Angel

Kapheen said:

The energy doors are a complete head scratcher for sure. A holding cell for the source of the new energy which is some cheezy B-flick energy monster living at the bottom of the giant hole that Maul falls into? lol

I posted that before you posted this:

I suggested that either with some FX work you can make the sabers clash on the panel manage to make the mechanism go mad (see ROTS) or either have maul using the force to crush the door panel (for some reason i guess)

-Angel

Great news Spence :) cant wait to see what have you done so far :)

The new energy source can be located in the completely out of place generator core that the Duel of the Fates occurs in. This area could be some sort of mining facility for the new fuel source.

The most common awesome idea that still cant solve the idiotic moments with the energy doors :/

I suggested that either with some FX work you can make the sabers manage to make the mechanism go mad or either have maul using the force to crush the door panel (for some reason i guess)

I m eager what spence will come up with.

-Angel

doubleofive said:

 

fishmanlee said:

It was Angel.

The DVD9 of ANHR has Ady's attempt to clean it up.

 

I dont think so. Ady said that he stabilize the frame rate. (not sure if he did some CC) The clean up was done by be for a test :)

edit: HERE IT IS http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPEheHK-cMc

Nice video. It has the same problem that ANH has. Terrible set sounds that are loud and not carefully done. Footsteps cracks and booms all over the place. :/

-Angel

jigsaw said:

question:

8. Removing of all the SE shots of Vader's shuttle leaving Bespin and docking with the Executor.

why is there a problem with this scene?

answer:

Ruins the pacing and we dont need to see where vader is going. The music cuts also are terrible.

Bring my shuttle line have everything in contex

-Angel

SilverWook said:

Funny how those "pylons" are on the minature too. ;)

Strange. They still look wooden set remains there.

If you cant show it that are pipes or machinery then dont show it at all. It breaks the illusion. Or just fix them in post :D

thanks for the model reference tho. I might redo some mockups :)

-Angel

shanerjedi said:

 But Geonosis looks like its clone.

You get the rhyme here eh? Clones...Attack...episode 2...

-Blue

EyeShotFirst said:

or add mountains (image from MattePainting.Org)

Nice.. What is the exact source for this image?

-Angel

doubleofive said:

Have a (temp) comp!

Nice to see that shot is fixed. Seeing the wooden pylons under the sail barge set was out of place :)

I also noticed that they fixed a glitch in AOTC. After we see the shot when the two guys are talking to the queen in the ship, the following shot has a fly by in the clouds. The last frame of it had one fog layer off in the HDTVs.

Its pretty bad the the fake shaking camera effect glitch is still unfixed (why you took so long scene) You can see the black bars next to obi and anakin :/

-Angel

Isnt the same idea that some Haljordan had with kevin bacon...erm Sebastian shaw as anakin?

-Angel

Since ady is gonna build the cloud city, take some time to take ideas and inspiration from these images

http://www.nehmzow.de/reportagefeatures/thumbs/?modus=thumbnails&kat=12&page=1

The feel that the clouds creating solid forms when the colors are mixed with variate ways may give a unique and rare view of the model in the cloud solid forms.

-Angel

darth_ender said:

I know, I know, I said this elsewhere, but since I'm so clever, I have to say it here.  I think this would be the perfect solution to the whole ROTJ Anakin head debate.  See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sebastian_Shaw_(comics) for my justification.  Isn't it brilliant?!

Lol i was talking about that with johnny_ringo the other day.

Star wars needs more bacon at the end.

And all are leading to kevin bacon ;)

-Angel

TheoOdo said:

*Awesome ideas*

If the other Neimodian is given the voice of an older male, it could suggest that he has dealt with Jedi in the past and has been impressed by them, further establishing them as a powerful and mysterious though misunderstood and somewhat forgotten order. This also plays into the theme of spirituality vs. attempts at technological domination from the original trilogy - the Viceroy is young and arrogant and believes in domination, strength and machine-like efficiency, whereas the older Neimodian is wiser and knows that there truly is some mysterious power the Jedi wield, even if he is uncertain what that power is exactly.

I hope spence is warm with the idea of redubing and not just placing subtitles or altering the audio to Japanese.

I like the efforts of redubing so far so im eager that this edit has a bigger scale.

-Angel

EyeShotFirst said:

 Instead, we see the training relates more to the training of Ivan Drago in Rocky 4, all sterile and sciencey. 

I cant wait to listen this if you ever make an audio drama of your novel a Force version of Hearts of fire made by john williams :P

-Blue

SilverWook said:

Who is this man?

Fixed that for you:

-Angel

ROFLRICK said:

What's the Facebook page ESB:R? I can't find it...

http://www.facebook.com/swrevisited

-Angel

This guy here from a post of FB made some solid suggestions on some things i liked:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcyRBQBat9k

The glows behind the smokes

The smoothed motion on R2's arm

The enhanced blasters

Blinkless leia

And the flash that turns red instead of blue is some that i would like to considered as changes for the best.

I have not compare this video to ady's previous work to know what has changed since then.

Nice to see people takes the suggestions to a whole new level :)

-Angel

Who is Anchoheard?

-Angel

doubleofive said:

I'd like to encourage everyone to keep donating! We're having a fundraiser on September 16, where instead of buying the Blu-rays, we'd like to have everyone donate at least one dollar/pound/euro/peso/whatever to the Project. Just follow the link in my sig to the site to find the Paypal button!

How much are the funds from the donations so far?

-Angel

timdiggerm said:

The newer one is slightly better, but the illumination is pretty crazy. Why are there light sources on either side?

Anyway, Harmy said it best.

Try to justify where the sun comes? Its a mystery that cant be solved anyway in OT. we never see it even more the second ambient light.

Its all about presentation ;) not originality.

I say more CGI :)

-Angel

Harmy said:

I must side with Tim on this one. I'm sorry but the DS looks CG as hell (where the original was a physical model, so it looks real) and the planet also looks very fake to me.

we might came up with a better render..

what do you propose at the end?

-Angel

The Aluminum Falcon said:

LOL. It's good that the Blu-Ray set is having some negative publicity about the new changes, but I'm surprised LFL hasn't taken any action against the leaked copies...

On that matter, I am very surprised that no one has leaked the deleted scenes nor the TPM with a CGI Yoda. I wonder if LFL is really attempting to keep those ones under guard.

In one of their documentaries they had a CG yoda on dagobah (probably for matching the proportions (which they failed), they had him say "you are reckless" lines. No idea why they didnt think to add him in ESB and Jedi as CG. That would be a nice start for the 3D edition dont you think? ;)

-Angel

none said:

Making the rounds:

My image dominates around the forums :P

-Angel

timdiggerm said:

I'll be the voice of dissent and say that it doesn't look cool. It's less convincing than the original.

Its the same model i made. maybe its the light condition.

-Angel

Bingowings said:

As I said before on the other thread these look like mockups done on here to illustrate a proposed change which is why I took Angel's misunderstanding at face value.

Sorry for that. I misread the other post. Still if the BD messed with that idea still there is room for recreating it or making better in R version.

-Angel

Its nice that the city in the clouds gets more dark rooms and meanings. (considering that everyone wants to live there, still is a mess of weird places)

-Blue

We dont have updates but keep posting radical visual ideas and plot fixes.

-Angel