Isn’t this supposed to be Poppasketti’s personal version of The Last Jedi?
Surprised to hear the guy who constantly nags people to make the changes he wants say something like this.
+1
Isn’t this supposed to be Poppasketti’s personal version of The Last Jedi?
You’re kidding, right?
Please, tell me you’re kidding.
The outdoor view of the Senate is astonishing!
Wow, thank you!
About your criticism, I have to entirely agree with you.
Thank you again for the comment 😉
Why not edit the GOUT and add the prequel music yourself?
Says the guy who constantly nags people with nonsensical “suggestions” instead of making his own edits.
+1
Updated definitive changelist
As snooker and others pointed out, I meant some of the coloring and the odd backgrounds out of focus (mostly on Endor’s ground).
I don’t really mind the ships. On the contrary, I like most of those shots. And I love this puppet Yoda (just to give my opinion from another post which I read). The lighting on his face while he is dying is something you cannot achieve with any level of CG.
Sorry if I was misunderstood. Not being native english speaker, sometimes it can happen.
PS: TNT, instead of filling everyone’s post with odd suggestions, you could always try to make your own edit. Just saying…
I loved this edit! The new color grade/ visual effects really gave it a new feel. Palpatine’s eyes are my favorite. The new music was great. There are some cutting issues in the first act at Jabba’s palace, though. Thank you this will be my go-to from now on!
Thank you man!
Phenomenal.
EDIT RELEASED
PM me for links, if you’re interested.
Personal thoughts:
First of all, I came to hate the visual quality of the original ROTJ. I dislike most of the coloring, and how many things look oddly out of focus.
Regarding the edit itself, it’s not perfect, but I hope it’s at least enjoyable. Without a doubt it’s been the most challening edit of mine so far. There are many things I’m satisfied with, and some others I’m not.
I hope to get some feedback from you.
Hey! Thank you!
I’ll definitely revisit this, but still don’t know about the resolution.
Soooo cool!
Me too… I just remember reading it somewhere.
I have an idea for an edit of a scene in The Last Jedi: remove the shot of Yoda lifting his finger before the lightning hits the tree just as Luke is about to burn it, as well as Yoda hitting Luke with his cane. That scene creates huge plot holes, like for example, why didn’t Obi-Wan decapitate Darth Vader on Bespin with a lightsaber? It also contradicts the scene where Obi-Wan mentions that he cannot interfere in The Empire Strikes Back, as it turns out that Force ghosts can actually interact with the real world.
It is supposed to happen only in certain places, strong with the Force (like Ach-To).
That was actually too much yellow-ish, I recognize that, but the final version will have a skin color correction in some scenes.
Man, that was just a test -.-"
Do you prefer that red-ish face?
I’m just working on the faces.
Could you please tell me what you think?
Original
Edited
I’ll try that 😉
It’s just Endor’s sun.
Plus, some flares here and there give a more modern look, which ROTJ in particular needs, IMHO.
Thank you both 😉
Full trailer: https://vimeo.com/386570076
😉
Updated changelist.
I’ll explain better later, but you can check AOTC for good examples of digital zooming and panning 😁
…
OK here’s a good example of what I’m talking about:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mDyGc68hpMAll the zooms and most of the pans on that video are digital. That is, they were added in editing to create dynamic and better framing. You can do the same with Jedi’s mostly static effect shots. Just don’t go crazy with it, zoom only up to 105%, it doesn’t need much.
(if you like the video please subscribe to the channel - it’s mine 😉 and it really needs a boost 😉 )
I will certainly do that.
Top: Original (telecine’s)
Bottom: Edited
Reduced blue tonality. Changed X Wing engine color. Added lighting.
Star Destroyer’s interior bridge recolored.
SD’s bridge recolored. Added atmosphere and sun-ish light.
Enhanced Ackbar’s skin color and white background.
Same as before. Reduced blue tonality in space and on the Death Star. Enhanced Endor color, added atmosphere and sun.
Less blue, more grey. Enhanced Palpatine’s eyes (more similar to TROS).
Still not sure about this. But for now I like Palpatine’s eyes.
Please, tell me what you think 😉
Thank you.
I’m not sure I understand what you mean with that suggestion. Could you explain?