logo Sign In

Bingowings

User Group
Members
Join date
18-Jul-2008
Last activity
8-Oct-2025
Posts
22,836

Post History

Post
#1101536
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time

For your consideration but I’m not sure if I’m sold on the idea.
RE: Marcia Lucas’ recent comments about the sudden appearance of the Falcon in the trench run.

Bingowings said:

It makes no logical sense, as the station defenses were designed to repulse ships larger than fighters.

It would have been nice if we heard a thunderclap of the Falcon jumping from hyperspace close to the station (taking a risk that he warned Luke about earlier in the film) but then you would miss the ship coming out of the sun.

Maybe Ady could play around with the concept in his next iteration of the film. I think as cinema it makes sense but even in a fantasy context it’s putting the Mechina into the Deus Ex.

Post
#1101535
Topic
Marcia Lucas Speaks!
Time

It makes no logical sense, as the station defenses were designed to repulse ships larger than fighters.

It would have been nice if we heard a thunderclap of the Falcon jumping from hyperspace close to the station (taking a risk that he warned Luke about earlier in the film) but then you would miss the ship coming out of the sun.

Maybe Ady could play around with the concept in his next iteration of the film. I think as cinema it makes sense but even in a fantasy context it’s putting the Mechina into the Deus Ex.

Post
#1101529
Topic
Random Thoughts
Time

Next week is the last week of my current job.
It’s been a bit difficult saying goodbye to so many fantastic volunteers and co-workers.

I had a job interview today. It didn’t go well. Very theatrically staged.

I was ushered into a room which looked very much like my old lab and I had to write a submission of ideas, timed.
I was then taken into a room with a very tall ceiling and a huge conference table. There were three middle aged bearded men interviewing a middle aged bearded man for a job on a equalities council.

I wouldn’t have been impressed with myself, I got a bit tense and stuttered and my brain froze up a bit but it was an experience. The annoying thing is I turned down a film audition (minor part nothing fancy) to have this job interview.

I logged on to my email and was greeted by two more rejection notices. It take many hours to fill these in. Nobody accepts CVs (resumes for my American pals) so you have to manually enter the data over and over. So to get a cut and paste generic rejection email is very dispiriting.

Something will probably turn up. “Keep Buggering On” is possibly my motto but it would be nice if it was easy for a while.

Post
#1100689
Topic
Should Vader and The Emperor even know who Yoda is?
Time

TV’s Frink said:

doubleofive said:

yhwx said:

doubleofive said:

mfastx said:

Nandi said:

I too think it would be best if Yoda remained a mystery and wasn’t a head of the council etc.
That he didn’t chose swampy forest because of an exile, but as a place to test himself, or a seclusion while he explores the Force, entire place for younger jedies should be sort of a pilgrimage where he decides are they worthy or not to be trained by him.

Didn’t he say he had a council on who was to be trained in ESB though?

“My own counsel will I keep, on who is to be trained!”

Counsel =/= Council

That’s just an interpretation though. He could have full well meant council.

The Script says:

  		YODA
  Ready, are you?  What know you 
  of ready?  For eight hundred years 
  have I trained Jedi.  My own counsel 
  will I keep on who is to be trained!
  A Jedi must have the deepest 
  commitment, the most serious mind.

They’re completely different words.

Wait, Yoda has his own personal council? Cool!

I’ll bet he also has very strict Principals.

“I’m not a committee!”

Post
#1099092
Topic
The 'next Movie you have seen' thread...
Time

TV’s Frink said:

Bingowings said:

It’s going to be The Empire Strikes Back Ady style with Jonno’s support feature reconstruction. WUP! WUP!

I should probably get around to downloading it now that I’m back.

What’s this Jonno thing?

He has done fun reconstructions of the sorts of adverts, trailers and support pictures that would have preceded the showing of the original films in the UK.

Post
#1099078
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time

NeverarGreat said:

Bingowings said:

Irregardless of if he was removed I would like to at least hear Yoda’s dialogue so he isn’t jumbling up his words like he did when he was pretending to be a goofy swamp-dweller.

He jumbles his words after he drops the crazy act - it’s just how he speaks. It would feel really weird for him to be speaking normally IMO, even in a place where the whole planet is one big city.

He drops the act and drops the speach mode. He only resumes it in Jedi when he is making the joke about looking good for his age.

Post
#1097749
Topic
STAR WARS: EP V &quot;REVISITED EDITION&quot;<strong>ADYWAN</strong> - <strong>12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW</strong>
Time

1anakin said:

Everything is spotless all around. So it pains me to even mention the one thing. When Yoda says to Luke, “Judge be by my size, do you?” His eyes turn towards Luke now and its a little off putting,

That was the very bit I loved that loved and mentioned in my previous post.

Post
#1097745
Topic
STAR WARS: EP V &quot;REVISITED EDITION&quot;<strong>ADYWAN</strong> - <strong>12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW</strong>
Time

I had lots of trouble playing this (nothing to do with the file itself just my equipment falling to bits) so it was a bit frustrating and probably not the most optimal viewing experience.

However. Wow!

It felt very familiar and yet fresh.
At no point did I feel that any of the changes were things the technical wizards of the day wouldn’t have done if they had the time and the kit.

Yoda felt as much an actor performance as Sir Alec in the first one. There is a moment when he looks at Luke which is utterly sublime.

Those scout walkers are characters in their own right. Moving like stop motion but able to convey worry, nervousness etc in all the ways the battle droids of the prequels did not.

I will need to see this again many times to register some of the changes which took months (maybe years) to plan build and film. The hanger matte replacement, my biggest gripe about the original version was that hanger matte, made worse by the contrast and tinting of future versions, was over in seconds but looked much better. The Han in Carbonite and Wampa changes are almost subliminal at times and yet give the film increased tangibility.

It’s an astonishing achievement to make these sorts of improvements to an already classic and timeless movie.

I can’t wait to see what you do with the increasingly less classic third sequel and prequels as they are the films that really need rescuing.