Density said:
Well Rey going dark would also be a rehash of the Vader plot
Only if it’s done is exactly the same way. Remember that Star Wars is bigger than the films and in many Star Wars stories people fall to the Dark Side.
The whole “come to the Dark Side, we have cookies” thing has gotten stale.
Not if you factor in that Palpatine used the fear of loss to make Anakin his apprentice and in ROTJ Palpatine was pretty much just saying “Your friends will die” over and over again. We haven’t actually seen a proper “seduction” to the Dark Side in the films.
We also need our protagonist to remain the moral center. Be challenged, yes, and they don’t necessarily have to be goody two-shoes, but they shouldn’t go full blown evil. Rey should be like Luke in that regard.
Wouldn’t that be a rehash of Luke’s plot?
As for Kylo being redeemed, I don’t really want to see that either. Like you said it would be a rehash of Vader.
Only if he dies.
If they pulled it off very carefully that could actually be one parallel that works, in that it might tie everything together by making the theme of it never being too late for redemption the central theme of Star Wars.
I’m okay with poetry but there has to be a different reason for him turning and his redemption moment would have to be different from Vader’s.
But surely there still could be a more interesting and unique direction to take his character. I’m just not sure what that would be.
Other than making him a Grey Force Wielder I can’t see anything entirely new they can do with him.