skyjedi2005 said:
How much i wish That the prequels and special editions never existed so questions like this one would not have to be asked, and would be irrelevant.
This like the question on versions of the movies would not have to be debated if the saga ended in 1983 like it should have.
Just Like Indiana Jones should have been left alone after last crusade.
All Lucas did was go back and destroy 2 of the favorite franchises of my youth, and added Bad and fake cgi where it was neither wanted or needed.
1999 Phantom Menace was hard to stomach Racist Characters like Jar Jar and the Gungans, and the Nemodians. Poop and Fart Jokes and writing that could have been put together by a juvenile moron.
Thanks Captain Bias!
My personal opinion? (Drumroll please)
...neither. That's right. Puppet Yoda lacked "life-ism" and CG Yoda lacked "material-ism" The puppet yoda was actually there, something you could see walk into a room physically. But still was as jittery as any muppet is. CG Yoda was gread on emotions and movement but lacked the materialistic/tangeable feel to him. You could never imagine him walking into a room, he's CLEARLY CG. We needed a mupppet with some CG work. To enhance the emotions and movement while retaining the tangeable feel to him.