streaming was even a thing.

George Lucas had this tv series that the working title was called Star Wars Underworld. Did he really intend to do Star Wars sequels or Indiana Jones V. Because i just don’t see it. A couple of pages of notes isn’t a screenplay. He had hundreds of hours of scripts for that unmade tv series.

I would like to see his treatments be fleshed out, that was what i wrongly thought Michael Arndt was doing before the filming of 7 commenced.

George says Disney didn’t use any of his treatment or story and we have to take him at his word i guess.

Post
#1464667
Topic
A Long Time Ago... - Share Your Star Wars Story
Time

I would like to see new restoration prints someday of the OOT, but until then i have 4K77 and 4K83.

As for the prequels and the Disney movies if other people enjoy them who am i to deny them. I’ve at least mellowed some what on Phantom Menace. I’ve never really enjoyed Attack of the Clones though, and my liking for Revenge of the Sith has been at least cut in half since the last time i watched it.

Still would like to see Star Wars 77 and Empire 1980 on the big screen. Looks like its something i will never experience. Wonder if i’ll live long enough for episodes 10, 11 and 12 to happen.

Seeing Return of the Jedi in 1985 was a experience i’ve never come close to again, except for Return of the King in 2003.