- Post
- #452740
- Topic
- The ANH:SE Redux Ideas thread (Radical Ideas Welcome).
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/452740/action/topic#452740
- Time
Jaitea achieved that you said perfectly. ANH vader will be more ESB one.
-Angel
Jaitea achieved that you said perfectly. ANH vader will be more ESB one.
-Angel
Idea in motion.
Back in some posts i ve said that id like to see vader be on something grander rather just walks like a pet in the corridors of the death star.
taking this shot from Flynn i can imagine replacing some interior to match with the death star ones and have vader meditating and then he leaves.
A nice pov IMO that shows some more bits of the exterior of the death star's dark side and brake the poor close sets with an opened one keeping the armored feeling.
-Angel
Bingowings said:
Did you do that yourself or is it from one of those game things you young people play?
Have you tried putting the people in there?
Nope. TFU2's concept art. Superior to the ROTJ's sets :D
No people yet. just trying to get feedback from the mood and colors
-Angel
My interpretation:
1st image: A double copckit ship with the body of Tantive? Or Actualy we see the back of the ship and its something like the MF in the mc quarrie's concepts (the one that had One cockpit)
2nd image: A tantive something corvete with no of the 8 engines.
3rd image: The same ship from the 1st image in a different angle. Now reminds more the jedi cruiser in the start of TMP with 2 engines instead of 3.
4th image: A B-Wing? Or a unidentified ship in a weird angle?
5th image: This looks more like the Bug like ship that the separatists have. with the Big wing in the middle.
Any source confirms these as desings?
-Angel
Ady. At the Fleet shots Little ships in the background was like garbage elements similar to those the star destroyer throw up and nothing was clear. Was ever established what was these ships (models/ size etc)
Will you try to recreate them or adding the most known ships in larger numbers?
-Angel
There is an other thing trying to keep the nostalgia/"how i saw it when i was 8"/classic-iconic moment and other trying to comunicate artistically and give to the audience something to bother.
The point is not this even can be explained scientificly but visually correct. Since ady stated that he is not gonna touch it for the first reasons then there you have it.
-Angel
I can say if you put some planets or moons that overlap a bit the new born star it will set the scale and that its not and sell the idea that its not a galaxy at the end.
-Angel
Maybe a more dramatic version of the poor ROTJ's briefing room.
Far more interesting lighted and colored while keeping a nice mood and an OT feel.
-Angel
Damn i was late...
Heck, I have recreations of Ady's blade settings and colors.
Which is?
-Angel
It has a pylon yes.
I think it has red circular lights but indeed its a pylon.
-Angel
Well i didnt want having issues like the new starfield in the alien movie. They put the exact same pattern in two sequential shots having the ship looks like it was a pasted element over a cardboard.
Watching what ady doing with variations in the shots it would pity having issues like these in the future
-Angel
Good to listen that ady :)
I had that feeling that you were using the same starfield that you were using as pattern in ANH:R (dont mention the previous debates about visible similarities of the pattern)
-Angel
Quick question.
Is there any particular reason why ady used/using the same starfields in both episodes so far, at most if not all space shots?
Is there any philosophy or trademark or credit behind this decision?
Just for the sake of difference isnt the starfields being randomly placed/generated in each space shot?
-Angel
Put Captain Solo in the Cargo Hold said:
That industrial part of Coruscant where Dookie flies at the end of Attack of the Clones, it's never seen or mentioned again in the series. Palpatine and Maul could have their conversation in that zone.
Already done that ;)
-Angel
doubleofive said:
I think he told me that tripped walker will either go down later or be up in the end.
Don't worry about continuity, he's got you covered.
You know something dont you? ;)
-Berry
True.
But still i dont get shot by shot solutions.
Thats the real trick isnt it ;)
For example to make more clear to you. The helicopter bug shot could be removed and have a static shot of kashyyk with some distant traffic.
Or instead of flybys cut directly to close ups of the actors...
-Angel
BmB said:
Secondly, I don't know wtf is up with the shading on Cloud City. I know it's from one of the old mattes? But it's not a particularly good matte TBH. The way it is lit it would have to be... well, almost paper thin actually.
http://media.giantbomb.com/uploads/0/118/673913-cloud_city_large.jpg
If you see here this matte has a lot better shading with a small but smooth transitional band from direct sunlight to ambient light, which is generally how round things shade when they are matte. And the shot should probably be updated to better reflect the circular nature of the beast.
You can take a taste of a more realistic shadowing and color grading as the sun moves in all directions :)
-Angel
Edited
Lets see:
If you could have a choice of making ROTS as OT as possible visually, what would be the aspects that you could change,remove,replace,disenhance,CC...etc?
Lets take the example of the SE of ESB and the extended bespin/twin cloud car with the fancy fly scenes. Pre SE it was only a static matte that had a slight zoom to leia's window.
Considering that, how you think will be the more suitable approach to many many fancy shots of ROTS can be toned down while keeping the same running time? Trimming and cutting out shots is not the best option everytime, otherwise you could have a 30min movie at the end.
Ideas for shot replacement is welcome in shots you think its unberable fake and CGI or you think an other movie has better CG that can sell the concept better than ROTS.
The only restriction to all the above is: Think if your suggested idea is doable!
If you got ideas/ suggestions/ mockups on specific shots please share.
-Angel
Busy
tko54321 said:
I always felt these weren't shown launching the important fatal blows to the Death Star in the original version of "A New Hope" due to budgetary or time constraints. And I hoped they would be shown in the SE or in the "Revisited" fan edit/reconstruction, but they weren't.
New shot(s) of them launching would give a great reference point for the difficulty of the shot on the target as well as show where the heck they're coming from. So that's my challenge to everyone out there creating new edits of the movie.
Oh, and replace those dopey shots of TV switcher controls for the Death Star firing sequences. Takes you right out of the movie.
Excellent!
You can post your radical ideas for ANH here.
More radical more welcome :)
-Angel
My Eyes are burning.
The topic title is indeed "Now it's just getting ridiculous- Yoda's new CGI look."
Why this was gone offtopic about obiwan and about a weird howl?
;)
-Berry
doubleofive said:
There! for those who mentioned that yoda is only angry in PT. This is might the only photo from the Muppet gimmick that might give a reason for the ILMers to prove their efforts.
A-Man posted:
It's not already seamless?
No its not ;)
-Angel
If they are going to change the audio so radical i suggest to make a seamless vader voice to all episodes :)
-Angel
Hahaha! XD
-Angel