I swear I'm going to go back and read the rest of this thread but right now I really need to get this off my chest right now.
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!
What the fuckety fucking hell is wrong with this franchise?! I really, really wanted to like this movie. Despite how lukewarm (at best) I felt about the 2009 one, I was trying to believe that now that they'd wasted two hours justifying the existence of a reboot (rather than just, you know, rebooting) that they could actually tell a story this time.
Well, I was kinda right. There is *something* of a story here. But it's really nothing more complex than a bad guy needing to get shot down with a little bit of character development for Kirk.
But the thing is, it just kept teasing me over and over and over again that this film might actually be *about* something. Ooh, maybe it's about this primitive race worshiping Starfleet as gods and some good discussions about the Prime Directive. Oh, wait, no, it's just a throwaway gag. And explain to me again why submerging the Enterprise underwater was supposedly necessary.
Then I thought they were really gonna backtrack on the idiocy of the last movie and actually show that Kirk truly is not ready to be in the captain's chair and really have to work his way back up, unlike the last time where it just got thrown in his lap with no justification. Like I said, they did kinda end up doing that, but first they spend about twenty minutes just dicking around for no reason. "Oh, you're back in the academy. No, wait, you're actually first officer now. Oh, wait, no, you're still captain. Just like you were before. What was the point of this again...?"
Then I thought it was going to be about Section 31 and the ethics of militarism, and there was a good scene between Kirk and Scotty about that before Scotty runs off (and what is it about this franchise that seems dead set against Scotty actually being the engineer of this ship?) and then it's never, ever, ever, ever, EVER dealt with again. The admiral (who is the same, underdeveloped Texan warmonger from Avatar) just becomes a bad guy that needs to be thumped. He is, and Starfleet's actions are never mentioned again. It's just there to give Khan a big ship to do big ship stuff with. I'm not the guy to go harping on about Gene's vision because I usually disagree with it, but even I have to say the man would probably be rolling over in his grave over how casually members of Starfleet just up and turn evil in this movie!
So, yeah, once again, this movie is about nothing. It's just a long stretch of boring as hell action sequences that go on for too long. I thought it was going to be cool that Chekov was the chief engineer, but that didn't amount to anything. I thought it was going to be cool that Carol Marcus was in this movie... but she didn't do anything. Why was she even here? What? Did Zoe Saldana refuse to take off her clothes again, and we had a bra and panty quota to fulfill?
And then there's the death scene flip, which is, quite frankly, self-parody. I will say I did like Kirk's line about being scared, but, really, I just didn't feel like this Kirk and Spock were close enough friends to justify this. It just didn't work for me. And while, for half a second, I thought maybe they'd have the balls to actually kill Kirk off, I then realized, "Oh, yeah. Magic Zombie Tribble. That's the key to bringing him back to life." So, yeah, Kirk died a pointless death that didn't affect the story in any way.
But what really pisses me off the most is what positive reviews this and the last one have gotten. I swear that I want to understand why people think these are good! Please! Make me understand! Because all I see are two pointless, shallow, action flicks, and that's not why I watch Star Trek!