Rogue One * Spoilers * Thread — Page 48

dahmage said:

DuracellEnergizer said:

dahmage said:

ZkinandBonez said:

ray_afraid said:

ZkinandBonez said:

ray_afraid said:

ZkinandBonez said:

It firing on Scarif would be pretty weird. But then again that’s the sort of crazy thing that the Empire might do.

I thought when they destroy Alderaan in SW that it was the first time the superlaser was used.

Well, the RO trailer does show the DS firing on Jedha. However the super laser is most likely not fully operational at this point, hence it doesn’t blow up the entire planet and instead just causes a lot of destruction. I guess they did this in RO so that the DS can still be a big threat to the main characters without undermining ANH. Alderaan was simply the first test of the “fully operational” DS and its planet destroying capabilities. In RO it seem to only be capable of blowing up a city-sized area.

Ugh…

Why “ugh”? Like SilverWook said, it makes sense for them to test the unfinished laser. Also since the plot of RO seem to revolve around Kyber crystals from Jedha and Galen’s expertise on them, it makes sense that they would have a weaker laser during this film.

Also ANH characters constantly bragging about the “fully armed and operatinal” DS does mean that it should be unfinished in RO. It’d be silly if it just hovered over some planet all the time doing nothing.

this has mostly been my take as well. that shot from the trailer almost certainly is the death star in some low power mode / not working mode. and if it isn’t the death star, i would be slightly annoyed that there is some other amazing weapon we never heard of…

Expeditionary Battle Planetoid?

Death Star prototype?

Nocturnô?

Unidentified test unit Death Star?

i don’t know any EU stuff, but wouldn’t it be really confusing to have any of those introduced in a movie that is all about the death star?

Well it’s definitely the DS firing on Jedha in the trailer.

And it seems like they borrowed the idea of a low power test shot from Legends; https://youtu.be/O64vg5xEhkw?t=24

However it seems very unlikely that it’ll actually destroy Jedha (or any other planet), but rather that it will simply burn a pretty big hole into it. Essentially it will destroy just enough to be a big threat in the plot of this movie without contradicting or detracting from the plot of ANH.

Ronster said:

ZkinandBonez said:

Well, it could be that we only see the DS over Jedha. Since it’s already in ANH there’s no need for it to appear throughout the entire movie, especially since Scarif is where they steal the plans.
I guess it could show up at the very end though, but it sees weird that the DS would be needed at Scarif. It firing on Scarif would be pretty weird. But then again that’s the sort of crazy thing that the Empire might do.

I have a feeling that the plot will revolve around three missions; sabotaging some Kyber crystal mining on Jedha (or at least getting some info). The DS shows up to stop them and cover it’s tracks. Then they go to try to save Galen from Eadu. Perhaps they get some info from him there. And finally with this info they go to steal the plans on Scarif. That’s my guess anyway.

As for the early marketing teaser, well, that could simply be marketing. They would have had good reason to avoid spoilers at that time. I also think it was made even before they started shooting, so it could have been based on some early ideas. Also the teaser did show a jungle, and Scarif is in all the trailers shown has having many oceans/lakes with small jungle areas as opposed to the thick jungle shown in the teaser.

Ok so the Planet in the Flash Back is called LAH’MU

And you are right zkinandbonez EADU is the blue misty mountain planet. (Could it be a mistake and it is actually Eriadu? That is Moff Tarkins home world heavily polluted industrial planet)

I also think that SCARIF is also where the dish is fitted so the Death star will move after it get’s fitted on to Jedha.

Check this map

Yes,it does seem like Scarif will be the place where the DS got constructed, or at least partially constructed, after it left Geonosis. However it seem unlikely that it would return to Scarif after going to Jedha, as Scarif is definitely at the end of the film.

In that map however it doesn’t indicate that the DS went to Jedha at all however. Which is weird

That pic of the X-Wings with headlights on is cool!

Yeah, aside from a shot of Luke’s X Wing in the Dagobah swamp, I don’t think we ever saw that in the OT. We saw the lights on Yoda’s face when it took off though.

SilverWook said:

Yeah, aside from a shot of Luke’s X Wing in the Dagobah swamp, I don’t think we ever saw that in the OT. We saw the lights on Yoda’s face when it took off though.

I imagine that would have been very hard to pull off with miniatures and old blue-screen effects. At least convincingly anyhow.

Ronster said:

I have a feeling Lah’mu and Eadu are fake names one of them (Eadu) being Eriadu gran moff Tarkin’s home world.

Fake names?

adywan said:

Finally, a clear shot of Rogue One’s Darth Vader. So it seems that he will swap between having his inner tunic under the chest plate to over it throughout the movie. And the lenses don’t look red here either, like they did in the trailers.

Is there photographic evidence of the alternative?

This new TV spot has a very different take on the “I rebel” line; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AElDp0ArdRw

Anyone still holding out for an Emperor cameo? I’m aware McDiarmid publicly denied involvement with the movie, but I wonder if he’ll still make a surprise appearance in the end.

Where Are Death Troopers, U-Wings, and TIE Strikers in the Original Trilogy?

I though this was a pretty interesting speculation video on how the Lucasfilm story group is going to justify all the new ships and troopers not having been seen in the OT.

Ronster said:

ZkinandBonez said:

Well, it could be that we only see the DS over Jedha. Since it’s already in ANH there’s no need for it to appear throughout the entire movie, especially since Scarif is where they steal the plans.
I guess it could show up at the very end though, but it sees weird that the DS would be needed at Scarif. It firing on Scarif would be pretty weird. But then again that’s the sort of crazy thing that the Empire might do.

I have a feeling that the plot will revolve around three missions; sabotaging some Kyber crystal mining on Jedha (or at least getting some info). The DS shows up to stop them and cover it’s tracks. Then they go to try to save Galen from Eadu. Perhaps they get some info from him there. And finally with this info they go to steal the plans on Scarif. That’s my guess anyway.

As for the early marketing teaser, well, that could simply be marketing. They would have had good reason to avoid spoilers at that time. I also think it was made even before they started shooting, so it could have been based on some early ideas. Also the teaser did show a jungle, and Scarif is in all the trailers shown has having many oceans/lakes with small jungle areas as opposed to the thick jungle shown in the teaser.

Ok so the Planet in the Flash Back is called LAH’MU

And you are right zkinandbonez EADU is the blue misty mountain planet. (Could it be a mistake and it is actually Eriadu? That is Moff Tarkins home world heavily polluted industrial planet)

I also think that SCARIF is also where the dish is fitted so the Death star will move after it get’s fitted on to Jedha.

Check this map

I have so many questions about this map.

Is it canon that Geonosis is the nearest neighboring planet to Tatooine? Was Tatooine able to avoid being involved (for the most part) being involved in either of these massive galactic wars because of The Hutts? Why was there not a greater imperial presence on Tatooine BEFORE whatever is about to happen on Scarif? Furthermore, why would smugglers like Han Solo make stops on a planet that is nearly on the doorstep of a major Imperial installation?

I know Luke’s feeling of isolation was largely because of his lot in life but retconn’ing Geonosis (the first major battle of the Clone Wars) and Scarif (a major military installation for the Empire) to being the 3 closest planets in the Star Wars universe makes Obi Wan’s decision to hide Luke there seem even more unfortunate.

I guess I also did not realize just how close Hoth was to Bespin (although that makes sense since hyperdrive was out). It appears to be closer than the 2nd Death Star was to Endor moon.

Jeddha’s proximity to Jakku is interesting, too.

Sorry, this is wandering off from my original points which were closer to Rogue One.

Well, just remember that “close” is quite relative when dealing with a map that covers an entire galaxy.

ZkinandBonez said:

Well, just remember that “close” is quite relative when dealing with a map that covers an entire galaxy.

Yeah, I get that. It is just further shrinks the Star Wars galaxy. I understand the need to have Scarif near Tatooine in order for the events of ANH to kick off.

I’m beginning to wonder if Disney has in mind an update Special Edition that fixes the 90’s special effects added and increases the amount of starfighters/Imperial fighters scattered throughout ANH. Especially with how much Disney is trying to tie-in all their other materials (Clone Wars/Rebels/etc.)

Will be interesting to see how they clean it all up at the end of Rogue One.

Hardcore Legend said:

ZkinandBonez said:

Well, just remember that “close” is quite relative when dealing with a map that covers an entire galaxy.

Yeah, I get that. It is just further shrinks the Star Wars galaxy. I understand the need to have Scarif near Tatooine in order for the events of ANH to kick off.

Well, it isn’t exactly a very detailed map. There’s definitely a lot of planets in between the ones that’s listed. I imagine that the SW galaxy, much like our own, has billions of planets in it. And only a very, very small amount of those are populated, and of course the future of the EU will undoubtedly introduce many new worlds, so many simply remain ‘unnamed’. So it’s not exactly like Tatooine and Geonosis are just sitting there is space next to each other. And even if that was the case, the space between them would still be too vast for anyone on each planet to really care about the other, unless they specifically had a reason to travel there. But, again, the map above only lists the most relevant planets to casual SW fans (most of them are movie locations, with a few species- or TV-relevant worlds). I mean just look at this map from Legends canon.