- Post
- #489843
- Topic
- Star Wars: A Renewed Hope (Moved to Facebook) (* unfinished project *)
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/489843/action/topic#489843
- Time
...
...
...
I'm glad I'm not Ady. For my edits, I've made it perfectly clear they aren't to satisfy anyone but myself. I expect people to hate half of what I'm doing and love half and hopefully you can't find two people who agree on all of it. I'm so disinclined to engage in arguments over something I love so much that I doubt I'll even reply to negative comments. Not to confuse it with critiques that are constructive yet contrary. I just can't abide negativity when it comes to these edits which is why I've been content with just sitting back and reading the forums for 3 years. I just wish every time I come to Ady's thread people were being wonderful to each other. Some of you guys could take a page out of Imp Fighter's book. He's always the nicest and most respectful guy here. Anyway, play nice boys. From experience, I can tell you that there is a lot of work and sleepless nights involved in doing these extensive edits and absolutely for no reward except personal satisfaction.
...
...
...
....
...
....
...
...
...
...
...
...
....
...
////
.....
Moved to Facebook. Those interested can search for and Friend me there.
:: Note: The OP has deleted all of his posts from this thread. You can check out his Facebook page for the edit here.
Sample videos can be found on Youtube here and here.
- M
Accepted.
Sorry for posting TDK stuff.
Peace.
I just got home from the theatre. I never in a million years thought I'd say this, but Heath Ledger has given one of the most amazing performances in Cinema history. Quite literally, The Dark Knight can stand as one of the top 5 best movies ever made. I'm stunned. I'm in awe. I'm deeply saddened that I'll never get to see the Joker again. Heath Ledger owns this character for all eternity. I don't know if I've ever left a theatre feeling this emotionally drained. I really don't know how to express how this movie..... just a movie.... has made an idelible mark on me. My entire lifetime I've dreamed of a movie capturing and surpassing what I feel a particular genre should be and this is better than the Frank Miller Batman. For me to say that is done with the utmost respect.
This is the Batman. This is the Joker. This is TwoFace. This is Gordon. There can be no other.
PS I know its not Star Wars..... I just don't care.
nohandluke said:
The guy on the bottom ISN'T Ratzenberger - John's the guy in the top photos who tell's Leia the shield doors must be closed. He's also the same guy in that behind the scenes photo with the X-Wing and pilot BECAUSE he's ALSO the guy who says, "OK, Everybody to your stations! LET'S GO!" And yes, he's also that guy in the close-up head shot posted. He has the mustache. The other guy doesn't, hence the other guy isn't Ratzenberger.
nohandluke
Oh and Ady - While we're on famous ESB debates - Will you be coloring Han's winter coat BLUE or BROWN? Yes, there's a debate as to what color it was...Which is why Hasbro made two different versions of the same figure a few years ago...
Yeah mate, I answered those questions myself in the post above. The other guy DOES have a light colored mustache and he actually SOUNDS like John. When Derlin says, "Okay, everybody to your stations...Let's go!" SOUNDS like John too. BUT when he says "Your highness, there's nothing more we can do tonight. The shield doors must be closed" seems like it must have been dubbed. That doesn't sound like John at all.
I corrected myself so I don't need correcting again thanks.
Okay, I'm having an argument with myself now. Since this is John Ratzenburger.......
Then who the hell is this??????
They're not the same guy (at least I don't think so....god I'm not sure of anything anymore)
Mielr said:
Darth Stewie said:
There's a lot of confusion on which one John Ratsenburger is too but I don't want to get into that argument because I can't prove which is which even though I know one is John and the other isn't. I've had virtual fights about that before and lost since I can't prove it.
He's the one who goes up to Leia and says "the shield doors must be closed", right?
That's the argument you see. Many will say that is him. I KNOW it is not but I'll get into another argument that I don't want to get into. The one who says to Han "Sir, Commander Skywalker hasn't checked in......... We're having trouble adapting them to the cold." THAT is John. So many will argue the point that its like hitting my head against a wall because I can't prove it but I KNOW it, so its a moot point.
You decide for yourself.....
I know what some of you'll say.... that's Major Bren Derlin on the top and THAT's John...................wait..............I just found something that might prove me wrong..........