logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
4-Jul-2025
Posts
1,471

Post History

Post
#1471449
Topic
Irvin Kershner on Special Editions
Time

Maybe he only watched the 1997 Special Edition on 35mm and never saw the incredibly awful 2004 DVD one can hope. Its worse it has that new Emperor scene and Boba Fett redubbed by Jango Fett. But the 97 still has worse replacement shots than the original lead up to cloud city, and alert my star destroyer to prepare for my arrival and Jerjerrod. Even if it had the Original Emperor and Jason Wingreen. If only they restored the picture did a cleaned up multi track digital mix, removed matte lines. Fix the Speeder transparency.

I even hate the zoomed in Falcon Cockpit shots. For every beautiful original effect cleaned up there is a nonsense cgi test shot that sticks out like a sore thumb.

They were using these as a place to learn new tools and create a toolbox to make the prequels. Its hideous to think they defaced the original. and even cut up the negative. And didn’t create a restored original first and the special edition second as an alternative cut.

Post
#1470805
Topic
Irvin Kershner on Special Editions
Time

Kersh was given final cut and Lucas had promised him it would be his movie. He went back on that with the Special Edition. Lucas made a similar promise to Marquand. But he was more amenable because he felt it was Lucas universe and he ought to make the film the way Lucas wanted. Of course he wasn’t alive to object to ROTJ Special Edition, but i doubt he would have minded. You are a director for hire when hired by Lucas, Lucas is the auteur. The only exception if Indiana Jones where it was co partnership with Spielberg, but it was never a suggestion that Lucas was backseat directing those, well at least the first 3, film 4 is arguable.

Post
#1470796
Topic
Raiders of the Lost Ark 35mm LPP Theatrical Experience - v1.0 (Released)
Time

Its native, just like a decade old and done by Pacific Title.

Just like those Star Wars 4K discs were done around the same time by Reliance Mediaworks, AKA Lowry.

Have no idea why they sat on it for so long.

Must be a Lucasfilm thing.

Raiders was done in 2011-2012

Star Wars was done in 2012-2013.

Only for both to be released a near decade later.

Post
#1470080
Topic
25 Years of the Special Edition
Time

We only have HD versions of the 97 Star Wars and Empire due to fan preservations. Not just the original but the 1997 cuts only exist on laserdisc.

Lucasfilm is only interested in the current version that would be the 2020 4K cut. Its funny how the 20th anniversary Special Edition is also not available on blu-ray.

Its ditto on theatrical Phantom Menace without cgi Yoda, it exists on laserdisc and fans did a 35mm preservation because Lucasfilm can’t be bothered to release the theatrical.

THX 1138 and American Graffiti are also probably a lost cause until some fan restores them. I’ve written Lucasfilm off, They are only interested in Disney Star Wars not in catalog releases of Lucas movies.

Post
#1470075
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

The original Matrix. Bubble gum surface level philosophy, wrapped up into a comic book like world that is completely without any verisimilitude or belief. It only helps that its all happening in a videogame like computer so the ridiculous unbelievable cgi scenes can be forgiven. I still enjoyed the sillyness and fun of it all. Its also a highly overrated movie. Carrie-Anne Moss is fantastic, but i feel like Keanu wasn’t yet the cool guy he is now and he was sort of awkward. I also feel like Neo and Trinity had zero chemistry and Morpheus basically does nothing and Laurence Fishburne’s talents are wasted.

Post
#1469773
Topic
Crafting the Illusion of a Wider World
Time

Yeah its lame it returns to Tatooine, and other than Endor their isn’t anything new. George always planned a bunch of different locales in the OT but because of the budget their was very few. We never got to see Alderaan, even Imperial Center aka Coruscant wasn’t added until the Special Edition.

What the OT did well was the used universe or worldizing. What Donner called Verisimilitude.

The prequels looked like a videogame. And the Disney movies are far too perfect looking and digital, even rogue one which comes the closest isn’t as gritty looking as it should have been.

The only places that seem kind of believable are Jakku and Ach-To in the sequels.

Post
#1469148
Topic
What are you reading?
Time

I just got Kaldar World of Antares in a collection of stories and also Edmond Hamilton’s Return to the Stars the sequel to the Star Kings.

I haven’t read one of his books since i read Star Kings.

Looking forward to reading some of this old pulp Sci-Fi.

Edit:
Kaldar was really bad, it was very poor Burroughs pastiche. The most remarkable things in it are a Star Trek like matter transporter that can move the person to a far away planet, and a Star Wars like lightsaber laser sword.

Post
#1467994
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

By definition Disney Star Wars is fanfiction because it isn’t from George Lucas. So i’m not surprised.

I haven’t seen Book of Boba Fett it or Mando for that matter beyond the Luke Skywalker episode and the first season episode 1.

Filoniverse is fanfic its always been. Its never been on the level of Star Wars 1-6. Even though Disney elavated it to such a canon status.

By no means is that condemnation the EU was also fanfic and so is the new EU.

I think that only the works from Lucas should be seen as canon, even bad ones.

I like Filoni fanfiction to a certain degree. I enjoyed Clone Wars and Rebels.