logo Sign In

GlastoEls

User Group
Members
Join date
3-Nov-2012
Last activity
18-Jun-2025
Posts
360

Post History

Post
#881684
Topic
How will you be watching the saga in preparation for Force Awakens?
Time

ImperialFighter said:
After being used to many years of high praise by so many fans around the world thanks to his much-loved trilogy, the negative backlash generated by his eventual prequel and ‘special edition’ efforts must have been uncomfortable for him. Although I owned the theatrical trilogy on laserdisc, I remember looking forward to the announcement of when it would finally hit the successful new dvd format at the time…but while loads of other lesser movies were appearing with reverential quality treatments, the Star Wars trilogy remained stubbornly unavailable on the format for years and years. That was the first of a series of dubious miss-steps, and instead, George eventually came up with his dissapointing prequel trilogy and awkwardly-tinkered-with OT versions.

He is the Maker and a legend.

He gets a pass from me on the prequels.

But - he picked a fight with his own fans on the Special Editions and his obstinate attempts to erase the OOT, so it’s hard to be totally sympathetic.

I’m convinced that people would be more generous to the PT had he not done that.

Post
#880880
Topic
<strong>STAR WARS: REBELS</strong> (animated tv series) - a general discussion thread
Time

fullmetal777 said:

This show is f&$@ing pathetic…never thought there would be a character more annoying to me than Jar Jar and Episode 2 Anakin…Ezra…I hate this character with all my black heart…a total Luke Skywalker rip off and all this crap about inquisitors is ridiculous…Vader is suppose to be the one purging the galaxy if Jedi! I can’t believe so many of you give this crap show a pass…you’re clearly blinded by your nostaligia for the OT

I can’t believe so many people are into this show, even granting it status equal to the original trilogy. For me, this show is a huge disappointment. It’s lame and completely misses the mark in the kind of story that I wanted to see take place between episode 3 and 4. I would think that if you were to ask fans what they wanted to see in a show that takes place between episode 3 and 4 the number one answer would have been Darth Vader. I know for me personally I want to see Vader hunt down the remaining Jedi. Instead we get no Vader except for one episode (those stupid cameos that aren’t even a minute long in season 1 don’t count for me). Instead we get the Inquisitors, stupid and pointless characters who are playing the role Vader should be doing.

Another point where this show fails is in the Rebels crew. I would think that a majority of Star Wars fans when asked what they would want to see in a Rebels show would say they want to see Mon Mothma, Bail Organa, Wedge Antilles, Biggs Darklighter and a young princess Leia coordinating their rebellion against the empire. Instead we get a lame and corny wannabe Luke Skywalker character, Ezra, who is more annoying than Anakin in AOTC could ever be, and feels like a total gimmick to copy the Luke character. Ezra is a totally unlikable character for me and I hate his stupid Sling shot! Man, how lame can you be? Sabine is another gimmicky character, sporting pink mandalorian armor, it just feels like a Disney business ploy to target little girls, which is exactly what it is ( “look! she’s a girl! and she has pink mandalorian armor! ain’t it cool girls? now buy all her toys!”). There’s nothing wrong with female characters but why depict it like this? Sabine even spray paints a TIE fighter hot flourescent colors! I wish this show would have been more like the EU Dark Horse comics “The Purge” and “At War With the Empire.” You know, actually tried to have some edge? The clone wars TV show was more edgy than this and at least they focused on their main characters like Anakin and Obi Wan and didn’t pull a bunch of gimmicky lame characters out of their butts.

This show just feels too kiddy at times and feels like they competely missed the mark. I want to see Vader hunting down Jedi, I want to see Mon Mothma getting the the Death Star plans, I want to see Wedge and Biggs in their X Wings, I want to see Bail Organa’s last stand on alderaan before he’s blown to bits, I want to see how Leia came to be a leader of the rebellion. As far as new characters Hera and Kanan are likable and I wish the show would cut the rest of the crew out because I don’t like them, especially Zeb and Ezra, who horseplay way too much like Tom and Jerry. The only good thing about this show was seeing Tarkin show up at the end if season 1, revealing Ashoka’s return and that Vader episode in season 2.

I know many of you disliked the prequels but to me this is far more blasphemous…I’d rather watch bith clone wars tv shows and revenge of the sith than thismlame shit any day

Yet my five year old nephew absolutely LOVES this show and squeals with delight when it’s on.

Maybe wait until Rogue One for some “edge”?

Post
#880639
Topic
secrethistoryofstarwars.com gone
Time

doubleofive said:

That article was written by Matt from dinosaurdracula.com and formerly of x-entertainment.com, which are/were both fueled by nostalgia. StarWars.com was asking for this when they hired him. But even so, it’s hardly official word. My podcast network producer does an article for StarTrek.com, that doesn’t make my podcast canon. 😉

True enough, but somebody made the editorial decision to allow the article.

How nice to read a non revisionist account of what really happened!

I thought only the Empire did censuring…

Post
#880120
Topic
secrethistoryofstarwars.com gone
Time

darklordoftech said:

GlastoEls said:

SilverWook said:

And there are people inside Lucasfilm who want the OOT restored and released as much as we do.

Briefest of acknowledgments on the official site today that the Special Editons are controversial!

http://www.starwars.com/news/collectibles-from-the-outer-rim-star-wars-vhs-releases?cmp=smc|274674436&linkId=18658509

I love how that article is 100% revisionism-free. I love seeing the truth of how Star Wars has been throughout history.

The official site takes its first step into a larger, more open world.

Meanwhile the official Twitter posted:

https://twitter.com/starwars/status/664213076569407489
And immediately gets a ton of OOT requests. Maybe people do still care.

Post
#880055
Topic
secrethistoryofstarwars.com gone
Time

SilverWook said:

darklordoftech said:

Is it just me or were the SEs hated far more before Lucas sold Star Wars to Disney? When Lucas owned Star Wars, everyone was saying “the evil Lucas is holding back the awesome OOT and shoving the awful SEs down our throats.” When Lucas sold to Disney, people switched to saying, “Disney wants to give us the awesome SEs but a small group of fans is trying to shove the awful OOT down our throats.”

There has always been a segment of the fandom that likes the SE’s. (Some have even gone out of their way to deride this site.) They don’t even want a world where both versions sit side by side and people can choose what to watch.

The general public is less aware of the situation, as the movies haven’t been referred to as Special Editions since 1997.

And this is why I slightly worry.

Who is actively - what’s the word - lobbying for this?

Save Star Wars has gone down - the general public know less and less - and nobody whatsoever mentions this at Lucasfilm any more.

Are we in danger that the quality of Harmy and other restorations is counter productive to Disney restoring it?

But then: look at the attention the recent Landis rumour got. The movie sites all picked it up, but so did some mainstream news sites, including Forbes…

Post
#880045
Topic
secrethistoryofstarwars.com gone
Time

darklordoftech said:

Is it just me or were the SEs hated far more before Lucas sold Star Wars to Disney? When Lucas owned Star Wars, everyone was saying “the evil Lucas is holding back the awesome OOT and shoving the awful SEs down our throats.” When Lucas sold to Disney, people switched to saying, “Disney wants to give us the awesome SEs but a small group of fans is trying to shove the awful OOT down our throats.”

That’s the distraction of The Force Awakens, plus the primary target of fury having thrown down his lightsaber and retired.

Look at the comments next to any SE release.

People still booed Han shooting first and Hayden in ROTJ at an OT marathon (2011 cuts) I attended last Christmas.

The better question is: are we doing enough proactively and politely to let Disney know?

Post
#795019
Topic
Star Wars theatrical versions not coming in 2015
Time

It's so blatantly going to be the 2011 cuts; that's what they played at the original trilogy marathon I attended last year (http://www.bfi.org.uk/news-opinion/news-bfi/features/8-things-we-learned-star-wars-day), which featured the crowd (fantastically) booing loudly at every major SE change.

Yes, that was last year, but I can't believe they won't release the OOT theatrically or BD without major fanfare, and do they want to interfere with the buzz about The Force Awakens?

Post
#794061
Topic
Star Wars theatrical versions not coming in 2015
Time

towne32 said:

SilverWook said:

There were many stories of people arranging to get May 25th 1983 off well in advance.

 Sure. And those marathons will sell out this time, I'm sure. But as far as I know, they're one day only events and that's probably not how they would handle a OOT release. Then again, how they would handle it seems to be 'not at all'.

Which again is the strangest part of all of this.

Not one single mention either way, by anybody at Disney / LFL, since the purchase back in 2012.

All we have on the record is the John Landis quote.

Post
#785008
Topic
Star Wars theatrical versions not coming in 2015
Time

Fang Zei said:

GlastoEls said:

Since the sale, has anyone affiliated with LFL mentioned the OOT at all in any capacity?

It's pretty odd not to have gotten any official word on the subject in the almost three years since the sale.

What could possibly make it that sensitive of a subject?

Is it still just "too soon" and they don't want to upset GL, despite it not being his company anymore?

Is the Fox situation a roadblock and Disney wants to wait until 2020?

Or is it simply a matter of timing and they don't want to put it out until it makes the most sense business-wise?

This is of course assuming they're planning on eventually putting it out at all, which isn't even a given.

They're are just too many variables, and until I at least hear a rumor that gets picked up by one of the more reputable websites I'm done speculating.

Great post and I totally agree.