I’m posting this mainly to see if there is anyone else out there who feels the way I do about TFA, I haven’t read/watched any reviews yet but the 95% on RT kind of surprised me. I’m not trying to rain on the parade at all here – I really wanted to like this movie – but to me it was disappointing. I’m actually kind of jealous of those who really loved it.
Cons:
I did not buy any of the major relationships at all, to me this was by far the biggest failing of the movie. Finn/Rey, Finn/Poe, shockingly even Leia/Han. They all felt extremely forced and came across as trying REALLY hard to recapture the chemistry of the Big 3 in the OT. When Poe and Finn rush to embrace after Finn sees him for the first time alive, I was kind of taken aback because to me they just hadn’t “gotten there” yet, so it just came off as weird. I don’t know what the problem was, the acting, the script, or some elusive, hard-to-quantify, movie magic thing.
The whole movie felt like a point-for-point rehash of Star Wars/ANH – a few nods here and there are cool and would be expected, but TFA went way beyond that. I’m honestly pretty surprised that this script was OK-ed because it is so blatant in parts. Just a few examples:
-The fact that once again a critical bit of info is given to a droid who is left to his (its?) own devices – said droid is then taken hostage by desert scavengers before being “rescued” by the protagonist.
-All of the ball turret scenes on the Falcon.
-A “scoundrel” type character that makes snarky remarks and likes to use his ship’s undercarriage gun to blast baddies while trying to escape.
-Death Star 3 (I’m REALLY surprised they went with this as I thought it was a common problem that people have with ROTJ)
-Cantina scene
Due to the above (and more I didn’t mention) I frequently had the feeling that I was watching a straight up second rate remake.
Last major problem I had with the movie was that it was just not subtle AT ALL. The worst example being the scenes setting up Finn to leave the First Order. I could practically hear JJ yelling into my ear “HE’S CONFLICTED ABOUT WHAT IS GOING ON RIGHT NOW! LOOK AT HIS FACIAL EXPRESSIONS! – CAN YOU TELL HE IS CONFLICTED? IN CASE YOU COULDN’T – LET ME SPELL IT OUT FOR YOU – THIS CHARACTER IS VERY CONFLICTED!!!”
There were also a few really bad exposition scenes where it felt like characters were just vomiting up important plot points because the script couldn’t think of a more clever way to explain the story.
Ok so enough of the bad, there were some parts of this movie that I did really dig:
-Every scene with Snoke was great. What an awesome character design. When he first came up on screen I was just blown away – the hologram-making-him-seem-huge trick was a stroke of genius, though part of me wishes he really was that big.
-Lightsaber duels following more after the style that Luke and Vader have at the end of ROTJ (i.e. passionate hacking that looks like they are really trying to kill each other). The only problem was I couldn’t get emotionally wrapped up in them in the same way because again, I just did not buy the character relationships.
-Some very cool landscapes: my three favorites being the backdrop as Rey “sandboards” down a dune, the Snoke “throne room”, and the bridge where Han bites it.
-The vision sequences when Rey picks up Luke’s lightsaber were pure awesome.
So to conclude, for me this movie failed, though in a different way from the prequels. Say what you want about the prequels (I am not a fan at all either – not trying to stir the pot here – just want to give some context to my views), but George did not “play it safe” and rehash the OT at all. And as much as the prequels suffer from general “woodenness”, I found TFA’s character relationships even less convincing (excluding Anakin/Padme).
Still hopeful for VIII though, but now I’m probably looking forward to Rogue One more. And I did still have a good time at the movies — getting to see the OT on the big screen for the first time was a treat (I’m one of those people that shelled out for ~14 straight hours of Star Wars 😛)