Yeah, look how simple and boring the space battle looks. That's something that I hope adywan improves in his ROTJ R edit. This is the last battle in the saga, I think it should be a little longer and more epic. It could really change the whole feel of the movie and the trilogy.
Adywan couldn't of messed with such a famous opening scene like that. I think the cue is perfect the way it is and is one of a couple things in these movies that can't be changed no matter how good the idea. Adding music wouldn't be necessary considering how well known that scene is.
The only thing that should be upgraded is the still lame Ben/Vader duel. The music adds alot, but doesn't sell the strong emotion that should be felt in the duel.
I wouldn't mess with changing C3POs voice. It would be very confusing to viewers. I also loved your so called "rough edit". I couldn't even tell that it was edited. Very nice work.
There are probably lines and words in the movie that can already be used. Even other movies he was in and interviews he gave could work as well.
Now finding words is one thing, but putting them all together and making it flow and sound like something Sidious would say will be near impossible to pull off. It really all depends how long he will be talking.
It only does this when I reply. Honestly, I have to play with it for a minute to even get it to let me type in the reply box. When I type in the reply title box or anywhere else, it doesn't do this. After every letter I type in the reply box, it turns it's self back on.
If you want to turn on Cap Locks, go to Settings-General-Keyboard-then it should be on that page somewhere.
ThrowgnCpr said:
vaderios said:
An exterior sketch.
Fixing the perspective problems and make the shot more interesting
-Angel
wow, that looks incredible!!!!
Yes it does, WOW.
As for this scaling of ships, I personally think this is getting out of hand. I understand the Falcon and some SD stuff, but not every ship and SD perfect. I'd rather see Ady start on ROTJ, than see him waste alot of time on things that no one would even notice.
THE EDIT WAS VERY WELL DONE. I REALLY LIKED THE DELAYED REACTION AT THE BEGINNING. ALSO, THE YAVIN MUSIC WAS A VERY GOOD IDEA. OVERALL GREAT WORK AND I HOPE TO SEE SOME MORE OF THESE. ALSO, ABOUT THE PALPS NEW HOLOGRAM SCENE YOU GUYS WANT TO DO, COULDN'T YOU FIND LINES OF HIM FROM OTHER MOVIES?
Yes BINGO, THE HOLE LOOKS TERRIBLE. IT DOESNT LOOK REAL AT ALL. I DON'T MIND THESE BANTHA SCENES, BUT THE BACKGROUNDS NEED TO GO. SORRY ABOUT THE BAD TEXT, IMI STILL TRYING TO FIGURE OUT MY IPOD,
Yes BINGO, THE HOLE LOOKS TERRIBLE. IT DOESNT LOOK REAL AT ALL. I DON'T MIND THESE BANTHA SCENES, BUT THE BACKGROUNDS NEED TO SORRY ABOUT THE BAD TEXT, IMI STILL TRYING TO FIGURE OUT MY IPOD,
Bingowings said:
Just as Obi-Wan allows himself to be killed he claims that if Vader strikes him down he will "become more powerful than...(he)...could possibly imagine" all Obi-Wan does in spirit form is give Luke a bit of shooting advice, direct him to Yoda and confess to fibbing a bit.
That's very true. So now the question is, how can Obi-Wan be shown more powerful as a ghost? I don't think it can be done, but someone could have an idea.
Not sure, I thought you guys could work off from it. I've heard ideas about Qui-Gon being added (which I'm opposed to), so I just brought up the idea of Ben's ghost being added somewhere in the movie.
Just an idea, would it be good to see Ben's Ghost again in ESB? Mabey a shot of him looking on at him on Hoth from a distance. Or mabey at Dagobah watching Luke train?
adywan said:
The flames are overkill IMHO.
Yes, I thought so too. I did like the upper right hand corner picture though.
Yes but we don't see close to 1000 stormies outside the bunker. This should be corrected. We need to see this legion of elite troops.
That's what I was getting at. I just didn't explain it well.
So the second wave of troops should be beefed up a lot but the Rebels should come with enough equipment to take out the troops they expect to find, especially on an all or nothing mission like this one.
That's alot better way to put it. Yes your right about all the troops, it wouldn't work, I just want to see another legion.
There doesn't need to be more weapons, but more rebels/troopers. Just because the Emperor says he has assembled his best fleet of troops doesn't mean that it is one fleet. He could of meant his best fleet and hundreds more troopers. You could give the best fleet a red stripe on them like the ones from ROTS and have them be the last ones standing, then have the others normal.
You could even change Palps line to "I have sent all my troops" instead of "I have sent my best fleet." I'd like to see overview shots of Endor to make the battle look larger. That would help alot.
Avatar said:
i can't believe no one is talking about the new cloud city matte
which i find to be the best shot so far though by the way ady? is this still an unfinished shotcause it looks a little bit unfinished.
maybe it's just me
I thought that to, but when it's in motion and in a higher quality, it will look great.
I just read a very long post of Ady's in his ESB thread, (pg 301.) Anyway, it really sounds like he is going to rip the PT apart, which I am 100% behind Ady for doing this. I expect some big plot changing changes along with extensive work on all the bad CG. I'm looking forward to ESB R, but i'm also very interested in what Ady will do for the PT. I think he can save them, he's that good.
shanerjedi said:
*chants* video mock up video mock up video mock up
I'll second that.
Great vid Ady, or at least what was shown (the color and the new music.)
Nice points DE. Ady does seem to go to color extremes (DS in ANH). I personally liked it but some didn't so much. I shouldn't say this yet because mabey some of Hoth will have a bluer tint and from his trailers, Hoth looks fine.
But Bingo brought up a great point on the cave shot, the inside looks bleached out when it should feel more like the inside of a cave.
As for Angel's beautiful underside of the SD, I really like it. It gives it a fresh look and a much stronger feeling.
So I really hope that Adywan considers adding a 'burn/singe mark' to this shot, roughly where you've placed your top one.
He will be adding scorch marks on the walls in the duel. He said so in his ESB R change list.
Bingo, I never realized the cave effect was missing, but now that you pointed it out, I prefer your picture better. It feels like he is in a cave now.
Oh, I'm almost certain that Ady fixed the second pic, the first pic is more of a preference.
It sounds like you know what they are.
Good, that's what I thought. Now I'm extremely curious. :)
Anybody have any predictions?
