Small update:
https://www.facebook.com/swrevisited/posts/pfbid032sYpooAxmCTRpv5oiB1R85hovMc4C8CxytJw9PwSEWZmK4DgwfzTdhLeoMTyn2Dfl
Grand Admiral Thrawn said:
Ady, great work as usual!
Not to be a Negative Nancy, but the exiting hyperspace scene just feels a bit out of place in ANH. I know there were new effects made for the Falcon flying in TESB, but to be honest those just felt more natural when slotted in. I could be wrong here, but I don’t believe we ever see a ship in or exiting hyperspace out of the tunnel in either the OT or the PT.
Maybe something similar to the Star Destroyer’s arrival in Rogue One would be better here?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8b2XYfpvEa0
Well in the PT we don’t see any ship in hyperspace as far as i can remember, but we do in the OT. And then we see the ships in the tunnel in the ST. So none of the trilogies gel together in that respect. I’ve done that “coming out of hyperspace” effect earlier on in the film when the stardestroyer reaches the Death Star. I want something visually different
.Mac. said:
I’m not speaking for Ady, so he can correct me if I’m wrong, but what I understand he’s trying to do is make the 3 OT films feel visually consistent with one another. Since ANH is the oldest of the three, that might mean it’ll be getting a little extra polish here and there.
You’re completely right .Mac . Now i’m not bothered about the revisited edits working in respect to the PT ( i just can’t watch them any more), but i do like the ST & Rogue One. So, even though nothing i do would really contradict the PT, i’m not worried about anything i do affecting them either.
Grand Admiral Thrawn said:
ThiscouldbeR2D2 said:
That was done in the original version of ANH:R.
Sorry for the confusion, the work of it “in the tunnel” while Leia and Han talk that was done for the OG Revisited looks great, as do the effects when Han and Luke talk.
I was strictly talking about the reused/updated shot that appears to have been used from ROS when the Falcon is exiting hyperspace.
The hyperspace exit is something i wanted to do when i first did ANH:H. But back then the resources just weren’t available all the way back then. the CG models just weren’t available and doing a shot like this at home would have been virtually impossible. So i just did it the only way i could back then.
One thing that can be jarring is that you are use to a scene playing out a certain way and something new can throw you out. But what i think is also contributing to this is the sound. In the original we get an abrupt loud engine sound, while in the new version it is softer and more gradual. Also this shot was not created using any reused footage from ROTS or any of the sequels. The falcon was rendered by Andreas , who is doing the CG work for me and the tunnel was taken from Ahsoka TV show, which was originally a static shot but i manipulated it to give the sweeping camera effect.
Jar Jar Bricks said:
I feel like it wouldn’t stick out as much if you put more clips of the same VFX caliber throughout the movie. Such as this, for example (with permission of course):
https://youtu.be/3cXYN-XBpkM?si=8up3ja5VOmlo-Lkk
Ady’s shot is amazing, no doubt, I just think that you have to approach viewing this edit as if it were a true SE re-release with modern effects in certain places.
I’m not sure what you mean here. There are new modern effects throughout these edits. That’s the whole point of them. In fact none of the effect shots in that sequence haven’t been altered or replaced with modern effects, with the shot of the falcon right after the exit from hyperspace being a newly CG rendered shot.
