rchdggr said:
[...] That is very OT to me. A regular guy. In the PT the heroes were anything but regular guys.
I don't think I've ever really thought about that before, but it's true. I think that's one of the reasons people relate to the OT heroes so much more easily than those of the PT. Of course none of them were ordinary in the end, but they all had fairly mundane origins, Leia being the notable exception. Even she, however, was easy to relate to because she seemed normal, as if she had had a normal upbringing and had just happened to be a princess.
Now, if we contrast Leia with Padmé, there's a marked difference. Likewise, Anakin has an extraordinary life, going from a slave with incredible talents to a famous and powerful Jedi to a Sith Lord. Most of the main characters have superpowers, or are politicians, or are both. The ordinary people are either aliens who are next to impossible to relate to (take Jar Jar, for example) or have only minor or background roles.
The PT also focused too much on the wrong side of life. Star Wars was never about the politics, even though we could see they existed in the background, but the PT brought that into the forefront. We saw too much of the Jedi and learned too much of what they believed and taught for them to be cool or interesting anymore. It would have been better to see them more from the outside, or to focus on a small number of them, with the others being more in the background.
Ah, well, yet another area of the PT that went wrong, which makes the possibility of making something good out of it seem still less likely.