logo Sign In

Harmy

User Group
Members
Join date
2-Feb-2010
Last activity
15-Jul-2025
Posts
7,232
Web Site
http://revengeofthejedi.wz.cz

Post History

Post
#535606
Topic
ET Blu-Ray to only feature theatrical edition
Time

TheBoost said:

TV's Frink said:

Alexrd said:

TV's Frink said:

Did you not read the tweet above where he said:

"I tried it once and I learned to regret it" - Spielberg on changing ET

Isn't it his right to NOT include a SE?

Of course he is. But then again, so is Lucas in his right to not include the original. Personally, I would like to see both versions released.

A director withholding a previously released SE and a director withholding a theatrical version is not comparable.

 I don't know. Is it a question or ORIGINAL INTENT or is it a question of film history? The ET SE is still a piece (arguably a notable piece) of film history.

This.

Post
#535419
Topic
ET Blu-Ray to only feature theatrical edition
Time

I like the original better too but I think that once the SE is done, it should be released as well (and there were HD broadcasts of the SE, so they do have an HD master for it already, so no additional cost would be involved). The general opinion may be that people don't care for the SE, but I'm sure you could find someone who likes the SE and would like to have the option of seeing it in HD.

But it's definitely still more logical to release the original only than the SE only.

Post
#535402
Topic
Preserving the "German" Original Trilogy (Released)
Time

Hey guys. Does any of you have the German 1995 full screen VHS set? If so could you please post photos of it? My uncle used to have it and I last saw it as a kid and I loved the box-set art but when I asked him if he still had it, he couldn't find it. I'd really like to see it again to confirm whether it's really as awesome as I remember it or it's just a false memory.

Post
#535352
Topic
Star Wars coming to Blu Ray (UPDATE: August 30 2011, No! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!)
Time

That thing about there being no need for LFL to release the originals because there are preservations here is BS. Mine are not true original cuts, because it is just impossible to remove every change that's been done and keep the cut in reasonable quality, not to mention that I still use the overly filtered, black crushed 2004 release. And dark_jedi's, no matter how amazingly he was able to improve them, will always be sourced from a motion smeared mpeg2 encode of a 1993 LD master. So there is still need for a proper release - the fan restorations are just a temporary replacement and we should still campaign for a proper release for the sake of film history preservation.


And the other argument, that George has no reason to release the OOT, because there are fan preservation is also totally wrong. In fact, it was the fan made bootlegs that prompted George to release the GOUT in the first place - at the time the fan-made bootlegs were all decent LD transfers, so what he gave us in an official release was exactly that, only that one bit better, so it'd be worth buying to those who already have the bootlegs - minimal cost, maximum profit.


Now there are HD quality bootlegs, maybe it will make him release the OOT in HD quality, again just that one bit better. Not out of realization of how important it is to preserve film history but simply out of greed.


I am afraid though that I can't trust LFL to get it right any more - I hope that if a proper release is ever to be made, they'd consider having someone like Mr Harris do the restoration. Otherwise, if done in-house by LFL, we might live to see the originals released DVNRed to hell with atrocious colour timing.