logo Sign In

Handman

User Group
Members
Join date
25-May-2014
Last activity
9-May-2025
Posts
3,667

Post History

Post
#1247882
Topic
Doctor Who
Time

Anchorhead said:

I particularly liked the scene where The Doctor is irritated at Tim Shaw for pulling a tooth from someone he just killed, as though that crossed the line for totally disrespecting the victim. She seems genuinely more bothered by that than the killing. For me, that’s the kind of depth of character & scene that’s been missing the past few years.

Exactly! I loved that.

How could she fall from the sky down into a train without breaking every bone of her body and having to regenerate again?

I’m glad you enjoyed the episode, but… there was also that one scene in The End of Time where the Doctor freefalled several hundred feet, crashed through a glass ceiling, and was still well enough to aim a gun…

What I mean to say is… the incredible improbability here is nothing new… and can easily be explained away by the weirdness that is regenerating.

Post
#1247567
Topic
Doctor Who
Time

Oh, definitely. I really enjoyed World Enough and Time and Oxygen of Capaldi’s final season.

I actually take back what I said about the writing being awful by the end of Capaldi’s run. It gradually got better over time. Outside of that three parter, and the finale being a bit too “Moffat”-y for me, it was a very solid season.

Post
#1247555
Topic
Doctor Who
Time

For every five average episodes, there are two damn near incompetent ones, and one that’s absolutely fantastic.

So, I’ve just started rewatching Matt Smith episodes, and I forgot how uneven his start was. However, there’s a reason it’s remembered so fondly, because this is the rare season that has three of those absolutely fantastic episodes.

Series 5

Fantastic:
The Eleventh Hour
Vincent and the Doctor
The Lodger

Good:
Amy’s Choice
The Big Bang

Average:
The Time of Angels
Flesh and Stone
The Vampires of Venice
The Hungry Earth
Cold Blood
The Pandorica Opens

Incompetent:
The Beast Below
Victory of the Daleks

Post
#1247541
Topic
Doctor Who
Time

LordZerome1080 said:

Handman said:

If that’s confirmed, then it sounds like a great time to try again.

Well, they haven’t explicitly said as such, but whenever the show gets a whole new creative team, they like to start fresh. It happened when Russell T. Davies left with Tennant, and it’s happening again with Moffat leaving with Capaldi. The show is really pushing the idea of being completely refreshed, even getting rid of Murray Gold, who wrote the music for the show since its revival. It’s safe to say this is an entirely different interpretation of the show. Right now is the perfect time to try again.

Every time I’d just about given up on the show, a great episode would appear and convince me to give it another chance. I can’t think of another show with which I’ve had such a love/hate relationship. I so desperately want to like it.

Oh, definitely. For every five average episodes, there are two damn near incompetent ones, and one that’s absolutely fantastic. And that episode, along with the surprisingly solid concept for the show, is enough to keep you going. The actors who’ve played the Doctor have been so consistently good, that there have been many times where I’d watch an episode just to see more of that performance, regardless of how bad the writing gets. And by the end of Capaldi’s run, it got really bad…

And how was the play Mrs. Lincoln?

What is the purpose of continually using this phrase towards me? If you can’t think critically about the things you love, well… that’s boring.

Post
#1247530
Topic
Doctor Who
Time

If that’s confirmed, then it sounds like a great time to try again.

Well, they haven’t explicitly said as such, but whenever the show gets a whole new creative team, they like to start fresh. It happened when Russell T. Davies left with Tennant, and it’s happening again with Moffat leaving with Capaldi. The show is really pushing the idea of being completely refreshed, even getting rid of Murray Gold, who wrote the music for the show since its revival. It’s safe to say this is an entirely different interpretation of the show. Right now is the perfect time to try again.

Every time I’d just about given up on the show, a great episode would appear and convince me to give it another chance. I can’t think of another show with which I’ve had such a love/hate relationship. I so desperately want to like it.

Oh, definitely. For every five average episodes, there are two damn near incompetent ones, and one that’s absolutely fantastic. And that episode, along with the surprisingly solid concept for the show, is enough to keep you going. The actors who’ve played the Doctor have been so consistently good, that there have been many times where I’d watch an episode just to see more of that performance, regardless of how bad the writing gets. And by the end of Capaldi’s run, it got really bad…

Post
#1247387
Topic
Doctor Who
Time

towne32 said:

ChainsawAsh said:

Handman said:

In addition to the end credits, we didn’t even get a title sequence!

And one of those four people was Wil Wheaton.

Nobody got a title sequence for the first episode. It was announced a week or two ago that it wouldn’t appear until episode 2.

Indeed. Though BBCA lacked the end credits as well. I later watched the digital version, and the theme (at least over the credits) is quite good. Has a lot in common with the 60s version’s melody (and the full version of it), but with modern heavy drums.

That’s because it is basically the original theme, remixed with modern heavy drums.

Here it is